Online citations, reference lists, and bibliographies.
← Back to Search

The Long History Of Molecular Electronics

Hyungsub Choi, Cyrus C. M. Mody
Published 2009 · Engineering

Cite This
Download PDF
Analyze on Scholarcy
Long before nanotechnology, the semiconductor industry was miniaturizing microelectronic components. Since the late 1950s, that industry's dominant material has been silicon. Yet there have always been competitors to silicon that supporters hope will upend the semiconductor industry. It is impossible to understand this industry without a more complete picture of these alternatives — how they come about, how they capture organizational support, why they fail. It is equally impossible to understand nanotechnology without a focus on these alternatives, since research communities devoted to perfecting them today form the backbone of the nanotechnology field. We trace the history of the longest lived silicon alternative — molecular electronics. Molecular electronics arose in the late 1950s as a visionary program conducted by Westinghouse on behalf of the Air Force. We attribute its failure to the difficulties inherent in matching a futuristic vision to a bureaucratically accountable, incremental program that could compete with silicon. Molecular electronics reappeared again at IBM in the 1970s and at the Naval Research Laboratory in the 1980s. In each of these incarnations, molecular electronics' charismatic champions failed to gain the organizational support to make it a mainstream technology. Only at the turn of the century, with new nanotechnology institutions and new models of industry—university collaboration, has some form of molecular electronics neared acceptance by the semiconductor industry.
This paper references
See Collins (2004) for a 30-year chronicle of Weber's rise and fall that parallels Carter's more compressed trajectory
Concepts and Capabilities of Molecular Electronics
Herwald (1960)
Molecular Electronics – Next-generationTechnology Hits an Early Mid-life Crisis
Service (2003)
Understanding Moore’s Law: Four Decades of Innovation (Philadelphia, PA: Chemical Heritage Foundation)
Brock (2006)
Few Biologists But Many Evangelicals Sign Anti-evolution Petition
Chang (2006)
Cramming More Components Onto Integrated Circuits
G. E. Moore (1998)
Technical Diversity and Technological Change in the American Semiconductor Industry
Daniel U Holbrook (1952)
Molecular Electronic Devices Offer Challenging Goal
J. Fox (1983)
According to the Semiconductor Industry Association, worldwide sales in the semiconductor industry in 2007 were US$256 billion. See
A rectifier, in this case, is merely a diode used in a circuit to convert alternating current into direct current
Bassett (2001) focuses on metal oxide semiconductor technology and the firms that engaged in its development
Riordan amp Hoddeson (1977)
Problems and Prospects of Future Electroactive Polymers and “Molecular
Carter (1979)
Technical Diversity and Technological Change in the American Semiconductor Industry, 1952–1965
Holbrook (1999)
Henderson claims that IBM sank more than a billion dollars into developing, but never adopting, X-ray lithography
The ManWho Cracked the Code to Everything’,Wired 10.06
Levy (2002)
Molecular Electronics -from Laboratory to Mass Production
Progress in digital integrated electronics
G. Moore (1975)
Executive Vice President) to C.J. Witting (Vice President)
J K Hodnette
Molecular Rectifiers
Aviram (1974)
Making Silicon Valley: Innovation and the Growth of High Tech, 1930-1970, by Christophe Lecuyer
C. Finn (2006)
Of life cycles real and imaginary : the unexpectedly long old age of optical lithography
R. Henderson (1995)
There's Plenty of Room at the Bottom
T. Quirk (2006)
A History of Modern Computing (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press)
Ceruzzi (1998)
Electronic Enterprise: Stories from the History of Westinghouse Electronic Systems' (printed by the Westinghouse Electronic Systems Division
Moore’s Law at 40’, in D.C. Brock (ed.) Understanding Moore’s Law: Four Decades of Innovation (Philadelphia, PA: Chemical Heritage Foundation)
Moore (2006)
The man who understood the Feynman machine.
