Online citations, reference lists, and bibliographies.
Please confirm you are human
(Sign Up for free to never see this)
← Back to Search

Fear Appeals In Social Marketing: Strategic And Ethical Reasons For Concern

G. Hastings, M. Stead, J. Webb
Published 2004 · Psychology

Save to my Library
Download PDF
Analyze on Scholarcy
This article criticizes the predominant use of fear appeals in social marketing. Laboratory studies, which have been the basis for most of the research on fear appeals and which generally suggest that high fear works, have limitations that include forced exposure, short-term measurement, and an overdependence on student samples. Although, unfortunately, field research evaluations of fear appeals are few, they usually reveal that fear has both weaker effects and unintended deleterious effects in real-world social marketing campaigns. Ethical concerns about fear appeals include maladaptive responses such as chronic heightened anxiety among those most at risk and, paradoxically, complacency among those not directly targeted, and increased social inequity between those who respond to fear campaigns, who tend to be better off, and those who do not, who tend to be the less educated and poorer members of society. Alternatives to fear appeals are the use of positive reinforcement appeals aimed at the good behavior, the use of humor, and, for younger audiences, the use of postmodern irony. © 2004 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
This paper references
Building Donor Relationships: An Investigation into the Use of Relationship and Database Marketing by Charity Fundraisers
Weir Laura (2000)
Increasing customer satisfaction
V Knauer (1992)
Why this NSPCC advert is harmful to children. The Observer
J Rayner (1999)
Significance of emotion
S. Wertz (1998)
Long-term effectiveness of mass media led antismoking campaigns in Australia.
J. Pierce (1990)
The limitations of fear messages
G. Hastings (2002)
Annual report
M. Ivimey (1958)
An Exploratory Investigation of Teenagers' Attitudes Toward Anti-Drug Appeals
George E. Belch (1995)
Advertising Repetition as a Signal of Quality: If It's Advertised So Much, Something Must Be Wrong
Amna Kirmani (1997)
Likeability: Why Advertising that is Well Liked Sells Well
A. Biel (1998)
Challenge to Youth: A Health Canada Anti-Tobacco Campaign
James H. Mintz (1999)
Thinking positively: Using positive affect when designing health messages.
J. Monahan (1995)
A Meta-Analysis of Relationships between Ad-Evoked Feelings and Advertising Responses
S. P. Brown (1998)
Developing the Foolsspeed phase 3 campaign—Main findings
M Stead (2001)
Threats and Promises in Advertising Appeals
M. Menasco (1982)
From sunup to sundown: A patient-centric approach to pharmaceutical marketing
J H Bolling (2001)
Annual report. Utrecht, the Netherlands: National Drugs Monitor
Ndm Bureau (2001)
There are Threats and (Maybe) Fear-Caused Arousal: Theory and Confusions of Appeals to Fear and Fear Arousal Itself
M. Latour (1997)
Preventing the Spread of Genital Warts: Using Fear Appeals to Promote Self-Protective Behaviors
K. Witte (1998)
A review of the effectiveness of health promotion interventions aimed at reducing inequalities in health
L. Arblaster (1996)
Relationship marketing in consumer markets – Rhetoric or reality?
L. O′Malley (2000)
Long-term effectiveness of mass media led anti-smoking campaigns in Australia
J P Pierce (1998)
Annual Report, 2000/2001
C. Stoffle (2001)
Why children start smoking cigarettes: predictors of onset.
K. Conrad (1992)
Threat , authoritarianism and political advertising : An experiment in personality and persuasion [ On - line ]
L. Weinreich (2000)
Ethical issues in researching and targeting consumers Ethics in marketing
N C Smith (1992)
Developing the Foolsspeed 40 " commercial—Main findings
D R Eadie (1998)
Fear-Arousing Persuasive Messages
Franklin J. Boster (1984)
A Meta-Analysis of Fear Appeals: Implications for Effective Public Health Campaigns
K. Witte (2000)
Strategically Desirable Brand Name Characteristics
Kim R. Robertson (1989)
Two years of AIDS publicity: a review of progress in Scotland
G. Hastings (1990)
Research to assist the development of the new cervical screening protocol for Newcastle and North Tyneside Health Authority: Pretest of invitation and results letters
M Stead (1996)
Public health advertising: Guidelines for health promotion professionals
R J Donovan (1991)
Relative effectiveness of comprehensive community programming for drug abuse prevention with high-risk and low-risk adolescents.
