Online citations, reference lists, and bibliographies.
Please confirm you are human
(Sign Up for free to never see this)
← Back to Search

A Critical Assessment Of The High-Performance Paradigm

J. Godard
Published 2004 · Economics

Save to my Library
Download PDF
Analyze on Scholarcy
Share
This paper assesses research on the effects of high-performance systems on employer, worker and union outcomes. It concludes that, compared with what has long been thought of as good management practice, claims that these systems yield superior performance outcomes may be unwarranted, and their implications for both workers and unions are at best uncertain. Conventional explanations for these findings are found to be insufficient. Alternative explanations involving the nature of the employment relation are proposed, and the need for an alternative paradigm, which promotes legal and institutional reforms, is established.
This paper references
10.1177/001979399104400204
The Impact on Economic Performance of a Transformation in Workplace Relations
Joel Cutcher-Gershenfeld (1991)
Technology and wage structures: implications for establishment wage structures
P. Cappelli (1996)
10.2307/25143610
Choosing Sides: Unions and the Team Concept
D. Wells (1988)
The foundations of human resource management in Britain: evidence from the Workplace Employee Relations Survey
L. de Menezes (2002)
10.1080/095851998341170
Workplace reforms, managerial objectives and managerial outcomes: The perceptions of Canadian IR/HRM managers
J. Godard (1998)
10.1111/1467-8543.00251
Advocates, Critics and Union Involvement in Workplace Partnership: Irish Airports
W. Roche (2002)
10.5465/256741
The Impact of Human Resource Management Practices on Turnover, Productivity, and Corporate Financial Performance
Mark A. Huselid (1995)
10.2307/2393660
On the Line at Subaru-Isuzu: The Japanese Model and the American Worker
L. Graham (1995)
10.1111/0019-8676.00220
Employee Perceptions of Job Influence and Organizational Participation Employee Perceptions
R. Delbridge (2001)
Commitment and Conflict: Worker Resistance to HRM in the Microelectronics Industry
A. Mckinlay (1996)
10.1111/1467-8543.00268
'High-Performance' Management Practices, Working Hours and Work-Life Balance
Michael White (2003)
The Canadian Workplace Transition
G. Betcherman (1994)
Works Councils in Western Europe: From Consultation to Participation
W. Streeck (1995)
What works at work
C. Ichniowski (1996)
Workplace Innovations in Canada. Ottawa: Economic Council of Canada
J. Mansell (1987)
10.1111/1467-8543.00197
Partnership at Work: Mutuality and the Balance of Advantage
D. Guest (2001)
10.1080/095851997341333
The challenge of change: the positive agenda of the TGWU
John Fisher (1997)
10.1111/1467-8543.00135
Human Resource Management and Performance in the UK Hotel Industry
K. Hoque (1999)
10.1080/00050068508256160
New forms of work organization
D. Gunzburg (1985)
An IR perspective on the high-performance paradigm
J. Delaney (2001)
A Working Nation
D. Ellwood (2000)
Quality of working life and human resource outcomes'. Industrial Relations
S J Havlovic (1991)
Measurement error in research of human resources and firm performance
B. Gerhart (2000)
The human equation
J. Pfeffer (1998)
10.1057/JORS.1993.76
The Nissan Enigma: Flexibility at Work in the Local Economy
G. K. Rand (1993)
10.1037//1076-8998.4.2.108
The impact of lean production and related new systems of work organization on worker health.
P. Landsbergis (1999)
As reported in a personal correspondence with the author, however, there were statistically significant correlations between his HPP measure and a number of these dependent variables
10.1111/1467-8543.00188
Beyond the High-Performance Paradigm? An Analysis of Variation in Canadian Managerial Perceptions of Reform Programme Effectiveness
J. Godard (2001)
10.5860/choice.44-1621
The New American Workplace
R. Drago (1993)
10.2307/2654029
Works Councils: Consultation, Representation, and Cooperation in Industrial Relations
J. Pontusson (1997)
10.1111/J.1468-232X.1989.TB00733.X
Joint Participation Programs: Self-help or Suicide for Labor?
