Changes In Masculine And Feminine Traits Over Time: A Meta-analysis
Published 1997 · Psychology
Download PDFAnalyze on Scholarcy
Sixty-three samples providing single-sex means on the Bem Sex-Role Inventory [BSRI; S. L. Bem (1974) “The Measurement of Psychological Androgyny,”Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, Vol. 42, pp. 155–162] and 40 reporting similar data on the Personal Attributes Questionnaire [PAQ; J. T. Spence and R. L. Helmreich (1978)Masculinity and Feminity, Austin University of Texas Press] for American undergraduates were located and analyzed. Women’s scores on the BSRI-M and PAQ-M (masculine) scales have increased steadily over time (r’s = .74 and .43, respectively). Women’s BSRI-F and PAQ-F (feminine) scale scores do not correlate with year. Men’s BSRI-M scores show a weaker positive relationship with year of administration (r = .47). The effect size for sex differences on the BSRI-M has also changed over time, showing a significant decrease over the twenty-year period. The results suggest that cultural change and environment may affect individual personalities; these changes in BSRI and PAQ means demonstrate women’s increased endorsement of masculine-stereotyped traits and men’s continued nonendorsement of feminine-steretyped traits.
This paper references
Volunteer bias in erotica research: Effects of intrusiveness of measure and sexual background
S. Wolchik (1985)
Masculinity, femininity, life stress, and depression
J. Stoppard (1987)
Relationship between Sex, Sex-Role Characteristics and Coronary-Prone Behavior in College Students
J. Nix (1981)
Love Styles, Masculinity/Femininity, Physical Attractiveness, and Sexual Behavior: A Test of Evolutionary Theory
A. Walsh (1993)
Psychological Androgyny, Feminine Gender Identity and Self- Esteem in Homosexual and Heterosexual Males
Robert E. Hooberman (1979)
Nursing Students: Stereotypically Feminine
J. Vandever (1978)
A Comparison of Androgynous, Feminine, Masculine, and Undifferentiated Women on Self-Esteem, Body Satisfaction, and Sexual Satisfaction
T. M. Kimlicka (1983)
Self-rated adjustment and sex-typing on the Bem Sex-Role Inventory: Is masculinity the primary predictor of adjustment?
L. Silvern (1979)
Masculinity, femininity, psychological androgyny, and the structure of values.
N. Feather (1984)
Housework in Marital and Nonmarital Households
Scott J. South (1994)
Sex-role development in late adolescence and adulthood
J. Fischer (1981)
Sex-Role Orientation of College Students and Their Same-Sex Parents
J. J. Karylowski (1989)
Relative Fairness and the Division of Housework: The Importance of Options
M. Lennon (1994)
Gender-role conflict scale: College men's fear of femininity
J. M. O'neil (1986)
If “good managers” are masculine, what are “bad managers”?
G. Powell (1984)
Sex role perceptions and social anxiety in opposite-sex and same-sex situations
C. Robins (1986)
The Effects of Sexually Violent Rock Music on Males' Acceptance of Violence Against Women
J. S. St. Lawrence (1991)
Stereotypic and nonstereotypic sex role trait and behavior orientations: Implications for personal adjustment.
J. L. Orlofsky (1987)
Sex differences in problem solving.
E. Johnson (1984)
Do Sex Differences Define Gender-Related Individual Differences within the Sexes? Evidence from Three Studies
R. Lippa (1995)
“Masculinity,” “femininity,” and the complex construct of adjustment
F. D. Payne (1987)
Sex-Role Orientation, Stress, and Subsequent Health Status Demonstrated by Two Scoring Procedures for Bem's Scale
B. A. Wech (1983)
Traditionality of choice and sex-role identification as moderators of the congruence of occupational choice in college women
L. K. Wolfe (1981)
Sex role attributes, symptom distress, and defensive style among college men and women.
S. Frank (1984)
Some psychometric characteristics of gender diagnosticity measures: reliability, validity, consistency across domains, and relationship to the big five.