C. Johnson (1990)
The Commitment-Trust Theory of Relationship Marketing
Robert M. Morgan (1994)
Scare tactics cut smoking rates in Australia to all time low
S. Chapman (1999)
Developing the Foolsspeed phase 3 campaign—Main findings. Glasgow, Scotland: University of Strathclyde, Centre for Social Marketing
M. Stead (2001)
LTSA advertising campaigns [Online
Land Transport Safety Authority. (2001)
Peur et persuasion: présentations des recherches(1953-1998) et d'une nouvelle lecture
F. Girandola (2000)
The Protection Motivation Model: A Normative Model of Fear Appeals:
J. F. Tanner (1991)
HEBS club smoking open its doors [On-line]
Decision Making: A Psychological Analysis of Conflict, Choice, and Commitment
Irving I. Janis (1977)
A breath of fresh air: Tackling smoking through the media
A Grey (2000)
Communicating about cancers: Formative research to guide the strategic development of a mass media cancer campaign . Final report
D R Eadie (1995)
AIDS publicity: some experiences from Scotland.
G. Hastings (1987)
Negative Outcomes, Threats and Threat Appeals: Widening the Conceptual Framework for the Study of Fear and Other Emotions in Social Marketing Communications
R. J. Donovan (1997)
Cognitive and physiological processes in fear appeals and attitude change: a revised theory of prote
R. W. Rogers (1983)
Zero defections: quality comes to services.
F. Reichheld (1990)
Charities struggle to find right balance with ad campaigns. The Guardian
L Ramrayka (2001)
Fear appeals in health promotion campaigns Designing health messages
J Hale (1995)
An Aggregate Examination of the Backlash Effect in Political Advertising: The Case of the 1996 U.S. Senate Race in Minnesota
Amy E. Jasperson (2002)
Effects of a Role Model and Fear in Warning Label on Perceptions of Safety and Safety Behavior
Mark A. deTurck (1994)
Anxiety associated with social issues: The development of a scale to measure an antecedent
Trina Sego (1994)
Don't just say no—Berkeley researcher Dr Joel Brown questions effectiveness of the federal government's antidrug education program . San Franscisco Bay Guardian [On-line]
J Cohn (1998)
Effects of components of protection-motivation theory on adaptive and maladaptive coping with a health threat.
P. A. Rippetoe (1987)
Branding perspectives on social marketing Advances in Consumer Research
K L Keller (1998)
Ethics In Marketing
N. Smith (1992)
Suspense and Advertising Responses
L. F. Alwitt (2002)
Partnership for a Drug-Free America (A)
V. Rangan (1993)
Fifteen years of fear arousal: research on threat appeals: 1953-1968.
K. Higbee (1969)
The Changing Nature of Theory and Practice in Marketing: on the Value of Synchrony
A. O'driscoll (1998)
The Scottish Office Home and Health Department domestic violence media campaign—Part 1: Qualitative evaluation. Glasgow, Scotland: University of Strathclyde, Centre for Social Marketing
S. G. MacAskill (1995)
Fear for sale
D Hevey (1992)
Some dangerous axioms of relationship marketing
M. Saren (1998)
The return of scare tactics
D. Hill (1998)
Findings and Theory in the Study of Fear Communications
H. Leventhal (1970)
The limitations of fear
B G. (2002)
Ethical theory and business (3rd ed.)
T. L. Beauchamp (1988)
Keynote paper From marketing mix to relationship marketing ‐ towards a paradigm shift in marketing
Christian Grönroos (1997)
Designing Health Communication Campaigns: What Works?
T. Backer (1992)
Advertising wearout in the Transport Accident Commission road safety campaigns.
T. Fry (1996)
Increasing the Persuasiveness of Fear Appeals: The Effect of Arousal and Elaboration
P. Keller (1996)
The TAC’s road safety campaign
Transport Accident Commission. (2002)
Charities struggle to find right balance with ad campaigns
L. Ramrayka
Perspective: When " honesty " in ads becomes just another gimmick. Campaign
S Hatfield (1994)
M. Latour (1988)
A rejoinder to `conclusions from the ARF's copy research validity project'
Russell I. Haley (1994)
You will die! Mass media invocations of existential dread
N. Henley (2002)
Relational Paradigms in Social Marketing
G. Hastings (2003)
Believe It Or Not: Persuasion, Manipulation and Credibility of Guilt Appeals
Robin Higie Coulter (1999)
Effects of fear-arousing warning messages
M. A. de Turck (1992)
Processing messages about disease detection and health promotion behaviors: the effects of anxiety.
