A Comparison Of Normative Data For The Trail Making Test From Several Countries: Equivalence Of Norms And Considerations For Interpretation.
Alberto Luis Fernández, Bernice A Marcopulos
Published 2008 · Psychology, Medicine
Download PDFAnalyze on Scholarcy
The Trail Making Test may not be equivalent across cultures, i.e., differences in the scores across different cultures may not reveal real differences in the ability of the subjects on the construct being measured. In order to assess this hypothesis, normative samples from ten different countries were compared. Age decade subgroups across samples were ranked based on mean time taken to complete each part of the task. Large Z scores differences were found between these samples when comparing the first with the second, and the last in the rank. These differences were significant even when age and education were comparable across samples. Following Van de Vijver & Tanzer (1997), several possible sources of bias were identified. Incomparability of samples and administration differences were the most likely factors accounting for differences. Because of the lack of validity studies in the countries considered, no firm conclusions could be obtained regarding construct bias. Although the TMT may be measuring visual scanning, psychomotor speed and mental flexibility, normative data from different countries and cultures are not equivalent which might lead to serious diagnostic errors.
This paper references
Norms for older
R. Siegert (1997)
Norms for older
R. Siegert (1997)
Trail Making Across Languages
Tatia M C Lee (2000)
Neuropsychological test performance in illiterate subjects.
Feggy Ostrosky-Solís (1998)
Normative data for eight neuropsychological tests based on a Danish sample.
Hanne Nielsen (1989)
Normative data for eight neuropsychological tests, gathered from a random sample of Danes aged 64 to 83 years
Henry Nielsen (1995)
The illiterate brain. Learning to read and write during childhood influences the functional organization of the adult brain.
A Castro-Caldas (1998)
Assessment of calculation and number processing using the EC301 battery: cross-cultural normative data and application to left- and right-brain damaged patients.
Georges Dellatolas (2001)
Houeto Jean-Luc (2005)
Flemish normative data on common neuropsychological tests: Influence of age, education, and gender.
Engelien Lannoo (1997)
The relation of the trail making test to organic brain damage.
Ralph M. Reitan (1955)
Creating Interpretation Guidelines for the Hebrew Trail Making Test
Bradley N. Axelrod (2000)
Are Trail Making and Color Trails Tests of Equivalent Constructs?
Tatia M C Lee (2000)
Trail Making Test: issues in normative data selection.
Vicki M. Soukup (1998)
What's Become of Research on the Cultural Basis of Cognitive Development?.
Barbara Rogoff (1995)
Neuropsychological test performance in Aruaco Indians: an exploratory study.
Ayda Ardila (2001)
Neuropsychological functioning in Alzheimer's disease and vascular dementia.
Patricia A. Boyle (1998)
Cognitive function in UK community-dwelling African Caribbean elders: normative data for a test battery.
Rob Stewart (2001)
Norms for older New Zealanders on the Trail Making Test
R. Siegert (1997)
Normative Data for a Brief Neuropsychological Screening Battery
Ola A. Selnes (1991)
Equivalence of the Color Trails Test and Trail Making Test in nonnative English-speakers.
Anthony T. Dugbartey (2000)
Cross-Cultural Neuropsychological Assessment : Theory and Practice
Victor Nell (2001)
Analysis of the elements of attention: A neuropsychological approach
Allan F. Mirsky (2005)
Epilepsy and nonepileptic attack disorder.
Eugene J. Rankin (1996)
Estandarización y validez conceptual del Test del Trazo en una muestra de adultos argentinos [Normative data and conceptual validity of the Trail Making Test in a sample of Argentinean adults
A. Fernández (2002)
Color Trails Test: Professional manual
L. D’Elia (1994)
A Compendium of Neuropsychological Tests: Administration, Norms, and Commentary
Otfried Spreen (1991)
Multinational neuropsychological testing: performance of children and adults.
Miriam Levav (1998)
Psykologhandbok vid alkoholkliniken. (Manual for psychologists.) Karolinska sjukhuset, 4:e upplagan
H. Bergman (1988)
Performance on Original and a Chinese Version of Trail Making Test Part B: A Normative Bilingual Sample
L Lu (2000)
Trail making test: normative values from 287 normal adult controls
Anna Rita Giovagnoli (2005)
Handbook of Normative Data for Neuropsychological Assessment.
Caren R. DeBernardo (2000)
You can't take it with you why ability assessments don't cross cultures
Patricia M. Greenfield (1997)
Effects of Age and Intelligence on Trail Making Test Performance and Validity
W R Goul (1970)
Bias and equivalence in cross-cultural assessment: An overview.
Fons van de Vijver (2004)
Introduction to cognitive rehabilitation
McKay Moore Sohlberg (1989)
Neuropsychological assessment, 3rd ed.