Chris Toumey (2007)
The Chip: HowTwo Americans Invented the Microchip and Launched a Revolution (NewYork: Random House)
T. R. Reid (2001)
How Probe Microscopists Became Nanotechnologists
Cyrus C. M. Mody (2004)
International diffusion of technology : the case of semiconductors
J. Tilton (1971)
Physical Limits in Semiconductor Electronics
R. Keyes (1977)
Conductance of a Molecular Junction
M. Reed (1997)
Proposal for Molecular Electronics
Further Considerations on “Molecular
Carter (1980)
Molecular Electronics Will Change Everything
Rick Overton (2000)
Manufacturing knowledge in transit: Technical practice, organizational change, and the rise of the semiconductor industry in the United States and Japan, 1948--1960
Hyungsub Choi (2007)
Superconducting devices for digital systems
R. Keyes (1979)
Electronic devices in large systems
R. Keyes (2008)
Molecular Electronics’, Chemical and Engineering News
Chandross (1983)
A New Microscope for Microelectronics Research
I M J W Mackintosh
Molecular level fabrication techniques and molecular electronic devices
F. Carter (1983)
Extended orthogonally fused conducting oligomers for molecular electronic devices
J. Tour (1991)
Clean Rooms for Environmental Control
Molecules as Electronic Components: Some Basic Considerations,' IBM Archives, Press Release Collection, Research Division
Beyond the Red Brick Wall: Spintronics, Novelty, and Overthe-Horizon Technologies
Patrick Mccray
The Needs of the Air Force’, in NSIA–ARDC Conference on Molecular Electronics (Washington, DC: 13–14 November)
C. H. Lewis (1958)
Complexes of the cuprous halides with dialkyl acetylenes
F. L. Carter (1956)
The Integrated Circuit: A Case Study of Product Innovation in the Electronics Industry
H. Kleiman (1966)
Potentialities of the Micro Module Concept
R B Reade
Trading Places: How We Allowed the Japanese to Take the Lead
Clyde V Prestowitz (1988)
Mark Reed, interview with Cyrus Mody
Molecular Electronics’, Chemical and Engineering News
Siatkowski (1984)
Charge distribution and bonding in the series (CF3)2On (n = 0-3) and in CF3SCF3 deduced from gas-phase x-ray photoelectron spectroscopy. Evidence for double bonding in saturated compounds
P. Brant (1981)
For background on the disadvantage chemists at Yorktown felt in dealing with the dominant physicists we draw on Robert Hamers, interview with Cyrus Mody
Defense Products) to George C. Szklai (Assistant to Vice President, Engineering)
J F Regan
Molecular ElectronicsWill Change Everything’,Wired 8.07
Overton (2000)
Molecular Electronic Devices II (NewYork: M
Carter (1987)
Making Silicon Valley : innovation and the growth of high tech, 1930-1970
C. Lécuyer (2005)
Cost and performance of VLSI computing structures
C. Mead (1979)
Toward Organic Rectifers
Metzger (1987)
Vice President and General Manager, Baltimore Divisions) to D.W. Gunther (General Manager,Youngwood Semiconductor Department)
B M Brown
Wohltjen interview
Molecular Electronics
X. Luo (2009)
The Age of Spiritual Machines
R. Kurzweil (1999)
Molecules for memory, logic and amplification
A. Aviram (1988)
Molecular Point of View Reinventing Electronics
Howard Wolinsky
Automated Mass Output Sought for Micromodules
McLean (1960)
Evidence of switching and rectification by a single molecule effected with a scanning tunneling microscope
A. Aviram (1989)
Physical problems of small structures in electronics
R. Keyes (1972)
International Agricultural Research
N. Borlaug (2004)
Warren D. Niederhauser (1984)
Nano:The Emerging Science of Nanotechnology (Boston, MA: Little, Brown)
Regis (1995)
By 'off-beat' we mean publications that Carter's supervisors, some peers, and trade magazines such as Chemical and Engineering News treated as unwarranted speculation (Carter's contribution to Yates
Fundamental Limitations in Microelectronics -1
Carver A Mead (1972)
Establishing Moore's Law
Ethan Mollick (2006)
Josephson Computer Technology: An IBM Research Project
W. Anacker (1980)
Ratner interview
Chip Industry Sets a Plan for Life after Silicon
Markoff (2005)
Understanding Moore's Law—Four Decades of Innovation (David C. Brock, ed.)
J. Steehler (2007)
The NRL Program on Electroactive Polymers.
L. B. Lockhart (1979)
Integration of Circtuit Functions intO Solids.