Anil Verma (1989)
10.1023/A:1016941914876
High Commitment Management in the U.K.: Evidence from the Workplace Industrial Relations Survey, and Employers' Manpower and Skills Practices Survey
S. Wood (1998)
10.1177/001979399504800201
Human Resource Bundles and Manufacturing Performance: Organizational Logic and Flexible Production Systems in the World Auto Industry
John Paul Macduffie (1995)
10.1111/1467-8543.00089
THE POLITICS OF PARTNERSHIP ? INNOVATION IN EMPLOYMENT RELATIONS IN THE SCOTTISH SPIRITS INDUSTRY
Abigail Marks (1998)
10.1177/001979390005300201
Work Reorganization in an Era of Restructuring: Trends in Diffusion and Effects on Employee Welfare
P. Osterman (2000)
10.3386/W5333
The Effects of Human Resource Management Practices on Productivity: A Study of Steel Finishing Lines
Casey Ichniowski (1995)
10.2307/2393320
The New Unionism: Employee Involvement in the Changing Corporation.
A. Lawrence (1990)
10.1177/001979399204600109
Product Quality Improvement through Employee Participation: The Effects of Unionization and Joint Union-Management Administration
W. Cooke (1992)
10.2307/3089250
Manufacturing Advantage: Why High-Performance Work Systems Pay off
Charles Koeber (1999)
10.1111/J.1468-232X.1991.TB00799.X
Quality of Work Life and Human Resource Outcomes
S. Havlovic (1991)
Low involvement work practices and business performance
D. Lewin (2001)
10.2307/2393374
Tightening the Iron Cage: Concertive Control in Self-Managing Teams
J. Barker (1993)
10.1111/J.1468-232X.1996.TB00420.X
Workplace Transformation and the Disposable Workplace: Employee Involvement in Australia
R. Drago (1996)
10.1111/J.1468-232X.1996.TB00411.X
The Performance Effects of Modular Production in the Apparel Industry
P. Berg (1996)
10.1111/0019-8676.00204
Editor's Introduction to “The Unemployment Effects of Minimum Wages: Evidence from a Prespecified Research Design”
D. Levine (2001)
Employees and high-performance work systems
H. Ramsay (2001)
10.7202/051206AR
Changing Work Systems, Changing Social Relations? A Canadian General Motors Plant
L. Clarke (1997)
Unions and management by stress
M. Parker (1995)
From high hopes to disillusionment: the evolution of worker attitudes at Mitsubishi Motors
R. Bruno (2000)
10.2307/2393856
Accounting for Teamwork: A Critical Study of Group-Based Systems of Organizational Control.
M. Ezzamel (1998)
Technology and skill requirements: implications for establishment wage structures
P. Cappelli (1996)
10.1177/001979390105400228
The Effect of High-Performance Work Practices on Employee Earnings in the Steel, Apparel, and Medical Electronics and Imaging Industries
T. Bailey (2001)
THE DETERMINANTS OF HIGH PERFORMANCE WORK SYSTEMS: CROSS-SECTIONAL AND LONGITUDINAL ANALYSES
Mark A. Huselid (1997)
10.1111/J.1748-8583.1999.TB00200.X
Human resource management - the workers' verdict
D. Guest (1999)
10.2307/41165742
Competitive Advantage Through People
J. Pfeffer (1994)
10.1007/BF02685861
Employee involvement programs: The noninvolvement of unions revisited
R. Allen (1996)
Union militancy and social partnership
J. Kelly (1996)
Productivity enhancing innovations in work organization, compensation, and employee participation in the union vs. the non-union sectors
P. Voos (1994)
10.1111/1468-232X.00300
Do Labor Laws Matter? The Density Decline and Convergence Thesis Revisited
J. Godard (2003)
10.1017/S0143814X00005596
National Diversity, Regime Competition and Institutional Deadlock: Problems in Forming a European Industrial Relations System
W. Streeck (1992)
10.2307/2522791
Collective bargaining and industrial relations : from theory to policy and practice
Daniel Mitchell (1981)
10.1111/1468-2370.00020
Human resource management and performance
S. Wood (1999)
10.7202/050832AR
Are Strong Unions Compatible with the New Model of Human Resource Management
D. Wells (1993)
10.2307/2150919
The New Unionism: Employee Involvement in the Changing Corporation
Fred Thompson (1988)
10.5465/256228
Self-Esteem and Task Performance in Quality Circles
J. Brockner (1986)
10.2307/144440
The Nissan Enigma: Flexibility at Work in a Local Economy
M. Cenzatti (1992)
10.1080/713769651
High-involvement work systems and performance outcomes: the strength of variable, contingent and context-bound relationships
P. Edwards (2001)
10.1177/001872679805100403
High Commitment Management in the U.K.: Evidence from the Workplace Industrial Relations Survey, and Employers' Manpower and Skills Practices Survey
S. Wood (1998)
The impact of high-performance work systems, implementation effectiveness, and alignment on shareholder wealth
G. Becker (1997)
High-performance work practices and firm performance: a synthesis of research and managerial implications
M. Huselid (1998)
10.1016/S0031-9406(10)60633-5
The Future of the Trade Unions
R. Griffin (1994)
10.2307/2524713
Working for the Japanese: Inside Mazda's American Auto Plant
Joseph J. Fucini (1990)
10.1111/0019-8676.21997002
Two Routes to Team Production: Saturn and Chrysler Compared
H. Shaiken (1997)
10.1111/J.1748-8583.1999.TB00201.X
Best practice and best fit: chimera or cul‐de‐sac?
