← Back to Search
Substitutes For Leadership And The Management Of Professionals
P. M. Podsakoff, S. MacKenzie, Richard E. Fetter
Published 1993 · Psychology
Save to my Library
Download PDFAnalyze on Scholarcy
In a recent study, Podsakoff, Niehoff, MacKenzie, and Williams (1993) reported that although several of the subordinate, task, and organizational variables identified in Kerr and Jermier's (1978) Substitutes for Leadership model had main effects on subordinate criterion variables, few of these “substitutes” actually moderated the relationships between leader behaviors and the criterion variables in a manner consistent with that specified by Howell, Dorfman, and Kerr (1986). The goal of this study was to explore the possibility that the reason for the lack of support reported by Podsakoff and his colleagues, was their use of a sample comprised primarily of nonprofessionals, by testing the substitutes model using a more professional sample (n = 411 professional, managerial, and whitecollar employees drawn from 10 different organizations). In addition, other key objectives of this study were to: (a) provide a definitional and statistical clarification of Howell, Dorfman, and Kerr's (1986) “substituting,” “neutralizing,” and “enhancing” effects; (b) report the psychometric properties of a refined and reduced substitutes-for-leadership scale; (c) test the moderating effects of the substitute variables on a broader range of criterion variables than had been previously examined; and (d) investigate the proportion of variance explained in these criterion variables by the main effects of the leader behaviors and the substitutes for leadership. The results indicate that few of the substitutes variables moderated the relationships between the leader behaviors and the subordinate criterion variables, and that the majority of the moderated relationships identified did not meet the criteria specified by Howell, Dorfman, and Kerr. Possible reasons for these findings, and their implications for the substitutes model, are then discussed.
This paper references
Situational moderators of leader reward and punishment behaviors: fact or fiction?
P. M. Podsakoff (1984)
PERSONALITY AND CHARISMA IN THE U.S. PRESIDENCY: A PSYCHOLOGICAL THEORY OF LEADERSHIP EFFECTIVENESS.
R. J. House (1990)
Transformational leader behaviors and their effects on followers' trust in leader, satisfaction, and organizational citizenship behaviors
P. M. Podsakoff (1990)
Task dimensions as moderators of the effects of instrumental leadership: A two-sample replicated test of path-goal leadership theory
C. Schriesheim (1981)
ORGANIZATIONAL CITIZENSHIP BEHAVIOR: ITS NATURE AND ANTECEDENTS
C. A. Smith (1983)
Leader reward behavior and subordinate satisfaction and performance.
H. P. Sims (1975)
Questions of Causation in the Path-Goal Theory of Leadership1
C. N. Greene (1979)
A vertical dyad linkage approach to leadership within formal organizations: A longitudinal investigation of the role making process
Fred Dansereau (1975)
An Exploration of the Path-Goal Theory of Leadership in a Health Care Environment
A. D. Szilagyi (1974)
Role Conflict and Ambiguity in Complex Organizations.
J. R. Rizzo (1970)
Conflict, Ambiguity, and Overload: Three Elements in Job Stress.
R. Kahn (1973)
Effects of Different Leader Behaviors under Different Levels of Task Interdependence
L. W. Fry (1986)
Assessing Construct Validity in Organizational Research
R. Bagozzi (1991)
Manual for the Minnesota Satisfaction Questionnaire.
D. Weiss (1967)
Leadership in Organizations.
Stuart C. Freedman (1981)
Culture-Free Leadership Effectiveness Versus Moderators of Leadership Behavior: An Extension and Test of Kerr and Jermier's “Substitutes for Leadership” Model in Taiwan
J. Farh (1987)
Clarifying some controversial issues surrounding statistical procedures for detecting moderator variables: Empirical evidence and related matters.
Eugene F. Stone (1989)
A meta-analysis and conceptual critique of research on role ambiguity and role conflict in work settings
S. E. Jackson (1985)
Toward a Contingency Theory of Leadership Based upon the Consideration and Initiating Structure Literature
S. Kerr (1974)
Organizational commitment, job satisfaction, and turnover among psychiatric technicians.