R. Lippa (1991)
Attitudes Toward Women, 1970–1995
J. Twenge (1997)
Sexual identification and gender identity among father-absent males
S. Kagel (1985)
Women's sports: A history
A. Guttmann (1991)
Career choice considerations and sex role self-concept of male and female undergraduates in nontraditional majors
C. Strange (1983)
On the utility of alternative procedures for assessing psychological androgyny.
S. Bem (1977)
Attitudes toward homosexuality: Assessment and behavioral consequences.
Mary E. Kite (1986)
Multidimensional self-concepts, masculinity, and femininity as a function of women's involvement in athletics
H. W. Marsh (1986)
Patterns of self-disclosure in homosexual and heterosexual college students
V. L. Bender (1976)
Working wives, working husbands
J. Pleck (1985)
The relationship of gender, self-esteem, and instrumentality to depressive symptomatology.
N. Russo (1993)
BSRI Scores: Stability Over Four Years for College Women
Barbara J. Yanico (1985)
Multivariate analysis of new sex role formulations and personality.
L. C. Bernard (1980)
The relationship of women's sex-role identity to self-esteem and ego development.
E. Schiff (1978)
Psychological Masculinity and Femininity: Relationship to Striving and Self-Concept in the Achievement and Interpersonal Domains
J. L. Orlofsky (1981)
Masculinity and femininity as factors in feminism.
D. Baucom (1978)
Sex-Role Attitude as a Moderator in the Relationship between Locus of Control and N Achievement
A. Bedeian (1977)
The Second Shift
A. Hochschild (1989)
Multivariate analysis of male and female professional career choice correlates.
Edward G. Wertheim (1978)
Theoretical and Operational Conceptualizations of Psychological Androgyny: Implications for Measurement
Nancy E. Downing (1979)
Machiavellianism and Women's Grade Point Averages
M. Ames (1979)
Sex-Role Identity across Two Cultures
J. Gackenbach (1981)
Gender Roles and Self-Esteem: A Consideration of Environmental Factors
J. Burnett (1995)
Linking individual development and social changes
A. Stewart (1989)
The effects of self-monitoring on the expressive display of masculinity-femininity
R. Lippa (1983)
Attitudes toward Women, Sex-Role-Stereotyping and Locus of Control
F. A. Minnigerode (1976)
Relations between instrumental and expressive personality characteristics and behaviors: A test of spence and Helmreich's theory
G. Holmbeck (1988)
Concern over the negative consequences of success
R. Ho (1981)
Polls and Surveys: Understanding What They Tell Us.@@@Trends in Public Opinion: A Compendium of Survey Data.
Lawrence D Bobo (1989)
Cross-Validation of Item Selection on the Bem Sex Role Inventory
H. Walkup (1978)
Depression, gender, gender role traits, and the wish to be held
M. Sanfilipo (1993)
Identity in three cohorts of midlife women.
R. Helson (1995)
The multidimensional aspects of masculinity-femininity.
L. C. Bernard (1981)
Fashion, Culture, and Identity
F. Davis (1992)
Desirable and undesirable masculine and feminine traits in counseling clients and unselected students.
C. K. Holahan (1980)
Gender role identity and dating behavior: What is the relationship?
J. L. Delucia (1987)
The masculinity-femininity of women who study college mathematics
S. Blackman (1986)
Interactive effects of social context and sex role identity on female self-disclosure during the acquaintance process
D. Shaffer (1991)
Correlates of female athletic participation: Masculinity, femininity, self-esteem, and attitudes toward women
R. Colker (1980)
Menstrual Distress and Sex-Role Attributes
Paul R. Good (1980)
Field Dependence, Sex Role Self-Perceptions, and Mathematics Achievement in College Students: A Closer Examination.
Malcolm L. Van Blerkom (1988)
Causes and consequences of sex-role attitudes and attitude change.
A. Thornton (1983)
A subcultural change of MMPI norms in the 1960s due to adolescent role confusion and glamorization of alienation.