M. Millar (1998)
Negative Emotions As Mediators of Attitudes in Advertising Appeals
David H. Moore (1989)
Tobacco control in the Netherlands
Stivoro (1998)
Advertising Works 8: Papers from the IPA Advertising Effectiveness Awards 1994
C Baker (1995)
Why this NSPCC advert is harmful to children
J. Rayner
Ethical Perspectives on the Postmodern Communications Leviathan
Chris R. Hackley (1999)
An Exploration of the Effects of Negative Political Advertising on Political Decision Making
B. Pinkleton (2002)
New Zealand Drink-driving Statistics: The Effectiveness of Road Safety Television Advertising
T. Macpherson (1998)
Negative Emotion and Message Processing
R. Baron (1994)
A breath of fresh air: Tackling smoking through the media. London: Health Development Agency
A. Grey (2000)
BBC News Online
P. Comber (2002)
Ethical Theory and Business
T. Beauchamp (1992)
Branding: Confessions of a Social Marketing Man
R. Belinoff (1995)
Affect Intensity and the Consumer's Attitude toward High Impact Emotional Advertising Appeals
D. Moore (1996)
Humanistic Advertising: A Holistic Cultural Perspective
Judie Lannon (1983)
Fear Appeals: Segmentation is the Way to Go
Valerie Quinn (1992)
Vicarious and Persuasive Influences on Efficacy Expectations and Intentions To Perform Breast Self-Examination.
R. Anderson (2000)
Fear appeals in print
M. S. LaTour (1993)
Adult and youth response to the Massachusetts anti-tobacco television campaign.
L. Biener (2000)
The Scottish Office Home and Health Department domestic violence media campaign—Part 1: Qualitative evaluation
S G Macaskill (1995)
From brand vision to brand evaluation
L. Chernatony (2001)
Converting the unconverted: the effect of inclination and opportunity to discount health-related fear appeals.
P. Keller (1999)
The guardian
K. Novak (2003)
A cross-cultural study of the persuasive effect of fear appeal messages in cigarette advertising: China and Canada
M. Laroche (2001)
Changing Adolescent Smoking Prevalence : Impact of Advertising Interventions
C. Pechmann (2001)
Assessing prosocial message effectiveness: effects of message quality, production quality, and persuasiveness.
E. Austin (1999)
Executing effective road safety advertising: are big production budgets necessary?
R. Donovan (1999)
Labelling of tobacco products in Europe: Results from the U.K. report prepared for the European Commission
E Devlin (2002)
Evaluation of antismoking advertising campaigns.
L. Goldman (1998)
The TAC's road safety campaign
November). Research to assist the development of the new cervical screening protocol for Newcastle and North
M. Stead (1996)
Fear and persuasion: Review and re-analysis of the literature (1953–1998)
F. Girandola (2000)
Fear advertising—It doesn't work! Health Canada Online
G Tripp (1988)
Building a world-class service system and setting rational priorities
J A Goodman (1995)
The Health Education Board for Scotland’s
S. MacAskill (1993)
A review of the marriage analogy in relationship marketing
C. Tynan (1997)
The effective use of fear appeals in persuasive immunization: An analysis of national immunization intervention messages
Susan L. Smith (1997)
A Method for Evaluating the Ethics of Fear Appeals
C. R. Duke (1993)
Guarding against Threatening HIV Prevention Messages: An Information-Processing Model
S. Blumberg (2000)
The advertising effectiveness of different levels of intensity of humour and warmth and the moderating role of top of mind awareness and degree of product use
P. D. Pelsmacker (1998)
Quit4Life: A Health Canada Tobacco Cessation Program
Philip D. Harvey (1999)
Using fear appeals for AIDS prevention in college aged population: An analysis of arousal and ad response
M S Latour (1989)
Can loyalty schemes really build loyalty
L. O’Malley (1998)
Building Successful Brands: the Strategic Options
P. Doyle (1990)
Effects of fear-arousing warning messages
M A De Turck (1992)
Adolescent Processing of Social and Physical Threat Communications
D. D. Schoenbachler (1996)
Attitudes, Personality and Behavior
I. Ajzen (1988)
The appropriateness of fear appeal use for health care marketing to the elderly: Is it OK to scare granny?