L. Porter (1973)
Role Conflict and Ambiguity: A Scale Analysis
R. Schuler (1977)
Self-Reports in Organizational Research: Problems and Prospects
P. M. Podsakoff (1986)
Type I error rates for moderated multiple regression analysis.
S. Paunonen (1988)
The Path-Goal Theory of Leadership: A Theoretical and Empirical Analysis
C. Schriesheim (1977)
Job Satisfaction and the Good Soldier: The Relationship Between Affect and Employee “Citizenship”
Thomas S. Bateman (1983)
A Paradigm for Developing Better Measures of Marketing Constructs
Gilbert A. Churchill (1979)
A causal-correlational analysis of the job satisfaction and performance relationship.
J. P. Wanous (1974)
Further Thoughts on Punishment In Organizations
H. P. Sims (1980)
A reliability coefficient for maximum likelihood factor analysis
L. Tucker (1973)
Organizational citizenship behavior: The good soldier syndrome.
D. Organ (1988)
The Measurement of Organizational Commitment.
R. Mowday (1979)
Effects of leader contingent and noncontingent reward and punishment behaviors on subordinate performance and satisfaction.
P. M. Podsakoff (1982)
The Effects of Group Cohesion and Leader Behavior on Subordinate Satisfaction
G. Dobbins (1986)
Leadership and Substitutes for Leadership Among Professional and Nonprofessional Workers
J. Howell (1986)
Moderator Variables in Leadership Research
J. P. Howell (1986)
The New Professionals: Managing Today's High-Tech Employees
Von Glinow (1988)
PATH-GOAL THEORY OF LEADERSHIP
R. J. House (1975)
Failures to detect moderating effects with ordinary least squares-moderated multiple regression: Some reasons and a remedy.
J. Morris (1986)
Transformational leadership, charisma, and beyond.
B. Avolio (1988)
A Path-Goal Theory of Leader Effectiveness
R. House (1971)
Accounting for Organizational Citizenship Behavior: Leader Fairness and Task Scope versus Satisfaction
Jiing-Lih Farh (1990)
Substitutes for Leadership: Test of a Construct
J. P. Howell (1981)
Analysis of relationships among leader behavior, subordinate job performance and satisfaction: A path-goal approach.
H. K. Downey (1975)
Issues in the study of “professionals” in organizations: The case of scientists and engineers
S. Kerr (1977)
Do Substitutes for Leadership Really Substitute for Leadership? An Empirical Examination of Kerr and Jermier's Situational Leadership Model
P. M. Podsakoff (1993)
Organizational citizenship behavior and objective productivity as determinants of managerial evaluations of salespersons' performance
S. MacKenzie (1991)
Personality and Charisma in the U.S. Presidency: A Psychological Theory of Leader Effectiveness
R. J. House (1991)
Convergent and discriminant validities of corresponding Job Descriptive Index and Minnesota Satisfaction Questionnaire scales.
B. Gillet (1975)
LEADERSHIP AND PERFORMANCE BEYOND EXPECTATIONS
B. Bass (1985)
A preliminary analysis of the construct validity of Kerr & Jermier's ‘Substitutes for Leadership’ Scales
M. Williams (1988)
Substitutes for leadership: Their meaning and measurement
S. Kerr (1978)
A Role-Making Model of Leadership in Formal Organizations: A Developmental Approach
G. Graen (1975)
Role conflict and ambiguity scales: Reality or artifacts?
R. House (1983)
CONTEXTUAL PREDICTORS OF ORGANIZATIONAL CITIZENSHIP BEHAVIOR.
