Holding Chambers (spacers) Versus Nebulisers For Beta-agonist Treatment Of Acute Asthma.
C. Cates, Emma J Welsh, B. Rowe
Published 2013 · Medicine
Download PDFAnalyze on Scholarcy
BACKGROUND In acute asthma inhaled beta(2)-agonists are often administered by nebuliser to relieve bronchospasm, but some have argued that metered-dose inhalers with a holding chamber (spacer) can be equally effective. Nebulisers require a power source and need regular maintenance, and are more expensive in the community setting. OBJECTIVES To assess the effects of holding chambers (spacers) compared to nebulisers for the delivery of beta(2)-agonists for acute asthma. SEARCH METHODS We searched the Cochrane Airways Group Trial Register and reference lists of articles. We contacted the authors of studies to identify additional trials. Date of last search: February 2013. SELECTION CRITERIA Randomised trials in adults and children (from two years of age) with asthma, where spacer beta(2)-agonist delivery was compared with wet nebulisation. DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS Two review authors independently applied study inclusion criteria (one review author for the first version of the review), extracted the data and assessed risks of bias. Missing data were obtained from the authors or estimated. Results are reported with 95% confidence intervals (CIs). MAIN RESULTS This review includes a total of 1897 children and 729 adults in 39 trials. Thirty-three trials were conducted in the emergency room and equivalent community settings, and six trials were on inpatients with acute asthma (207 children and 28 adults). The method of delivery of beta(2)-agonist did not show a significant difference in hospital admission rates. In adults, the risk ratio (RR) of admission for spacer versus nebuliser was 0.94 (95% CI 0.61 to 1.43). The risk ratio for children was 0.71 (95% CI 0.47 to 1.08, moderate quality evidence). In children, length of stay in the emergency department was significantly shorter when the spacer was used. The mean duration in the emergency department for children given nebulised treatment was 103 minutes, and for children given treatment via spacers 33 minutes less (95% CI -43 to -24 minutes, moderate quality evidence). Length of stay in the emergency department for adults was similar for the two delivery methods. Peak flow and forced expiratory volume were also similar for the two delivery methods. Pulse rate was lower for spacer in children, mean difference -5% baseline (95% CI -8% to -2%, moderate quality evidence), as was the risk of developing tremor (RR 0.64; 95% CI 0.44 to 0.95, moderate quality evidence). AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS Nebuliser delivery produced outcomes that were not significantly better than metered-dose inhalers delivered by spacer in adults or children, in trials where treatments were repeated and titrated to the response of the participant. Spacers may have some advantages compared to nebulisers for children with acute asthma.
This paper references
Barriers to metered-dose inhaler/spacer use in Canadian pediatric emergency departments: a national survey.
M. Osmond (2007)
Inhalation therapy in asthma: nebulizer or pressurized metered-dose inhaler with holding chamber? In vivo comparison of lung deposition in children.
J. Wildhaber (1999)
An open, prospective comparison of beta 2 agonists given via nebuliser, Nebuhaler, or pressurised inhaler by ambulance crew as emergency treatment.
I. Campbell (1995)
A comparison of albuterol administered by metered-dose inhaler and spacer with albuterol by nebulizer in adults presenting to an urban emergency department with acute asthma.
K. B. Newman (2002)
Effect of bronchodilator therapy administered by canister versus jet nebulizer.
C. Shim (1984)
Comparison of metered-dose inhaler attached to an Aerochamber with an updraft nebulizer for the administration of metaproterenol in hospitalized patients.
M. J. Berenberg (1985)
Efficacy and safety of a home‐made non‐valved spacer for bronchodilator therapy in acute asthma
M. Duarte (2002)
Cumulative dose-response study comparing terbutaline pressurized aerosol administered via a pearshaped spacer and terbutaline in a nebulized solution
E. Birk Madsen (1982)
Comparison of salbutamol delivered by nebulizer or metered-dose inhaler with a pear-shaped spacer in acute asthma
G. Rodrigo (1993)
Treatment of acute asthma: Salbutamol via jet nebuliser vs spacer and metered dose inhaler
C. Robertson (1998)
Salbutamol treatment of acute severe asthma in the ED: MDI versus hand-held nebulizer.
C. Rodrigo (1998)
Experience with a metered-dose inhaler with a spacer in the pediatric emergency department.
