Establishing Nationally Representative Benchmarks Of Farm-gate Nitrogen And Phosphorus Balances And Use Efficiencies On Irish Farms To Encourage Improvements.
I. Thomas, C. Buckley, E. Kelly, E. Dillon, J. Lynch, B. Moran, T. Hennessy, P. Murphy
Published 2020 · Chemistry, Medicine
Download PDFAnalyze on Scholarcy
Agriculture faces considerable challenges of achieving more sustainable production that minimises nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) losses and meets international obligations for water quality and greenhouse gas emissions. This must involve reducing nutrient balance (NB) surpluses and increasing nutrient use efficiencies (NUEs), which could also improve farm profitability (a win-win). To set targets and motivate improvements in Ireland, nationally representative benchmarks were established for different farm categories (sector, soil group and production intensity). Annual farm-gate NBs (kg ha-1) and NUEs (%) for N and P were calculated for 1446 nationally representative farms from 2008 to 2015 using import and export data collected by the Teagasc National Farm Survey (part of the EU Farm Accountancy Data Network). Benchmarks for each category were established using quantile regression analysis and percentile rankings to identify farms with the lowest NB surplus per production intensity and highest gross margins (€ ha-1). Within all categories, large ranges in NBs and NUEs between benchmark farms and poorer performers show considerable room for nutrient management improvements. Results show that as agriculture intensifies, nutrient surpluses, use efficiencies and gross margins increase, but benchmark farms minimise surpluses to relatively low levels (i.e. are more sustainable). This is due to, per ha, lower fertiliser and feed imports, greater exports of agricultural products, and for dairy, sheep and suckler cattle, relatively high stocking rates. For the ambitious scenario of all non-benchmark farms reaching the optimal benchmark zone, moderate reductions in farm nutrient surpluses were found with great improvements in profitability, leading to a 31% and 9% decrease in N and P surplus nationally, predominantly from dairy and non-suckler cattle. The study also identifies excessive surpluses for each level of production intensity, which could be used by policy in setting upper limits to improve sustainability.
This paper references
Reducing agricultural nutrient surpluses in a large catchment - Links to livestock density.
A. Svanbäck (2019)
Developing farm-level sustainability indicators for Ireland using the Teagasc National Farm Survey
M. Ryan (2016)
Sources of nitrogen and phosphorus emissions to Irish rivers and coastal waters: Estimates from a nutrient load apportionment framework.
Eva Mockler (2017)
Modeling the Nitrogen and Phosphorus Inputs and Outputs of Financially Optimal Irish Beef Production Systems
P. Crosson (2007)
Seasonal exports of phosphorus from intensively fertilised nested grassland catchments.
Ciaran Lewis (2013)
Th e Dutch Approach to the Implementation of the Nitrate Directive: Explaining the Inevitability of its Failure
S. A. Wright (2008)
Global agriculture and nitrous oxide emissions
D. Reay (2012)
Permissible manure and fertilizer use in dairy farming systems on sandy soils in The Netherlands to comply with the Nitrates Directive target
J. J. Schroeder (2007)
A carrying capacity framework for soil phosphorus and hydrological sensitivity from farm to catchment scales.
Rachel Cassidy (2019)
Environmental impacts of innovative dairy farming systems aiming at improved internal nutrient cycling: A multi-scale assessment.
Wim de Vries (2015)
Identifying contrasting influences and surface water signals for specific groundwater phosphorus vulnerability.
P-E Mellander (2016)
A model for technical inefficiency effects in a stochastic frontier production function for panel data
G. Battese (1995)
Approaches and uncertainties in nutrient budgets: implications for nutrient management and environmental policies
O. Oenema (2003)
Patterns and processes of phosphorus transfer from Irish grassland soils to rivers—integration of laboratory and catchment studies
P. Jordan (2005)
Assessing the risk of phosphorus transfer to high ecological status rivers: Integration of nutrient management with soil geochemical and hydrological conditions.
William M Roberts (2017)
The relevance of spatial scales in nutrient balances on dairy farms
Maricke M.W.J. van Leeuwen (2019)
Influence of stormflow and baseflow phosphorus pressures on stream ecology in agricultural catchments.
M. Shore (2017)
Whole-Farm Nutrient Mass Balance Benchmarks for New York Dairies
Sebastian Cela (2014)
Nutrient balances influence hydrologic losses of nitrogen and phosphorus across agricultural fields in northwestern Ohio
Brittany R. Hanrahan (2019)
Nitrogen use efficiency: A potential performance indicator and policy tool for dairy farms
J. M. Powell (2010)
Application of a double bootstrap to investigation of determinants of technical efficiency of farms in Central Europe
L. Latruffe (2008)
Dairy farm nutrient management model: 2. Evaluation of different strategies to mitigate phosphorus surplus
Pekka Huhtanen (2011)
Evaluation of Soil Tests for Predicting Nitrogen Mineralization in Temperate Grassland Soils
Noeleen T. McDonald (2014)
Prospects for Minimizing Phosphorus Excretion in Ruminants by Dietary Manipulation
H. Valk (2000)
Characterising phosphorus transfers in rural catchments using a continuous bank-side analyser
P. Jordan (2007)
Farm gate level nitrogen balance and use efficiency changes post implementation of the EU Nitrates Directive
Cathal Buckley (2015)
Effect of offering dairy cows diets differing in phosphorus concentration over four successive lactations: 2. Health, fertility, bone phosphorus reserves and nutrient utilisation.