Suzeanne B. Benet (1993)
Fear-provoking recommendations, intentions to take preventive actions, and actual preventive actions.
H. P. Krisher (1973)
Scary warnings and rational precautions: A review of the psychology of fear appeals
R. Ruiter (2001)
Adults' response to Massachusetts anti-tobacco television advertisements: impact of viewer and advertisement characteristics
L. Biener (2000)
The report of the Surgeon General: preventing tobacco use among young people.
M. J. Elders (1994)
A content analysis of television advertising for the Massachusetts Tobacco Control Program media campaign, 1993-1996.
W. Dejong (2000)
Negative Affect and Health: The Importance of Being Earnest
Tracy J. Mayne (1999)
The effect of media, product and message factors on ad persuasiveness: the role of affect and cognition
A. Chaudhuri (1996)
Drinking and Driving PSAs: A Content Analysis of Behavioral Influence Strategies.
M. Slater (1999)
Packages: The money or the options
F Richardson (2001)
An Exploratory Assessment of the Effect of Alternative Advertising Appeals
J. S. Johar (1987)
LTSA advertising campaigns [Online] . New Zealand: Wellington
Fear and persuasion: Review and re-analysis of the literature Année Psychologique
F Girandola (1953)
Developing the Foolsspeed phase 2 commercial—Main findings. Glasgow, Scotland: University of Strathclyde, Centre for Social Marketing
M. Stead (2000)
Estimating Demand Functions for Product Characteristics: Reply
Brian T. Ratchford (1982)
Using fear appeals in advertising for AIDS prevention in the college-age population.
M. Latour (1989)
Manipulative advertising
T. L. Beauchamp (1988)
Communicating about cancers: Formative research to guide the strategic development of a mass media cancer campaign
D. R. Eadie (1995)
Personality and behavior
J. E. Gordon (1963)
Downsizing to Improve Strategic Position
S. W. Drew (1994)
M/C: A Journal of Media and Culture
P. Newman (2001)
Don't be afraid to use fear appeals: an experimental study
Micahel S. LaTour (1996)
Cognitive Responses to Negative and Comparative Political Advertising
Patrick C. Meirick (2002)
A critical perspective on the drug czar's antidrug media campaign.
W. Dejong (1999)
The ethics of psychoactive ads
M. Hyman (1990)
The continuing importance of emotion in tobacco control media campaigns: a response to Hastings and MacFadyen
L. Biener (2002)
The Ethicality of Using Fear for Social Advertising
D. Arthur (2003)
A Model of the Effects of Self-efficacy on the Perceived Ethicality and Performance of Fear Appeals in Advertising
R. Snipes (1999)
The Effects of Sexual Social Marketing Appeals on Cognitive Processing and Persuasion
T. Reichert (2001)
Developing the Foolsspeed phase 2 commercial—Main findings
M Stead (2000)
Advertising and promotion: An integrated marketing communications perspective
G E Belch (2001)
Ethical issues in researching and targeting consumers
N. C. Smith (1992)
Branding Perspectives on Social Marketing
K. Keller (1998)
Using the Media to Tackle the Health Divide: Future Directions
G. Hastings (1998)
11 steps to brand heaven
L. Weinreich (1999)
The Health Education Board for Scotland's 1992 anti-smoking initiative
S Macaskill (1993)
Evaluation of the written information sent to women who are called back for further investigation of breast screening in the UK
G. Ong (1996)
Zipping, Zapping and Nipping
P. Kitchen (1986)
Correspondence regarding this article should be sent to: Gerard Hastings, c/o Professor Andrew McAuley, Centre for Social Marketing
It takes two to make a relationship.
A. Kao (2001)
Alcohol and marijuana use among rural youth: interaction of social and intrapersonal influences.
G. Botvin (1998)
This is the Partnership for a Drug-Free America: Any Questions?