G. Benton (1989)
Aerosolized metaproterenol in the treatment of asthmatics with severe airflow obstruction. Comparison of two delivery methods.
G. Salzman (1989)
High- versus low-dose, frequently administered nebulized albuterol in children with severe, acute asthma
Julie M. Mazurek (1990)
[Different inhaler devices in acute asthma attacks: a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study].
H. C. Chong Neto (2005)
Assessing the quality of reports of randomised controlled trials: is blinding necessary
A Jadad 1996 Jadad (1996)
Single breath versus panting technique in salbutamol delivery through a 750 mL spacing device.
R. James (1990)
Metered dose inhaler and nebuliser in acute asthma.
Y. Z. Lin (1995)
Diferentes dispositivos inalatórios na crise aguda de asma: um estudo randomizado, duplo-cego e controlado com placebo
H. C. Neto (2005)
Cost-benefit comparison of aerosol bronchodilator delivery methods in hospitalized patients.
A. Jasper (1987)
Delivery of albuterol in a pediatric emergency department
J. Williams (1996)
Inalador dosimetrado com espaçador artesanal versus nebulizador no tratamento da crise de sibilância na criança
Liana Consuelo Santana Vilarinho (2003)
Salbutamol inhalado o nebulizado en el tratamiento de la exacerbación aguda del asma en el preescolar. Estudio comparativo aleatorizado.
M. L. Chávez (1999)
British Guideline on the Management of Asthma
G. Douglas (2008)
Comparación entre salbutamol administrado por inhaladores de dosis medida con espaciador vs nebulizado en ninos con asma aguda
M. L. M. Alanís (1997)
Nebuhaler versus nebuliser in children with acute asthma.
M. Freelander (1984)
A randomised controlled trial to assess the relative benefits of large volume spacers and nebulisers to treat acute asthma in hospital
A. Dewar (1999)
High-Dose Albuterol by Metered-Dose Inhaler Plus a Spacer Device Versus Nebulization in Preschool Children With Recurrent Wheezing: A Double-Blind, Randomized Equivalence Trial
D. Ploin (2000)
GLOBAL STRATEGY FOR ASTHMA MANAGEMENT AND PREVENTION
R. Pauwels (1996)
Emergency department treatment of severe asthma. Metered-dose inhaler plus holding chamber is equivalent in effectiveness to nebulizer.
A. Idris (1993)
Metered-dose inhalers with spacers vs nebulizers for pediatric asthma.
K. Chou (1995)
Randomised trial spacer v nebuliser for acute asthma.
P. Parkin (1995)
Fortes doses de salbutamol par aérosol doseur et chambre d’inhalation chez les nourrissons et les jeunes enfants siffleurs
D. Ploin (2001)
High-versus low-dose, frequently administered, nebulized albuterol in children with severe, acute asthma.
S. Schuh (1989)
Pear shaped spacer nebuhaler compared with nebulised solution for terbutaline administration in acute severe asthma.
Beasley Cr (1985)
Corticosteroids for preventing relapse following acute exacerbations of asthma.
B. Rowe (2000)
Improvement of pressurised aerosol deposition with Nebuhaler spacer device.
S. Newman (1984)
Efficacy and cost comparisons of bronchodilatator administration between metered dose inhalers with disposable spacers and nebulizers for acute asthma treatment.
S. Dhuper (2011)
Is nebulized aerosol treatment necessary in the pediatric emergency department?
A. Mandelberg (2000)
Repeat Dosing of Albuterol via Metered-Dose Inhaler in Infants With Acute Obstructive Airway Disease: A Randomized Controlled Safety Trial
Mohammed Kaashmiri (2010)
Violence in the Accident and Emergency Department
S. P. Cembrowicz (1992)
Comparative trial of continuous nebulization versus metered-dose inhaler in the treatment of acute bronchospasm.
M. Levitt (1995)
Comparison between efficacy of MDI+spacer and nebuliser in the management of acute asthma in children.
M. Fayaz (2009)
[Metered-dose inhalers with home-made spacers versus nebulizers to treat moderate wheezing attacks in children].
Liana Consuelo Santana Vilarinho (2003)
Management of acute asthma in children using metered dose inhaler and small volume nebulizer.
S. W. Jamalvi (2006)
[Hospital emergency rooms].