Rekha Karambayya (1990)
Affective and nonaffective components of job satisfaction and organizational commitment as determinants of organizational citizenship and in-role behaviors
L. J. Williams (1988)
Some issues associated with the use of moderated regression
E. F. Stone (1984)
Applied multiple regression/correlation analysis for the behavioral sciences
J. Cohen (1975)
Biography and the Assessment of Transformational Leadership at the World-Class Level
B. Bass (1987)
Transformational Leadership and the Falling Dominoes Effect
B. Bass (1987)
A Restatement of the Satisfaction-Performance Hypothesis
D. Organ (1988)
This paper is referenced by
Leadership as a driver of entrepreneurship : an international exploratory study.
C. Félix (2019)
Transformational and social processes of leadership as predictors of organisational outcomes
M. Muchiri (2012)
The role of fair treatment and rewards in perceptions of organizational support and leader-member exchange.
S. Wayne (2002)
Different identifications cause different types of voice: A role identity approach to the relations between organizational socialization and voice
Wen Wu (2015)
The dynamic interaction between eyewitnesses and interviewers: the impact of differences in perspective on memory reports and interviewer behavior.
A. Douglass (2013)
A Study of Organizational Citizenship Behavior (OCB) and its Antecedents in an Indian Police Agency
Hanif Qureshi (2015)
The relationship between high commitment management and employee attitudes and behaviours : the role of psychological contract fulfilment and justice
S. Zeidan (2006)
The effects of service climate and the effective leadership behaviour of supervisors on frontline employee service quality : a multi-level analysis
C. Hui (2007)
Relationships of role stressors with organizational citizenship behavior: a meta-analysis.
Erin M. Eatough (2011)
Citizenship behavior and fairness in organizations: Issues and directions for future research
P. M. Podsakoff (1993)
Integrative Framework of Leadership Effectiveness
W. Ismail (2011)
Organizational Citizenship Behavior of Contingent Workers in Singapore
L. V. Dyne (2008)
A 25-year perspective on levels of analysis in leadership research
Shelley D. Dionne (2014)
Characteristics of effective leadership networks: a replication and extension
K. Leithwood (2019)
Does one good turn deserve another? coworker influences on employee citizenship
W. H. Bommer (2003)
A META-ANALYTIC REVIEW OF ATTITUDINAL AND DISPOSITIONAL PREDICTORS OF ORGANIZATIONAL CITIZENSHIP BEHAVIOR
D. Organ (1995)
Leadership and quality management practices in Thailand
T. Laohavichien (2011)
Linking demographic diversity to organisational outcomes : The moderating role of transformational leadership
M. Muchiri (2013)
The Impact of Hospital CEO Leadership Behaviors on Employees` Job Satisfaction and Intention in Korea
Jae-San Park (2006)
Role Perceptions and Performance
Rachel Sady (2019)
How leaders impact employee creativity: a study of Indian R&D laboratories
V. Gupta (2012)
Professional identity neutralizes charismatic leadership tactics in a crisis
R. A. Kamble (2019)
Substitutes-for-leadership theory: Development and basic concepts
C. Schriesheim (1997)
Organisational Justice–Job Satisfaction–Organisational Citizenship Behaviour
Hooi Lai Wan (2016)
Measuring substitutes for leadership using the concepts need for leadership : A cross-sectional research
R. E. D. Vries (1995)
Führungsverhalten in jungen Unternehmen
S. Zäch (2014)
Organizational citizenship levels of academicians in terms of several variables: The sample of Physical Education and Sports Sciences
A. Aydın (2015)
The Variance Architecture Approach to the Study of Constructs in Organizational Contexts
Dan J. Putka (2002)
Organizational culture, leadership and performance in context : trust and rationality in organizations
B. Koene (1996)
Need for leadership as a moderator of the relationships between leadership characteristics and individual outcomes
R. E. D. Vries (2002)
The role of authentic leadership and ethical leadership in an organisational setting - predictors for ethical climate, organisational citizenship behaviour, affective organisational commitment and in-role performance
B. Nikolić (2015)
Prioritizing those who follow: Servant leadership, needs satisfaction, and positive employee outcomes
Kristin N. Saboe (2010)See more