C P Ferris (2010)
Effect of stocking rate on pasture production, milk production, and reproduction of dairy cows in pasture-based systems.
K. A. Macdonald (2008)
Developing the EU Farm Accountancy Data Network to derive indicators around the sustainable use of nitrogen and phosphorus at farm level
Cathal Buckley (2015)
Effect of offering dairy cows diets differing in phosphorus concentration over four successive lactations: 1. Food intake, milk production, tissue changes and blood metabolites.
C P Ferris (2010)
Groundwater nitrate reduction versus dissolved gas production: A tale of two catchments.
Eoin McAleer (2017)
Nitrogen balance and use efficiency on twenty-one intensive grass-based dairy farms in the South of Ireland
Eugen Mihailescu (2014)
Development and adoption of new technologies to increase the efficiency and sustainability of pasture-based systems
Paddy French (2015)
SyNE: An improved indicator to assess nitrogen efficiency of farming systems
Olivier Godinot (2014)
A model of nitrogen efficiency in contrasting grass-based dairy systems.
W. Ryan (2011)
Application of data envelopment analysis to measure technical efficiency on a sample of Irish dairy farms
E. Kelly (2012)
Intensification, nitrogen use and recovery in grazing-based dairy systems
K. Stott (2016)
Phosphorus (P) management in the ‘De Marke’ dairy farming system
H. Aarts (2004)
Potential development of Irish agricultural sustainability indicators for current and future policy evaluation needs.
J. Lynch (2019)
Modelling representative and coherent Danish farm types based on farm accountancy data for use in environmental assessments
R. Dalgaard (2006)
Soil tests for predicting nitrogen supply for grassland under controlled environmental conditions
Noeleen T. McDonald (2014)
Benchmarking performance in the irrigation and drainage sector: a tool for change
H. Malano (2004)
Incidental nutrient transfers: Assessing critical times in agricultural catchments using high-resolution data.
Mairead Shore (2016)
Statistical modelling of nitrogen use efficiency of dairy farms in Flanders
E. Ramírez (2011)
An evaluation of whole farm nitrogen balances and related indices for efficient nitrogen use
J. Schröder (2003)
Milk production, estimated phosphorus excretion, and bone characteristics of dairy cows fed different amounts of phosphorus for two or three years.
Z. Wu (2001)
Environmental farm accounting: The case of the dutch nutrients accounting system
J. Breembroek (1996)
Improving nitrogen management on grassland on commercial pilot dairy farms in the Netherlands
J. Oenema (2012)
Estimation and determinants of phosphorus balance and use efficiency of dairy farms in Northern Ireland: A within and between farm random effects analysis
A. Adenuga (2018)
Flow paths and phosphorus transfer pathways in two agricultural streams with contrasting flow controls
Per‐Erik-E. Mellander (2015)
Nutrient management in New Zealand pastures— recent developments and future issues
R. Monaghan (2007)
The relationship between milk production and farm-gate nitrogen surplus for the Waikato region, New Zealand.
P. Beukes (2012)
Too much of a good thing
M. Sutton (2011)
Transfers of phosphorus within three dairy farming systems receiving varying inputs in feeds and fertilizers
P. Withers (2004)
Quantities of mineral N in soil and concentrations of nitrate‐N in groundwater in four grassland‐based systems of dairy production on a clay‐loam soil in a moist temperate climate
J. Humphreys (2008)
The potential to reduce the risk of diffuse pollution from agriculture while improving economic performance at farm level
C. Buckley (2013)
More food, low pollution (mo fo lo Po): a grand challenge for the 21st century.
E. Davidson (2015)
Evaluation of the Dutch implementation of the nitrates directive, the water framework directive and the national emission ceilings directive
Hans JM van Grinsven (2016)
Improving the identification of hydrologically sensitive areas using LiDAR DEMs for the delineation and mitigation of critical source areas of diffuse pollution.