P. Tudela (2003)
Traitement aux urgences des crises d’asthme par nébulisations versus chambres d’inhalation☆
N. Sannier (2007)
Comparative efficacy of terbutaline administered by Nebuhaler and by nebulizer in young children with acute asthma.
J. Pendergast (1989)
Comparison of a hand-held nebulizer with a metered dose inhaler-spacer combination in acute obstructive pulmonary disease.
G. Maguire (1991)
Nebulized wet aerosol treatment in emergency department--is it essential? Comparison with large spacer device for metered-dose inhaler.
A. Mandelberg (1997)
Efficacy of salbutamol by nebulizer versus metered dose inhaler with home-made non-valved spacer in acute exacerbation of childhood asthma.
Shahina Yasmin (2012)
Assessing the quality of reports of randomized clinical trials: is blinding necessary?
A. Jadad (1996)
M. Edwards (2005)
A comparative study of efficacy of salbutamol via metered dose inhaler with volumatic spacer and via dry powder inhaler, easyhaler, to nebulization in mild to moderate severity acute asthma exacerbation in childhood.
Mukda Vangveeravong (2008)
Comparison of treatment of acute asthma attacks in children with salbutamol dispensed by the Volumatic dispenser or by a nebulizer
C. VázquezCordero (1992)
Metered dose inhaler salbutamol treatment of asthma in the ED: comparison of two doses with plasma levels.
G. Rodrigo (1996)
A comparison of albuterol administered by metered dose inhaler (and holding chamber) or wet nebulizer in acute asthma.
A. Colacone (1993)
A Comparative Study of Efficacy of Salbutamol via Metered Dose Inhaler (MDI) with Volumatic Spacer and via Dry Powder Inhaler (DPI), Easyhaler, to Nebulization in Mild to Moderate Severity Acute Asthma Exacerbation in Children
Chaiyan Sirikul (2008)
Comparison of Nebuhaler and nebulizer treatment of acute severe asthma in children.
G. Fuglsang (1986)
Nebuhaler technique. British Journal of Diseases of the Chest 1988;82:172–4
Gleeson 1988 Gleeson JGA (1988)
[Bronchodilation induced by fenoterol in asthmatic patients: comparison of jet nebulization and spacer device].
N. Morrone (1990)
Costs and effectiveness of spacer versus nebulizer in young children with moderate and severe acute asthma.
A. Leversha (2000)
Wet nebulizer versus spacer and metered dose inhaler via tidal breathing.
M. Ba (1989)
Efficacy of albuterol administered by nebulizer versus spacer device in children with acute asthma.
E. Kerem (1993)
Comparison of beta-adrenergic agents delivered by nebulizer vs metered dose inhaler with InspirEase in hospitalized asthmatic patients.
T. F. Morley (1988)
Randomized controlled trial of salbutamol aerosol therapy via metered dose inhaler-spacer vs. jet nebulizer in young children with wheezing.
J. Deerojanawong (2005)
Holding chambers versus nebulisers for beta-agonist treatment of acute asthma.
C. Cates (2002)
Effects of airway calibre on lung delivery of nebulised salbutamol.
B. Lipworth (1997)
Treatment of acute severe asthma with inhaled albuterol delivered via jet nebulizer, metered dose inhaler with spacer, or dry powder.
A. Raimondi (1997)
Aerosol bronchodilator delivery methods. Relative impact on pulmonary function and cost of respiratory care.
W. Summer (1989)
Randomized trial of salbutamol via metered-dose inhaler with spacer versus nebulizer for acute wheezing in children less than 2 years of age.
L. Rubilar (2000)
Terbutaline aerosol given through pear spacer in acute severe asthma.
M. D. Morgan (1982)
Comparison of salbutamol efficacy in children--via the metered-dose inhaler (MDI) with Volumatic spacer and via the dry powder inhaler, Easyhaler, with the nebulizer--in mild to moderate asthma exacerbation: a multicenter, randomized study.
Chalerat Direkwatanachai (2011)
Successful implementation of spacer treatment guideline for acute asthma
C. Powell (2001)
Bronchodilator delivery in acute airflow obstruction. A meta-analysis.
M. O. Turner (1997)
Comparative efficacy of salbutamol by pressurized aerosol and wet nebulizer in acute asthma.
