Subject-specific Finite Element Models Implementing A Maximum Principal Strain Criterion Are Able To Estimate Failure Risk And Fracture Location On Human Femurs Tested In Vitro.
E. Schileo, F. Taddei, L. Cristofolini, M. Viceconti
Published 2008 · Engineering, Medicine
Download PDFAnalyze on Scholarcy
No agreement on the choice of the failure criterion to adopt for the bone tissue can be found in the literature among the finite element studies aiming at predicting fracture risk of bones. The use of stress-based criteria seems to prevail on strain-based ones, while basic bone biomechanics suggest using strain parameters to describe failure. The aim of the present combined experimental-numerical study was to verify, using subject-specific finite element models able to accurately predict strains, if a strain-based failure criterion could identify the failure patterns of bones. Three cadaver femurs were CT-scanned and subsequently fractured in a clinically relevant single-stance loading scenario. Load-displacement curves and high-speed movies were acquired to define the failure load and the location of fracture onset, respectively. Subject-specific finite element models of the three femurs were built from CT data following a validated procedure. A maximum principal strain criterion was implemented in the finite element models, and two stress-based criteria selected for comparison. The failure loads measured were applied to the models, and the computed risks of fracture were compared to the results of the experimental tests. The proposed principal strain criterion managed to correctly identify the level of failure risk and the location of fracture onset in all the modelled specimens, while Von Mises or maximum principal stress criteria did not give significant information. A maximum principal strain criterion can thus be defined a suitable candidate for the in vivo risk factor assessment on long bones.
This paper references
A phantom for standardization and quality control in spinal bone mineral measurements by QCT and DXA: design considerations and specifications.
W. Kalender (1992)
Mechanical strength of a femoral reconstruction in paediatric oncology: A finite element study
F. Taddei (2003)
The effect of impact direction on the structural capacity of the proximal femur during falls
C. M. Ford (1996)
The multimod application framework: A rapid application development tool for computer aided medicine
M. Viceconti (2007)
Fracture simulation of the femoral bone using the finite-element method: How a fracture initiates and proceeds
T. Ota (1999)
Finite element prediction of proximal femoral fracture patterns under different loads.
M. Gomez-Benito (2005)
Predicting Proximal Femoral Strength Using Structural Engineering Models
J. Keyak (2005)
Femoral strength is better predicted by finite element models than QCT and DXA.
D. Cody (1999)
Correlations between orthogonal mechanical properties and density of trabecular bone: use of different densitometric measures.
J. Keyak (1994)
Uniaxial yield strains for bovine trabecular bone are isotropic and asymmetric
W. C. Chang (1999)
Bone mineral content and mechanical strength. An ex vivo study on human femora at autopsy.
A. Alho (1988)
Comparison of isotropic and orthotropic material property assignments on femoral finite element models under two loading conditions.
L. Peng (2006)
Critical evaluation of known bone material properties to realize anisotropic FE-simulation of the proximal femur.
D. Wirtz (2000)
Dependence of yield strain of human trabecular bone on anatomic site.
E. Morgan (2001)
A Method for Registration of 3-D Shapes
P. Besl (1992)
Prediction of femoral fracture load using finite element models: an examination of stress- and strain-based failure theories.
J. Keyak (2000)
Biomechanics of trabecular bone.
T. M. Keaveny (2001)
Improved prediction of proximal femoral fracture load using nonlinear finite element models.
J. Keyak (2001)
Regional differences in cortical porosity in the fractured femoral neck.
K. L. Bell (1999)
Yield strain behavior of trabecular bone.
D. Kopperdahl (1998)
Tensile yield in compact bone is determined by strain, post-yield behaviour by mineral content.
J. Currey (2004)
The relationship between loading conditions and fracture patterns of the proximal femur.
K. Yang (1996)
The relationship between the structural and orthogonal compressive properties of trabecular bone.
R. Goulet (1994)
The material mapping strategy influences the accuracy of CT-based finite element models of bones: an evaluation against experimental measurements.
F. Taddei (2007)
How does bone break?
D. Taylor (2003)
Finite element models predict in vitro vertebral body compressive strength better than quantitative computed tomography.
R. Crawford (2003)
The compressive behavior of bone as a two-phase porous structure.
D. Carter (1977)
Prediction of femoral fracture load using automated finite element modeling.
J. Keyak (1998)
Extracting clinically relevant data from finite element simulations.
M. Viceconti (2005)
Structure Analysis of High Resolution Magnetic Resonance Imaging of the Proximal Femur: In Vitro Correlation with Biomechanical Strength and BMD
T. Link (2002)
A fabric-dependent fracture criterion for bone.
S. Pietruszczak (1999)
Fracture prediction for the proximal femur using finite element models: Part I--Linear analysis.
J. C. Lotz (1991)
Prediction of Hip Fracture Can Be Significantly Improved by a Single Biomedical Indicator
D. Testi (2004)
Comparison of the elastic and yield properties of human femoral trabecular and cortical bone tissue.