D. Schubert (1975)
Gender-related traits and gender ideology: Evidence for a multifactorial theory.
J. Spence (1993)
Sex-role and need configuration
Batlis Nc (1981)
The "Self-Disclosure" and "Self-Presentation" Views of Item Response Dynamics and Personality Scale Validity
J. A. Johnson (1981)
Validity of Using Bem Sex-Role Inventory Norms on other Samples: Analysis of a Southern Sample
P. J. Faulkender (1987)
The measurement of psychological androgyny.
S. Bem (1974)
The relationship of sex role to self-concept.
C. Erdwins (1980)
Sex differences in depression across the high school to college transition
T. Gladstone (1994)
Not Just Another Pretty Face
T. Cash (1985)
Shifts in Sex-Role after a Decade of Cultural Change
D. M. Pedersen (1985)
Intercorrelations of attitudes, personality, and sex role orientation in a college sample
C. Nagoshi (1993)
Female Career Preference and Androgyny
Joanne H. Clarey (1982)
Sex Role Orientation
J. S. St. Lawrence (1985)
Sexual aggression and love styles: An exploratory study
D. Sarwer (1993)
Relationship between sex role attitudes and personality traits and the sex role behavior scale-1: A new measure of masculine and feminine role behaviors and interests.
J. L. Orlofsky (1981)
Sex-role androgyny and patterns of causal attribution for academic achievement
M. Brewer (1979)
Overcoming the masculine mystique : preferences for alternative forms of assistance among men who avoid counseling
J. M. Robertson (1992)
Decade Differences in Personality of Junior College and University Freshmen
M. Southern (1974)
Maternal Employment and Androgyny
R. Hansson (1977)
Gender Self-Concepts in the USA and Yugoslavia
T. Novaković (1988)
Contrast of the Gender-Identity Scale with Bem's Sex-Role Measures and the MF Scale of the MMPI
R. V. Alumbaugh (1987)
Categorization agreement of the personality attributes questionnaire and the bem sex role inventory
J. Gaa (1981)
The relationship between sex-role orientation and the type A behavior pattern: a test of the main effect hypothesis.
M. J. Stevens (1984)
The differential role of instrumentality, expressivity, and social support in predicting problem-solving appraisal in men and women
P. Heppner (1995)
Stressful life events: Moderators of the relationships of gender and gender roles to self-reported depression and suicidality among college students
L. Waelde (1994)
Further evidence that M-F is bipolar and multidimensional.
M. Russell (1978)
The relation of gender-role orientation to sexual experience among college students
B. Whitley (1988)
A factor analysis of the Bem Sex-Role Inventory.
C. Whetton (1977)
Sex-gender differences in level of androgyny
A. B. Heilbrun (1982)
Theories of sexual orientation.
Michael D. Storms (1980)
Norms for college undergraduates for the Bem Sex-Role Inventory and the Wiggins Interpersonal Behavior Circle.
P. Yarnold (1987)
Correlations of Masculinity and Femininity to Sensation Seeking
J. Tobacyk (1980)
Gender jeopardy: The effects of gender, assessed femininity and masculinity, and false success/failure feedback on performance in an experimental quiz game.
R. Lippa (1983)
Statistical abstract of the United States
D. Commerce (1878)
Type of Menstrual Discomfort and Psychological Masculinity in College Women
Donald J. Woods (1979)
Correlates of negative attitudes toward homosexuals in heterosexual college students
L. A. Kurdek (1988)
Relationships between Sex-Role Orientation and Attitudes toward Women as Managers
M. Collins (1979)
“Masculinity,” “femininity,” and adjustment in college men
F. D. Payne (1983)
Psychological androgyny and sex role flexibility: A test of two hypotheses
R. Helmreich (1979)
Masculine Instrumentality and Feminine Expressiveness: Their Relationships with Sex Role Attitudes and Behaviors
J. Spence (1980)
The relationship of sex-role characteristics to self-report and role-play measures of assertiveness in women
J. Nix (1984)
Participation in competitive amateur sports as a function of psychological androgyny
A. Myers (1978)
Comparison of Factors from the Bem Sex-Role Inventory for Male and Female College Students
T. M. Kimlicka (1980)
The relation of gender and sexual orientation to measures of masculinity, femininity, and androgyny: a further analysis.
