Online citations, reference lists, and bibliographies.
← Back to Search

Non-invasive Cancer Detection Using Volatile Biomarkers: Is Urine Superior To Breath?

R. Becker
Published 2020 · Medicine

Cite This
Download PDF
Analyze on Scholarcy
In recent years numerous reports have highlighted the options of chemical breath analysis with regard to non-invasive cancer detection. Certain volatile organic compounds (VOC) supposedly present in higher amounts or in characteristic patterns have been suggested as potential biomarkers. However, so far no clinical application based on a specific set of compounds appears to exist. Numerous reports on the capability of sniffer dogs and sensor arrays or electronic noses to distinguish breath of cancer patients and healthy controls supports the concept of genuine cancer-related volatile profiles. However, the actual compounds responsible for the scent are completely unknown and there is no correlation with the potential biomarkers suggested on basis of chemical trace analysis. It is outlined that specific features connected with the VOC analysis in breath - namely small concentrations of volatiles, interfering background concentrations, considerable sampling effort and sample instability, impracticability regarding routine application - stand in the way of substantial progress. The underlying chemical-analytical challenge can only be met considering the severe susceptibility of VOC determination to these adverse conditions. Therefore, the attention is drawn to the needs for appropriate quality assurance/quality control as the most important feature for the reliable quantification of volatiles present in trace concentration. Consequently, the advantages of urine as an alternative matrix for volatile biomarker search in the context of diagnosing lung and other cancers are outlined with specific focus on quality assurance and practicability in clinical chemistry. The headspace over urine samples as the VOC source allows adapting gas chromatographical procedures well-established in water analysis. Foremost, the selection of urine over breath as non-invasive matrix should provide considerably more resilience to adverse effects during sampling and analysis. The most important advantage of urine over breath is seen in the option to partition, dispense, mix, spike, store, and thus to dispatch taylor-made urine samples on demand for quality control measures. Although it is still open at this point if cancer diagnosis supported by non-invasively sampled VOC profiles will ultimately reach clinical application the advantages of urine over breath should significantly facilitate urgently required steps beyond the current proof-of-concept stage and towards standardisation.
This paper references
The possibility of inventing new technologies in the detection of cancer by applying elements of the canine olfactory apparatus.
A. Pomerantz (2015)
Diagnostic biomarkers for lung cancer prevention.
R. Gasparri (2018)
Noninvasive detection of lung cancer by analysis of exhaled breath
A. Bajtarevic (2009)
Canine scent detection in the diagnosis of lung cancer: revisiting a puzzling phenomenon
R. Ehmann (2011)
Accuracy and Methodologic Challenges of Volatile Organic Compound–Based Exhaled Breath Tests for Cancer Diagnosis: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis
G. Hanna (2018)
The “olfactory fingerprint”: can diagnostics be improved by combining canine and digital noses?
G. Lippi (2020)
Exploring the potential of NTME/GC-MS, in the establishment of urinary volatomic profiles. Lung cancer patients as case study
P. Porto-Figueira (2018)
Detection of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) from exhaled breath as noninvasive methods for cancer diagnosis
Xiaohua Sun (2015)
Study of the art: canine olfaction used for cancer detection on the basis of breath odour. Perspectives and limitations.
T. Jezierski (2015)
Detection of cancer through exhaled breath: a systematic review
A. Krilaviciute (2015)
Exhaled volatile organic compounds in patients with non-small cell lung cancer: cross sectional and nested short-term follow-up study
D. Poli (2005)
The application of statistical methods using VOCs to identify patients with lung cancer.
A. Ulanowska (2011)
Strengths, Weaknesses, and Opportunities of Diagnostic Breathomics in Pleural Mesothelioma—A Hypothesis
K. Lamote (2014)
Suitability of different polymer bags for storage of volatile sulphur compounds relevant to breath analysis.
P. Mochalski (2009)
Organic metabolites in exhaled human breath--a multivariate approach for identification of biomarkers in lung disorders.
E. M. Gaspar (2009)
A review of the volatiles from the healthy human body.
B. D. L. de Lacy Costello (2014)
Assessment of the exhalation kinetics of volatile cancer biomarkers based on their physicochemical properties.
A. Amann (2014)
Can dogs smell lung cancer? First study using exhaled breath and urine screening in unselected patients with suspected lung cancer
T. Amundsen (2014)
Cancer sniffer dogs: how can we translate this peculiarity in laboratory medicine? Results of a pilot study on gastrointestinal cancers
C. Panebianco (2017)
Use of synthetic urine as a matrix substitute for standard and quality control materials in the clinical assessment of iodine by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry.
Carrie J Haglock-Adler (2014)
Volatile organic compounds in breath as markers of lung cancer: a cross-sectional study
M. Phillips (1999)
Solid phase microextraction for analysis of alkanes and aromatic hydrocarbons in human breath.
H. Yu (2005)