Harun H. Bayraktar (2004)
Subject-specific finite element models of long bones: An in vitro evaluation of the overall accuracy.
F. Taddei (2006)
Mechanistic fracture criteria for the failure of human cortical bone
R. K. Nalla (2003)
Trabecular bone modulus-density relationships depend on anatomic site.
E. Morgan (2003)
High-resolution finite element models with tissue strength asymmetry accurately predict failure of trabecular bone.
G. Niebur (2000)
The modified super-ellipsoid yield criterion for human trabecular bone.
Harun H. Bayraktar (2004)
Effect of local density changes on the failure load of the proximal femur
Z. M. Oden (1999)
Subject-specific finite element models can accurately predict strain levels in long bones.
E. Schileo (2007)
In vitro replication of spontaneous fractures of the proximal human femur.
L. Cristofolini (2007)
The mechanical properties of bone.
F. G. Evans (1969)
Short Term In Vivo Precision of Proximal Femoral Finite Element Modeling
Dianna D. Cody (2004)
Tensile and compressive stress yield criteria for cancellous bone.
S. Cowin (2005)
This paper is referenced by
Development of computational biomechanical tools to assess the performance of the resurfaced hip joint
A. Dickinson (2011)
Are plasticity models required to predict relative risk of lag screw cut-out in finite element models of trochanteric fracture fixation?
Jérôme M. Goffin (2014)
QCT-based failure analysis of proximal femurs under various loading orientations
Majid Mirzaei (2015)
Finite Element Prediction and Experimental Verification of the Failure Pattern of Proximal Femur using Quantitative Computed Tomography Images
Majid Mirzaei (2012)
The use of digital image correlation in the biomechanical area: a review
M. Palanca (2016)
Maximum principal strain as a criterion for prediction of orthodontic mini-implants failure in subject-specific finite element models.
M. H. Albogha (2016)
Patient-Specific Bone Multiscale Modelling, Fracture Simulation and Risk Analysis—A Survey
Amadeus C S de Alcântara (2019)
Performance of the resurfaced hip. Part 2: The influence of prosthesis stem design on remodelling and fracture of the femoral neck
Alexander S Dickinson (2010)
How accurately can we predict the fracture load of the proximal femur using finite element models?
Sven van den Munckhof (2014)
Developing CT based computational models of pediatric femurs.
X. Li (2015)
Experimental validation of finite elements model in hip fracture and its clinical applicability.
Ricardo Larraínzar-Garijo (2019)
Development of Subject-Specific Proximal Femur Finite Element Models Of Older Adults with Obesity to Evaluate the Effects of Weight Loss on Bone Strength
SL Schoell (2018)
Computer and experimental analyses of the stress state in the cement hip joint endoprosthesis body.
S. Tabaković (2014)
On prediction of the compressive strength and failure patterns of human vertebrae using a quasi-brittle continuum damage finite element model.
Zahira Nakhli (2019)
Opportunistic Screening for Osteoporosis Using Computed Tomography: State of the Art and Argument for Paradigm Shift
L. Lenchik (2018)
Relationships Between Femoral Strength Evaluated by Nonlinear Finite Element Analysis and BMD, Material Distribution and Geometric Morphology
He Gong (2012)
Material mapping strategy to improve the predicted response of the proximal femur to a sideways fall impact.
W. Enns-Bray (2018)
Modeling the Neck for Impact Scenarios
D. Cronin (2018)
Experimental validation of finite element modelling on tibia with osteogenesis imperfecta
H. Y. Tan (2019)
Quantitative computed tomography-based finite element analysis predictions of femoral strength and stiffness depend on computed tomography settings.
D. Dragomir-Daescu (2015)
Characterisation of trabecular bone behaviour under impact
B. Rosli (2019)
Analysis of trabecular bone mechanical properties from magnetic resonance images
Z. Zabolizadeh (2012)
Finite element analysis of pedestrian lower limb fractures by direct force: the result of being run over or impact?
Z. Li (2013)
Multiscale investigation of the functional properties of the human femur
L. Cristofolini (2008)
Specimen-specific modeling of hip fracture pattern and repair.
Azhar A. Ali (2014)
Numerical Modelling of Femur Fracture and Experimental Validation Using Bone Simulant
Miguel Marco (2017)
Geometry reconstruction method for patient-specific finite element models for the assessment of tibia fracture risk in osteogenesis imperfecta
Christiane Caouette (2016)
A new approach to prevent contralateral hip fracture: Evaluation of the effectiveness of a fracture preventing implant.
Marek Szpalski (2015)
Subject-specific finite element model with an optical tracking system in total hip replacement surgery
Brad P Miles (2015)
An Anisotropic Analysis of Human Femur Bone with Walking Posture: Experimental and Numerical Analysis
Ritu Painkra (2018)
Improving the Hip Fracture Risk Prediction Through 2D Finite Element Models From DXA Images: Validation Against 3D Models
M. Terzini (2019)
Mechanical testing of bones: the positive synergy of finite–element models and in vitro experiments
L. Cristofolini (2010)See more