Muriel Deutsch Lezak (1995)
Comparison of the Trail Making and Color Trails Tests in a Chinese Context: A Preliminary Report
Tatia M. C. Lee (2000)
This paper is referenced by
Mental time travel in mild cognitive impairment
Sara Coelho (2019)
Normative data for the Mini-Mental State Examination, the Free and Cued Selective Reminding Test and the Isaacs Set Test for an older adult Mexican population: The Coyoacán Cohort Study
Hind Mokri (2013)
Assessing Learning Strategy Use in English- and Spanish-Speaking Older Adults During Verbal Learning Tests
Cynthia Funes (2015)
How Older Adults Cope with Cognitive Complexity and Environmental Constraints during Dual-Task Walking: The Role of Executive Function Involvement
Roberta Forte (2019)
Cross-Cultural Applicability of the Montreal Cognitive Assessment (MoCA): A Systematic Review.
Ciarán O'Driscoll (2017)
Effects of Alcohol Hangover on Cognitive Performance: Findings from a Field/Internet Mixed Methodology Study
Andrew Scholey (2019)
An Iranian Normative Sample of the Color Trails Test
Mahgol Tavakoli (2015)
Neurological and neuropsychological outcome after resection of craniopharyngiomas.
Henrik Giese (2019)
Alternative Type of the Trail Making Test in Nonnative English-Speakers: The Trail Making Test-Black & White
Hyun Jung Kim (2014)
Construct and Concurrent Validity of the Spanish Adaptation of the Boston Naming Test
Alberto Luis Fernández (2015)
Tilburg University Bias and real differences in cross-cultural differences
Fons J R van de Vijver (2010)
Repeatable Battery for the Assessment of Neuropsychological Status (RBANS): Normative Data for Older Adults.
Michelle Olaithe (2019)
The Adaptation and Validation of an Arabic Version of the Cornell Scale for Depression in Dementia (A-CSDD).
Sonia Ben Jemaa (2019)
How to Assess Executive Functions in a Low-Educated and Multicultural Population Using a Switching Verbal Fluency Test (the TFA-93) in Neurodegenerative Diseases?
Pauline Narme (2019)
Trail Making Test : Normative data for the Latin American Spanish speaking adult population
J. C. Arango-Lasprillaa (2015)
Adult Age and Cultural Differences in Performance on the Weekly Calendar Planning Activity (WCPA)
Joan Toglia (2017)
A Comparison of Three types of Trail Making Test in the KoreanElderly: Higher Completion Rate of Trail Making Test-Black and Whitefor Mild Cognitive Impairment
Karyeong Kim (2016)
Lost in time : a neurophilosophical quest to understand the perception of time in MCI patients
Sara Cunha Leal Rocha Coelho (2017)
Trail Making Test Part A and Brain Perfusion Imaging in Mild Alzheimer's Disease
Aki Shindo (2013)
Robust Norms for Neuropsychological Tests of Verbal Episodic Memory in Australian Women
Alicia M. Goodwill (2019)
Overgeneral Memory in Binge Eating Disorder is Linked to Binge Frequency
Jennifer Svaldi (2011)
The relationship between age, cognitive function, cardiovascular fitness, and serum blood markers of cognitive function in healthy older adults
David Bellar (2009)
The Effects of Aging, Malingering, and Traumatic Brain Injury on Computerized Trail-Making Test Performance
David L. Woods (2015)
DOCTORAT DE L'UNIVERSITÉ BORDEAUX 2 6SpFLDOLWp : Psychologie
Bordeaux Segalen (2013)
A Comparison of Three types of Trail Making Test in the Korean Elderly: Higher Completion Rate of Trail Making Test-Black and White for Mild Cognitive Impairment
Karyeong Kim (2016)
Trail Making Test: Normative data for the Latin American Spanish speaking adult population.
J.C. Arango-Lasprilla (2015)
Risky decision making in adults with ADHD.
Swantje D Matthies (2012)
Estudo das respostas neuropsicológicas associadas à utilização de campos magnéticos cerebrais no córtex pré- frontal em sujeitos normativos
Marta Isabel Ferreira Duarte (2012)
Regression-based normative data and equivalent scores for Trail Making Test (TMT): an updated Italian normative study
Mattia Siciliano (2018)
The Shape Trail Test: Application of a New Variant of the Trail Making Test
Qianhua Zhao (2013)
Construct and Criterion Validity of the Rey Auditory Verbal Learning Test-Spanish Version in Adults with Traumatic Brain Injury
Cristobal Neblina (2012)
Trail Making Test: normative data for the Lebanese adult population.
Jessica Abi Chahine (2019)See more