R. Tarala (1980)
Comparative efficacy of jet nebulizer and metered dose inhaler with spacer device in the treatment of acute asthma.
V. Batra (1997)
Equivalence of continuous flow nebulizer and metered-dose inhaler with reservoir bag for treatment of acute airflow obstruction.
J. Turner (1988)
Clinical Investigations: COPDNebulized Wet Aerosol Treatment in Emergency Department—Is It Essential?: Comparison With Large Spacer Device for Metered-Dose Inhaler
Avigdor Mandelberg (1997)
Relative amount of albuterol delivered to lung receptors from a metered-dose inhaler and nebulizer solution. Bioassay by histamine bronchoprovocation.
K. Blake (1992)
This paper is referenced by
Acute Severe Asthma in Adolescent and Adult Patients: Current Perspectives on Assessment and Management
E. Kostakou (2019)
The Evolution of Spacers and Valved Holding Chambers
ДОСТАВКА ПРЕПАРАТОВ В ЛЕГКИЕ: ПРОБЛЕМНЫЕ АСПЕКТЫ
В. В. Архипов (2011)
[Asthma: treatment of exacerbations].
M. Lubret (2012)
Which Device in Asthma ?
Improving treatment of asthma attacks in children
A. Bush (2017)
CQ6 Are pMDIs with spacers more effective than nebulizers in the multiple-dose inhalation of beta2-agonists for treating acute asthma exacerbation in children?
Mayumi Sugimoto (2017)
Der schwere lebensbedrohliche Asthmaanfall
G.-S. Haarmeyer (2018)
Missed opportunities to transition from nebulizers to inhalers during hospitalization for acute asthma: A multicenter observational study
V. Press (2017)
Emergency MDI and spacer packs for asthma and COPD.
D. Keeley (2019)
Acute asthma, prognosis, and treatment
Jennifer E. Fergeson (2017)
Response to Review Regarding Cost Analysis of Salbutamol Administration
Paul Spin (2017)
EVIDENCE-BASED BEST PRACTICES FOR THE MANAGEMENT OF ASTHMA IN PEDIATRIC PRIMARY CARE
In South Carolina (2015)
Recomendaciones prácticas para el manejo de la crisis asmática en pacientes adultos
G. Menga (2015)
Asthma 2 Diagnosis, management, and prognosis of preschool wheeze
F. Ducharme (2014)
What the pulmonary specialist should know about the new inhalation therapies
H.M. Janssens (2012)
Evaluating a clinical practice intervention to promote delivery of salbutamol by metered-dose inhalers with holding chambers in a pediatric emergency department.
Barbara Hill-Taylor (2013)
Aerosoles: fármacos y los dispositivos para su administración
A. Cortés-Telles (2013)
Zasady stosowania komór inhalacyjnych u dzieci
A. Emeryk (2017)
Minimising the environmental impact of inhaled therapies: problems with policy on low carbon inhalers
D. Keeley (2020)
A Guide for Pediatric Emergency Medicine Providers
Sarah Kline-Krammes (2013)
Combined Inhaled Anticholinergics and Short-Acting Beta2-Agonists for Initial Treatment of Acute Asthma in Children Terapêutica Combinada Inalatória com Anticolinérgicos e Beta2-Agonistas de Curta Ação no Tratamento Inicial da Asma Aguda em Crianças
Manuel Ferreira-Magalhães (2015)
Inhaled therapy in asthma
Vicente Plaza Moral (2016)
[The implementation gap in asthma prevention and control?].
Pascal Demoly (2014)
Advances in the aetiology, management, and prevention of acute asthma attacks in children.
S. Saglani (2019)
Cochrane review - in their own words
C. Cates (2013)
Principal findings of systematic reviews of acute asthma treatment in childhood
J. Castro-Rodriguez (2015)
Le traitement de la crise d’asthme de l’enfant aux urgences basé sur des données probantes : utopie ou réalité ?
Fm Ducharme (2012)
Guideline for the management of acute asthma in adults: 2013 update.
U. Lalloo (2012)
Management of Acute Loss of Asthma Control: The Yellow Zone
Karen Rance (2016)
Anticipating the outcomes and care choices for people living with COPD.
D. Goeman (2012)
Diagnosis, management, and prognosis of preschool wheeze
F. Ducharme (2014)See more