B. Finlay (1991)
Gender characteristics and adjustment: a longitudinal study.
J. Aubé (1992)
The measurement of psychological androgyny: an extended replication.
H. Hogan (1977)
Sex role identity and its relationships to sex role attributes and sex role stereotypes.
Michael D. Storms (1979)
Masculinity and femininity
E. V. D. Vliert (1998)
Ratings of self and peers on sex role attributes and their relation to self-esteem and conceptions of masculinity and femininity.
J. Spence (1975)
A Comparison Of The Adjective Check List, Bem Sex Role Inventory, And Personal Attributes Questionnaire Masculinity And Femininity Subscales.
K. E. O’grady (1979)
Gender-related traits and helping behaviors.
F. M. Siem (1986)
Narcissism, sex roles, and self-functioning
P. Watson (1987)
Bem Sex Role Inventory: A theoretical and methodological critique.
E. Pedhazur (1979)
Seductive father-daughter relationships and sex roles in women
Joseph D. LaBarbera (1984)
Sex Differences in Social Behavior : A Social-role interpretation
A. Eagly (1987)
Care-oriented moral reasoning and prosocial behavior: A question of gender or sex role orientation
I. Söchting (1994)
German and American Responses to the Bem Sex Role Inventory
H. Hogan (1979)
Social psychology as history.
K. Gergen (1973)
Sex-Role Identity and Sex: An Important Distinction for Research on Women in Management
G. Powell (1982)
Adolescent girls' sex role development: Relationship with sports participation, self-esteem, and age at menarche
J. Butcher (1989)
Sex Differences in Moral Judgments? A Test of Gilligan's Theory
W. J. Friedman (1987)
Are Masculine Trait-Factors in Women a Help or a Hindrance in Dealing with Fear of Success?
M. Kearney (1982)
Factors Affecting the Sex of One's Friends
Diane Donio (1985)
Defense Mechanisms in Females as a Function of Sex-Role Orientation.
R. G. Evans (1982)
Impact of Maternal Employment on Daughters' Sex-Role Orientation and Fear of Success
F. D. Gilroy (1981)
The relationship of sex-role orientation to heterosexuals' attitudes toward homosexuals
Bernard E. WhitleyJr. (1987)
Sexually Aggressive Tactics in Dating Relationships: Personality and Attitudinal Correlates
J. Spence (1991)
Hemodynamic adjustments to laboratory stress: the influence of gender and personality.
M. T. Allen (1993)
The Effects of Early Parental Divorce on the Sex Role Development of College Students
James D. Vess Jr. Ma (1983)
The relationship between sex-role identity and beliefs in personal control
S. J. Johnson (1981)
Comparison of Masculine and Feminine Personality Attributes and Sex-Role Attitudes across Age Groups.