D. Buchanan (1998)
A review of the effectiveness of health promotion interventions aimed at reducing inequalities in health. London: Health Education Authority Report
L Arblaster (1996)
A cross-cultural examination of fear-appeal advertising in an individualism-collectivism framework
J. D. Williams (1998)
A relationship's success relies on conversation
J Treasure (2002)
Why the Massachusetts anti-cigarette campaign won’t work [Online
A. Brody (1998)
Don’t just say no—Berkeley researcher Dr. Joel Brown questions effectiveness of the federal government’s antidrug education program
J. Cohn (1998)
Fear Appeals in Print Advertising: An Analysis of Arousal and Ad Response
T. Henthorne (1993)
Facilitating Recycling: Reverse—Distribution Channel Design for Participation and Support
J. Thøgersen (1997)
December). Developing the Foolsspeed 40” commercial—Main findings. Glasgow: University of Strathclyde, Centre for Social Marketing
D. R. Eadie (1998)
Audience attitudes towards brand (product) placement: Singapore and the United States
James A. Karrh (2001)
Effects of Fear Arousal on Attitude Change: Recent Developments in Theory and Experimental Research1
I. L. Janis (1967)

This paper is referenced by
La vaccination chez les professionnels soignants : l’exemple d’une étude utilisant la méthode des choix discrets pour analyser les préférences vaccinales contre une maladie aiguë, fréquente et avec risques de complications sévères chez les personnes vulnérables
Léo Donzel Godinot (2018)
Pride in Technology‐Based Health Interventions: A Double‐Edged Sword
Danae Manika (2017)
Co-designing social marketing programs
T. Dietrich (2016)
Representations of Teen Pregnancy and Motherhood in the United States
Jacqueline Daldin (2015)
The Role of Social Media for Stakeholder Involvement: A Literature Review
Barbara Krumay (2016)
La communication sociétale : Quelle légitimité pour les annonceurs ?
S. Capelli (2006)
Peddling a semiotics of fear: a critical examination of scare tactics and commercial strategies in public health promotion
G. Brookes (2015)
25 years of Psychology & Marketing: a multidimensional review
Haseeb Shabbir (2009)
Social marketing ethics
S. Carter (2016)
Avoidance orientation moderates the effect of threatening messages
Jonathan van ’t Riet (2012)
Charitable Giving to Distant Others: An extended theory of planned behaviour model
Robert Mittelman (2016)
The Fakegate scandal: Social marketing ethics in promoting a difficult-to-sell good cause
Erik L. Olson (2018)
Les stratégies et les discours de prévention en santé publique : paradigmes et évolutions
J. Raude (2013)
The role of emotions and social cognitive variables in online health information seeking processes and effects
J. Myrick (2017)
Online sunscreen purchases: Impact of product characteristics and marketing claims
Giselle Prado (2019)
Emotional Appeals in Environmental Group Communications
Melissa Merry (2010)
Towards a better understanding of the effectiveness of threat appeals for counselling services
K.. Eccarius (2007)
Systematic literature review to examine the evidence for the effectiveness of interventions that use theories and models of behaviour change: towards the prevention and control of communicable diseases
K. Angus (2013)
Disgust images and nonprofit children’s causes
A. T. Allred (2018)
Emotions elicited by a road safety campaign
M. Suckfüll (2014)
Lynne Eagle (2009)
Understanding Health Behavior: An Integrated Model for Social Marketers
M. Cismaru (2008)
Exploring organisational use of negative emotions on Facebook and their effect on brand perceptions
Mark James Dinnage (2018)
Appeal to fear in health care: appropriate or inappropriate?
J. K. Simpson (2017)
Stereotype und negative Emotionen in Marketing und Kommunikation
Marie-Christin Papen (2019)
Principles and Practice of Social Marketing: An International Perspective
R. Donovan (2010)
Towards a new economic paradigm : exploring mental models and message framing effects about ecological economics
M. Tomaselli (2017)
Saving “Little Sister”: A Test of the Effectiveness of Kinship Appeals in Conservation Marketing
D. Morris (2020)
Searching from the heart: The interplay between emotions and customization in online health information seeking
J. Myrick (2013)
Community Cohesion in the London Borough of Barking and Dagenham
M. Wood (2010)
Road safety education in schools: a critical examination of three initiatives
M. Vick (2008)
Promoting Positive Engagement With Climate Change Through Visual and Iconic Representations
Sophie A. Nicholson-Cole (2009)
See more
Semantic Scholar Logo Some data provided by SemanticScholar