I. A. Thomas (2016)
The Dutch Mineral Accounting System and the European Nitrate Directive: implications for N and P management and farm performance
C.J.M. Ondersteijn (2002)
Long-term effects of feeding diets without mineral phosphorus supplementation on the performance and phosphorus excretion in high-yielding dairy cows
N. Odongo (2007)
The Nitrogen Balancing Act: Tracking the Environmental Performance of Food Production
E. McLellan (2018)
Agriculture as a phosphorus source for eutrophication in the north‐west European countries, Norway, Sweden, United Kingdom and Ireland: a review
B. Ulén (2007)
Effect of dietary phosphorus content on milk production and phosphorus excretion in dairy cows
C. Wang (2013)
Farm-gate nitrogen balances on intensive dairy farms in the south west of Ireland
M. Treacy (2008)
Agrimonde – Scenarios and Challenges for Feeding the World in 2050
S. Paillard (2014)
Peak Phosphorus: Clarifying the Key Issues of a Vigorous Debate about Long-Term Phosphorus Security
D. Cordell (2011)
Phosphorus management on Irish dairy farms post controls introduced under the EU Nitrates Directive
Cathal Buckley (2016)
Nutrient balance at chain level: a valuable approach to benchmark nutrient losses of milk production systems
Wenhua Mu (2016)
Variable response to phosphorus mitigation measures across the nutrient transfer continuum in a dairy grassland catchment
P.N.C. Murphy (2015)
Sustainable value assessment of farms using frontier efficiency benchmarks.
Steven Van Passel (2009)
Stream water quality in intensive cereal cropping catchments with regulated nutrient management
A. Melland (2012)
The scope for regulatory incentives to encourage increased efficiency of input use by farmers.
A. Barnes (2009)
The seasonality of phosphorus transfers from land to water: implications for trophic impacts and policy evaluation.
P. Jordan (2012)
Linking changes in nutrient load source apportionment to estuarine responses: an Irish perspective
Sorcha Ní Longphuirt (2016)
Implementation of the EU Nitrates Directive in the Republic of Ireland — A view from the farm
C. Buckley (2012)
Food security and sustainable intensification
H. Godfray (2014)
Identification of farmer characteristics and farm strategies explaining changes in environmental management and environmental and economic performance of dairy farms
C.J.M. Ondersteijn (2003)
Effect of varying the phosphorus content of dairy cow diets on losses of phosphorus in overland flow following surface applications of manure.
S. M. O’Rourke (2010)
Economic sustainability of agricultural holdings in Poland in the context of their environmental impact
Wioletta Wrzaszcz (2016)
Element balances as a tool for sustainable nutrient management: a critical appraisal of their merits and limitations within an agronomic and environmental context
I. Öborn (2003)
A sub-field scale critical source area index for legacy phosphorus management using high resolution data
I. A. Thomas (2016)
Nutrient budgeting as an approach to improving nutrient management on Australian dairy farms
C. Gourley (2007)
Characterization of nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium mass balances of dairy farms in New York State.
S. Cela (2014)
A review of farm level indicators of sustainability with a focus on CAP and FADN
A. Diazabakana (2014)
Farm gate nitrogen surpluses and nitrogen use efficiency of specialized dairy farms in Flanders: Evolution and future goals
F. Nevens (2006)
Nitrogen and phosphorus surpluses on Danish dairy and pig farms in relation to farm characteristics
A. H. Nielsen (2005)
Quantification of phosphorus transport from a karstic agricultural watershed to emerging spring water.
Per-Erik Mellander (2013)
Does balanced phosphorus fertilisation sustain high herbage yields and phosphorus contents in alternately grazed and mown pastures?
Jantine van Middelkoop (2016)
Environmental assessment tools for the evaluation and improvement of European livestock production systems
N. Halberg (2005)
Sustainability indicators for improved assessment of the effects of agricultural policy across the EU: Is FADN the answer?
Edel Kelly (2018)
Farm structure or farm management: effective ways to reduce nutrient surpluses on dairy farms and their financial impacts
C.J.M. Ondersteijn (2003)
Assessing the sustainability of Irish agriculture
Emma J. Dillon (2010)
Farm level environmental indicators; are they useful?: An overview of green accounting systems for European farms
N. Halberg (2005)
Measuring progress in agricultural sustainability to support policy-making
Emma Jane Dillon (2016)
A phosphorus budget for Northern Ireland: inputs to inland and coastal waters
R. Smith (2005)
Efficiency analysis for organic agricultural producers: the role of soil-improving inputs.
L. Lohr (2007)
Economic impacts of nitrogen and phosphorus use efficiency on nineteen intensive grass-based dairy farms in the South of Ireland
Elena Mihailescu (2015)
Farm-gate phosphorus balances and soil phosphorus concentrations on intensive dairy farms in the south-west of Ireland.
Eimear M. Ruane (2014)
A system N balance for a pasture-based system of dairy production under moist maritime climatic conditions
William S. Burchill (2016)
A comprehensive framework to assess the sustainability of nutrient use in global livestock supply chains
Aimable Uwizeye (2016)
Benchmarking the economic, environmental and societal performance of Dutch dairy farms aiming at internal recycling of nutrients
Mark A. Dolman (2014)
Eco-efficient approaches to land management: a case for increased integration of crop and animal production systems
R. J. Wilkins (2007)
Economic modelling of an integrated grazed and conserved perennial ryegrass forage production system
Eoghan Finneran (2012)
This paper is referenced by
Assessing Sustainability Performance at the Farm Level: Examples from Greek Agricultural Systems
Irene Tzouramani (2020)