John R Purcell (1999)
10.1177/001979399404700202
How Common is Workplace Transformation and Who Adopts it?
P. Osterman (1994)
10.1177/001979398603900403
The Effects of Corporate Strategy and Workplace Innovations on Union Representation
T. Kochan (1986)
10.1111/J.1748-8583.2001.TB00029.X
Teamworking: a new dynamic in the pursuit of management control
John F. Geary (2001)
10.1080/09585199600000117
High commitment management and unionization in the UK
S. Wood (1996)
10.1057/9780230524583_2
The Future of Trade Unions
R. Hyman (2004)
10.1177/001979399805200106
“Flexible” Workplace Practices: Evidence from a Nationally Representative Survey
M. Gittleman (1998)
Do "High-Performance" Work Practices Improve Establishment-Level Outcomes?.
Peter Cappelli (2001)
10.2307/2667059
Modern Manors: Welfare Capitalism since the New Deal
Sanford M. Jacoby (1997)
10.1111/0019-8676.491997012
Whither Strategic Choice: Do Managerial IR Ideologies Matter?
J. Godard (1997)
10.1177/001979398704000408
Employee Involvement: The Implications of Noninvolvement by Unions
Anil Verma (1987)
10.2307/2654100
What Workers Want
D. Clawson (1999)
The Canadian Workplace in Transition Kingston: Ontario
G. Betcherman (1994)
10.1177/001979390105400402
High Performance and the Transformation of Work? The Implications of Alternative Work Practices for the Experience and Outcomes of Work
J. Godard (2001)
10.1111/J.1468-232X.1996.TB00409.X
What works at work : overview and assessment
Casey Ichniowski (1996)
Managing Human Resources and Industrial Relations
J. Storey (1993)
10.1111/1467-8543.00178
Employees and High-PerformanceWork Systems:Testinginside the Black Box
H. Ramsay (2000)
10.3386/W8050
The Anatomy of Employee Involvement and its Effects on Firms and Workers
R. Freeman (2000)
10.5465/256705
Effects of human resource systems on manufacturing performance and turnover
Jeffrey B. Arthur (1994)
Highperformance’ management practices, working hours and work–life balance
M. White (2003)
10.1111/1467-6486.00153
In Search of Commitment‐Oriented Human Resource Management Practices and the Conditions that Sustain Them
W. Roche (1999)
Do ‘high-performance’ work practices improve establishment level outcomes?
D. Neumark (2001)
Human Resource Management: Rhetorics and Realities
K. Legge (1995)
Human Resource Management and Business Performance.
S. Wood (2002)
10.1016/0024-6301(92)90400-v
Machine that changed the world
C. Staff (1993)
10.2307/2522343
Personnel Policies in Large Nonunion Companies
Fred K. Foulkes (1980)
Limits and possibilities for HRM in an age of management accountancy
P. Armstrong (1989)
10.1007/S12122-003-1025-Y
Learning from Saturn
Anthony V. Baltakis (2003)
10.1111/1467-6486.00154
Do Implementation Processes and Rationales Matter? The Case of Workplace Reforms
J. Godard (1999)
10.1111/1468-232X.00245
Institutional Environments, Employer Practices, and States in Liberal Market Economies
J. Godard (2002)
Union voting intentions: HR policies, organizational characteristics, and attitudes
A. Young (1998)
10.1111/J.1744-6570.2000.TB02418.X
Measurement error in research on human resources and firm performance: How much error is there and how does it influence effect size estimates?