J. Spence (1979)
Relationship of Sex Role to Male- and Female-Dominated Professions
Z. E. Tyer (1979)
A theoretical analysis of sex differences in same-sex friendships
Robert J. Barth (1988)
The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life
E. Goffman (1959)
Hostility and sex guilt: Perceptions of self and others as a function of gender and sex-role orientation
R. G. Evans (1984)
Relationships between Achievement and Affiliation Needs and Sex-Role Orientation of College Women Whose Fathers Were Absent from Home
S. M. Harris (1991)
Gender role, gender-role conflict, and psychological well-being in men
Mark J. Sharpe (1991)
This paper is referenced by
Are You a “Woman”? Representation of Femininity in Two Women's Magazines in Singapore, Cleo and Her World
Iccha Basnyat (2014)
A MULHER NA PSICANÁLISE: ESTUDO EXPLORATÓRIO
Teresa Cortez (2012)
Factors Influencing High School Students’ Interest in pSTEM
T. Ito (2018)
An Intimate Portrait of the Individual Investor
Robert B. Durand (2006)
Defining the Alpha Female: A Female Leadership Measure
R. Ward (2010)
Gender Role Internalization, Multiple Roles, and Chinese Women's Mental Health
T. Tang (2001)
Geschlecht, geschlechts- bezogenes Selbstkonzept und Berufserfolg Befunde aus einer prospektiven Längsschnittstudie mit Hochschulabsolventinnen und -absolventen The Impact of Gender and Gender-Related Self-Concept on Career Success: Findings from a Prospective Study
A. Abele (2003)
Gender and Age Differences in Individual Decisions about Wireless Mobile Data Services: A Report from China
J. Lu (2008)
‘Expressive-Instrumental Traits and Sexist Attitudes among Spanish University Professors’
M. Fernández (2007)
MEN, WOMEN, AND MANAGERS: ARE STEREOTYPES FINALLY CHANGING?
Emily E. Duehr (2006)
Factors influencing levels of research activity in clinical psychologists: a new model
Sue Holttum (2006)
Sex Differences in Goals for Supportive Interactions
E. MacGeorge (2005)
It Depends Who is Asking and Who You Ask: Social Incentives for Sex Differences in the Propensity to Initiate Negotiation
H. Bowles (2005)
ICTM 2016 Proceedings of the International Conference on ICT Management for Global Competitiveness and Economic Growth in Emerging Economies, Conference Theme: Economic, Cultural and Social Innovations for Human Capital in Transition Economies
A. Senejko (2016)
Desirability of the Bem Sex-Role Inventory Items for Women and Men: A Comparison Between African Americans and European Americans
A. M. Konrad (2002)
Ziele, Selbstkonzept und Work-Life-Balance bei der längerfristigen Lebensgestaltung. Befunde der Erlanger Längsschnittstudie BELA-E mit Akademikerinnen und Akademikern
A. Abele (2005)
Führungskompetenz: Selbst- und Fremdwahrnehmung weiblicher und männlicher Führungskräfte
Sabine Sczesny (2003)
Age, gender, race, socioeconomic status, and birth cohort differences on the children's depression inventory: a meta-analysis.
J. Twenge (2002)
More males run fast A stable sex difference in competitiveness in U.S. distance runners
R. O. Deaner (2006)
Stability and Change in Personality in Adult Women Over a 37-Year Period
O. Viman (2012)
Are Barbie and Ken too cool for school? A case-control study on the relation between gender and dropout.
M. Theunissen (2015)
Instrumental or Expressive?
Andrew P. Smiler (2010)
Breaking the rules: Personal control increases women’s direct relationship initiation
Jennifer C. D. MacGregor (2011)
Har sättet att resa betydelse för betraktarens uppfattning om en person? : En jämförelse mellan cyklist och bilist
Anna Yngvén (2014)
Gender and Gravestone Epitaphs: A Warren County Cemetery
Callis Goodwin (2013)
Differences in German Youth Gender Ideologies: The Relationship Between Family Structure and Doing Gender
Alyssa Alexander (2017)
Country’s preferred leader behaviour profile: Does cultural homogeneity matter?
Inga Minelgaitė (2018)
The Influence of perspective and gender on the processing of narratives
J. Houska (2010)
SEXUAL COERCION ACROSS CULTURES: AN EXAMINATION OF PREVALENCE, PERCEPTIONS, AND CONSEQUENCES OF SEXUAL COERCION IN KOREA AND THE UNITED STATES
J. Kim (2012)
A Status Account of Gender Stereotypes: Beyond Communality and Agency
M. Conway (2000)
Navigating Social Roles in Pursuit of Important Goals: A Communal Goal Congruity Account of STEM Pursuits
A. Diekman (2013)
Female Leadership Advantage and Disadvantage: Resolving the Contradictions
A. Eagly (2007)See more