Breath analysis in respiratory diseases: state-of-the-art and future perspectives
P. Finamore (2019)
Olfactory detection of cancer by trained sniffer dogs: A systematic review of the literature
F. Pirrone (2017)
Cancer odor in the blood of ovarian cancer patients: a retrospective study of detection by dogs during treatment, 3 and 6 months afterward
G. Horvath (2013)
Quantitative breath analysis of volatile organic compounds of lung cancer patients.
Geng Song (2010)
Olfactory detection of human bladder cancer by dogs: proof of principle study
C. Willis (2004)
Breath gas concentrations mirror exposure to sevoflurane and isopropyl alcohol in hospital environments in non-occupational conditions.
M. Castellanos (2016)
Diagnostic Accuracy of Canine Scent Detection in Early- and Late-Stage Lung and Breast Cancers
Michael McCulloch (2006)
Volatile S-nitrosothiols and the typical smell of cancer.
W. Schröder (2015)
Exhaled volatile organic compounds discriminate patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease from healthy subjects
V. Besa (2015)
The volatilome – investigation of volatile organic metabolites (VOM) as potential tumor markers in patients with head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSCC)
P. Opitz (2018)
Determination of volatile organic compounds in exhaled breath of patients with lung cancer using solid phase microextraction and gas chromatography mass spectrometry
M. Ligor (2009)
Discrimination of cancerous and non-cancerous cell lines by headspace-analysis with PTR-MS
C. Brunner (2010)
SPME in clinical, pharmaceutical, and biotechnological research – How far are we from daily practice?
W. Filipiak (2019)
Identification of volatile lung cancer markers by gas chromatography–mass spectrometry: comparison with discrimination by canines
B. Buszewski (2012)
Olfactory detection of prostate cancer by dogs sniffing urine: a step forward in early diagnosis.
J. Cornu (2011)
Breath gas aldehydes as biomarkers of lung cancer
P. Fuchs (2010)
Breath biomarkers for lung cancer detection and assessment of smoking related effects--confounding variables, influence of normalization and statistical algorithms.
S. Kischkel (2010)
A non-invasive approach to explore the discriminatory potential of the urinary volatilome of invasive ductal carcinoma of the breast
Khushman Taunk (2018)
Clinical use of exhaled volatile organic compounds in pulmonary diseases: a systematic review
K. V. D. van de Kant (2012)
Training and Validating a Portable Electronic Nose for Lung Cancer Screening
R. V. D. van de Goor (2018)
Review and Comparison of Cancer Biomarker Trends in Urine as a Basis for New Diagnostic Pathways
Carmen Bax (2019)
Exhaled Breath Analysis for Lung Cancer Detection Using Ion Mobility Spectrometry
H. Handa (2014)
The human volatilome: volatile organic compounds (VOCs) in exhaled breath, skin emanations, urine, feces and saliva.
A. Amann (2014)
Changes in urine headspace composition as an effect of strenuous walking
D. Samudrala (2015)
Urinary Volatile Organic Compounds for the Detection of Prostate Cancer
T. Khalid (2015)
Exhaled breath analysis for lung cancer.
A. Dent (2013)
Headspace measurements of irradiated in vitro cultured cells using PTR-MS
C. Brunner (2011)
Accuracy of volatile urine biomarkers for the detection and characterization of lung cancer
P. Mazzone (2015)
Investigation of cell culture volatilomes using solid phase micro extraction: Options and pitfalls exemplified with adenocarcinoma cell lines.
K. Schallschmidt (2015)
Data interpretation in breath biomarker research: pitfalls and directions.
W. Miekisch (2012)
2-Aminoacetophenone as a potential breath biomarker for Pseudomonas aeruginosa in the cystic fibrosis lung
Amy J Scott-Thomas (2010)
Breath Analysis: A Systematic Review of Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs) in Diagnostic and Therapeutic Management of Pleural Mesothelioma
A. Catino (2019)
Determination of aldehydes in exhaled breath of patients with lung cancer by means of on-fiber-derivatisation SPME-GC/MS.
D. Poli (2010)
Phase-resolved real-time breath analysis during exercise by means of smart processing of PTR-MS data
H. Schwoebel (2011)
Electronic nose: a non-invasive technology for breath analysis of diabetes and lung cancer patients.
B. Behera (2019)
Measurement of volatile organic compounds in exhaled breath as collected in evacuated electropolished canisters.
J. Pleil (1995)
A breath test for malignant mesothelioma using an electronic nose
Elaine. Chapman (2011)
Comparison of volatile organic compounds from lung cancer patients and healthy controls-challenges and limitations of an observational study.
K. Schallschmidt (2016)
A review of exhaled breath: a key role in lung cancer diagnosis.
D. Marzorati (2019)
Exhaled breath condensate: a comprehensive update
H. Ahmadzai (2013)
A study of the volatile organic compounds exhaled by lung cancer cells in vitro for breath diagnosis
X. Chen (2007)
Exhaled breath condensate biomarkers for lung cancer.
Annalisa Campanella (2019)
Acetonitrile and benzene in the breath of smokers and non-smokers investigated by proton transfer reaction mass spectrometry (PTR-MS)
A. Jordan (1995)
Detection of lung cancer with volatile markers in the breath.
M. Phillips (2003)
A quantitative study of the influence of inhaled compounds on their concentrations in exhaled breath.
P. Španěl (2013)
Is olfactory detection of human cancer by dogs based on major histocompatibility complex-dependent odour components?--A possible cure and a precocious diagnosis of cancer.
S. Balseiro (2006)

Semantic Scholar Logo Some data provided by SemanticScholar