Barry A. Gerhart (2000)
10.1111/1467-8543.00183
Union Decline in Britain
S. Machin (2000)
10.1093/acprof:oso/9780198292333.001.0001
Life on the line in contemporary manufacturing
R. Delbridge (1998)
Work organization, unions, and economic performance
R. Marshall (1992)
10.1177/001979399404700301
The Survival of Employee Participation Programs in Unionized Settings
A. Eaton (1994)
10.1177/001979390005300307
Reflections on the “High Performance” Paradigm's Implications for Industrial Relations as a Field
J. Godard (2000)
10.1177/001979390005300401
Explaining Variation in Workplace Restructuring: The Role of Local Union Capabilities
Ann C. Frost (2000)
Editor's Introduction to 'The Employment Effects of Minimum Wages
D Levine (1995)
10.1111/1468-2338.00069
Can Labour-management Co-operation Deliver Jobs and Justice?
C. Heckscher (1997)
10.1111/J.1468-232X.1996.TB00413.X
Methodological Issues in Cross‐Sectional and Panel Estimates of the Human Resource‐Firm Performance Link
Mark A. Huselid (1996)
10.2307/2072577
The New Unionism: Employee Involvement in the Changing Corporation.
M. Poole (1990)
10.2307/2654241
Just Another Car Factory? Lean Production and Its Discontents
Robert J. Hironimus-Wendt (1998)
10.1111/1467-8543.00273
Human Resource Management and Corporate Performance in the UK
D. Guest (2003)
10.5465/AMBPP.1997.4981101
THE IMPACT HIGH PERFORMANCE WORK SYSTEMS, IMPLEMENTATION EFFECTIVENESS, AND ALIGNMENT WITH STRATEGY ON SHAREHOLDER WEALTH.
Mark A. Huselid (1997)
Collective Bargaining and Industrial Relations; From Theory to Policy and Practice. Homewood, Ill.: Irwin
T. Kochan (1980)
10.1016/S0923-4748(00)00035-7
Manufacturing Advantage: Why High-Performance Work Systems Pay Off
Gil A. Preuss (2001)
10.1007/S12122-001-1038-3
Human resource management practices and worker desires for union representation
J. Fiorito (2001)
10.1177/001872675100400101
Some Social and Psychological Consequences of the Longwall Method of Coal-Getting
E. Trist (1951)
10.1177/001979399204500306
The Link between Business Strategy and Industrial Relations Systems in American Steel Minimills
Jeffrey B. Arthur (1991)
10.1016/S1053-4822(01)00047-X
An industrial relations perspective on the high-performance paradigm
John T Delaney (2001)
10.1111/1467-8543.00204
Updating the Determinants of Firm Performance: Estimation using the 1998 UK Workplace Employee Relations Survey
J. Addison (2001)
10.2307/3552181
Labour Unions, Workplace Rights and Canadian Public Policy
J. Godard (2003)
Reinventing the Workplace. Washington: Brookings Institution
D. Levine (1995)
Human resource management practices and worker desire for representation
J. Fiorito (2001)
Alternatives to Lean Production
C. Berggren (1992)
10.1111/J.0019-8676.2004.00319.X
Is There a Wage Payoff to Innovative Work Practices?
Michael J. Handel (2000)
10.1111/J.0019-8676.2004.00320.X
High-Involvement Management and Pay in Britain
J. Forth (2004)
Reflections on the high-performance paradigm’s implications for IR as a field
J. Delaney (2000)
10.1111/J.1468-232X.1988.TB01011.X
Quality Circle Survival: An Exploratory Analysis
R. Drago (1988)
10.1177/095001701400438170
Team Membership and the Experience of Work in Britain: An Analysis of the WERS98 Data
B. Harley (2001)
Alternative Work Practices and Quit Rates: Methodological Issues and Empirical Evidence for Canada
R. Morissette (2003)
10.2307/256712
The Impact of Human Resource Management on Organizational Performance: Progress and Prospects
B. Becker (1996)
10.1111/J.1468-232X.1987.TB00698.X
The Impact of Human Resource Policies on Union Organizing
Jack Fiorito (1987)
The Mutual Gains Enterprise
P. Osterman (1994)
High-performance and the transformation of work? The implications of alternative work practices for the nature and experience of work
J Godard (1997)



This paper is referenced by
10.1108/01437721211234138
Healthy personnel policies
T. Eriksson (2012)
10.1016/J.JBUSRES.2016.10.016
Empirical insights on the nature of synergies among HRM policies - An analysis of an ethics-oriented HRM system
M. Guerci (2017)
Mrs. MRF. Aqeela, Ramakrishnan Vivek
. Aqeela (2018)
10.1111/j.1468-2338.2011.00646.x
From the British Worker Question to the Impact of HRM: Understanding the Relationship between Employment Relations and Economic Performance
S. Procter (2012)
10.1108/13527591211207699
Graphical profiling of team working through participatory research
Monica Rolfsen (2012)
Employee coverage of high-performance work systems in Spain: a comparative analysis before and during economic retrenchment
G. Pruneda (2014)
10.1002/JOB.623
The relationship between multiple levels of learning practices and objective and subjective organizational financial performance
L. D. Milia (2009)
Internal promotions versus external recruitement : evidence in industrial plants
P. Ángel (2003)
10.7202/016491AR
La gestion à « haute performance » dans la fonction publique québécoise : Pratiques mobilisatrices et cohérence
D. Beaupré (2007)
10.1111/BJIR.12433
Strategic Dilemmas: How Managers Use HR Practices to Meet Multiple Goals
J. Lee (2019)
The impact of the quality of the work environment on employees’ intention to quit
R. Markey (2012)
Trends in job quality : evidence from French and British linked employer-employee data
Zinaida Salibekyan (2016)
10.1111/1748-8583.12144
Shut the fridge door! HRM alignment, job redesign and energy performance
S. Christina (2017)
10.1177/0019793914564966
Efficiency in Employee-Owned Enterprises
Saioa Arando (2015)
Is there a European convergence in HRM practices? A cluster analysis of the high-performance paradigm across 31 countries
Pedro Ferreira (2016)
10.1111/j.1468-2338.2010.00585.x
Thatcherism Delayed? The Irish Crisis and the Paradox of Social Partnership
T. Mcdonough (2010)
10.2139/ssrn.1937490
Does High Involvement Management Improve Worker Wellbeing?
Petri Bockerman (2011)
10.1016/J.PUBREV.2011.11.006
Most valuable stakeholders: The impact of employee orientation on corporate financial performance
N. D. Bussy (2012)
10.1111/j.1467-8543.2010.00793.x
Institutions and the Management of Human Resources: Incentive Pay Systems in France and Great Britain
D. Marsden (2009)
10.1177/001979390906200203
Institutional Environments, Work and Human Resource Practices, and Unions: Canada versus England
J. Godard (2009)
High-involvement work systems : their effect on employee turnover and organisational performance in New Zealand organisations
Sarah-jane P Doody (2007)
THREE ESSAYS ON THE "DARK SIDE" OF TEAMS
Kevin S. Cruz (2011)
10.1111/j.1468-005x.2008.00214.x
The limits of high performance work systems in unionised craft-based work settings: HPWS in unionised craft-based work settings
J. McBride (2008)
Linking organisational systems to performance in Australian hospitals
S. Lawrence (2010)
10.21446/SCG_UFRJ.V9I2.13319
Contrato Psicológico em Empresas de Alta Performance: A Dor e a Delícia de ser um Trabalhador Contemporâneo Psychological Contract in High Performance Companies: The Pain and the Pleasure of being a Contemporary Worker
D. Neves (2014)
10.1016/J.IEDEEN.2017.12.001
Socially responsible HR practices and their effects on employees’ wellbeing: Empirical evidence from Catalonia, Spain
D. Celma (2018)
A survey of the relationship between human resource management practices and performance of small scale manufacturing firms in Nairobi’s industrial area - Kenya
Roselyne A Midii (2013)
10.7176/ejbm/11-6-07
E-HRM Practices and its impact on Organizational Performance: A study on the Manufacturing industry in Bangladesh
Md. Tanjil Ahmed (2019)
An Investigation of Job Embeddedness in a Male-Dominated Industry: What Makes Female Employees Stay?
Johanne Reboli Bredesen (2019)
Dynamic capabilities, leadership behaviour and performance of manufacturing firms in Nairobi, Kenya
Thomas O. Nyachanchu (2018)
10.1111/1744-7941.12153
Control and involvement HR practices in Indian call centres: still searching for answers
Subra Ananthram (2018)
10.1108/hrmid.2008.04416bad.004
Contested resources: unions, employers and the adoption of new work practices in US and UK telecommunications
Matias Ramirez (2008)
See more
Semantic Scholar Logo Some data provided by SemanticScholar