S. W. Herwald (1960)
Further Considerations on "Molecular" Electronic Devices
Forrest L Carter (1980)
Searching for S-P Analogues of (SN)x
Forrest L Carter (1980)
The ColdWar and American Science: Military–Industrial–Academic Complex at MIT and Stanford (NewYork: Columbia
Leslie (1993)
A Model for Technological Change Applied to the Turbojet Revolution
E. Constant (1973)
More on Molecular Electronics
J. Heath (2004)
Fundamental limitations in microelectronics—I. MOS technology
B. Hoeneisen (1972)
Gravity’s Shadow:The Search for GravitationalWaves (Chicago, IL
Collins (2004)
Opening Remarks’, in F.L. Carter (ed.),Molecular
A. I. Schindler (1982)
Crystal Fire:A History of the Information Age (NewYork:W.W
Riordan (1997)
Air Arm Division)
J A Gerath
Vacuum Tube Technology and Enthusiasm in the World of Highend Radio
Kieran Downes
The eight functional blocks included: (1) audio amplifier; (2) video amplifier; (3) tuned amplifier; (4) multivibrators; (5) switches; (6) analog-to-digital converters
Does Nanotechnology Descend from Richard Feynman’s 1959Talk?
Toumey (2005)
Molecular Electronics: Commercial Insights
J. Tour (2003)
Toward the Digital Age: Research Labs, Start-up Companies, and the Rise of MOSTechnology (Baltimore, MD
Bassett (2001)
Integration of Circuit Functions
Herwald (1960)
Mini-mini Components: Turning Individual Molecules into Electronic Components
Munn was editor of the Journal of Molecular Electronics, which ran from 1985 through 1991 before merging with Chemtronics to form Advanced Materials for Optics and Electronics
The Age of Spiritual Machines (Harmondsworth, Middlesex: Penguin Books Ltd)
Kurzweil (1999)
Indeed, even the lowly vacuum tube continues to be better understood and improved by manufacturers of high-end audio equipment
Engines of Creation: the Coming Era of Nanotechnology
K. E. Drexler (1986)
Basic research within a military context : the Naval Research Laboratory and the Foundations of extreme ultraviolet and X-ray astronomy, 1923-1960
B. Hevly (1988)
Molecular Electronic Devices (NewYork: M
Carter (1982)
Molecular Electronics – Science and Technology (NewYork: Engineering Foundation)
Aviram (1989)
Beyond the Red BrickWall: Spintronics, Novelty, and Overthe-HorizonTechnologies’, unpublished paper for JointWharton-CHF Symposium on the Social Studies of Nanotechnology (Philadelphia, 7 June)
McCray (2007)
The molecular device computer: Point of departure for large scale cellular automata
F. Carter (1984)
Molecular Computers Are Far from Realization: Conference finds components are impossible to construct; promoters urge research to develop use of biological molecules as sensors
R. M. Baum (1983)
Arthur von Hippel: The Scientist and the Man
F. V. Hippel (2005)
R. Metzger (1999)
Integrated Circuitry, Micro-miniaturization and Molecular Electronics
Wolfgang W Gartner
Engines of Creation:The Coming Age of Nanotechnology (Garden City, NY: Doubleday)
Drexler (1986)
Recall the important role of the Signal Corps in early microelectronics programs such as micro-module
The Search for Organic Unimolecular Rectifers’, in A
Metzger (1991)
Molecular engineering
A. V. Hippel (1955)
The application of gas phase and solid state X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy to the investigation of derivatives containing the repeating SN unit
P. Brant (1980)
Gravity's Shadow: The Search for Gravitational Waves
Matthew Stanley (2005)
Will small be beautiful? Making policies for our nanotech future
W. Mccray (2005)
Government Support of Semiconductor Technology: Diverse Approaches and Information Flows
Daniel U Holbrook (1995)
AF Lab Chief Says Moletronics is on the Way
Electronic Design
Proposal for Molecular Electronics -Dendritic Approach' (Negotiation No. AAN-45106
Dendritic Germanium
Westinghouse Engineer
Trading Places: HowWe Allowed the Japanese to Take the Lead (NewYork: Basic Books)
Prestowitz (1988)
Problems and Prospects of Future Electroactive Polymers and "Molecular" Electronic Devices
Forrest L Carter (1979)
1984a) ‘Molecular Electronics
Carter (1984)
Special thanks to an anonymous reviewer for prompting this discussion
Electrons Away, or Tales of a Government Scientist
Harold A Zahl (1968)
Molecular level fabrication techniques and molecular electronics devices
F. Carter (1984)
Death Knell for Josephson?Why the Giant Turned Back from the Junction
Kehoe (1983)
Government Support of Semiconductor Technology: Diverse Approaches and Information Flows’, Business and Economic History
Holbrook (1995)
The Man Who Cracked the Code to Everything
Stephen Levy (2002)
See Holbrook (1995, 1999) for an elaboration of this point
amp Mackintosh (1964)
Air Arm Division) to S.W. Sampson (Chief, Components & Techniques Laboratory, AFCRC)
S W Herwald
Molecular Electronic: Its Impact on Manufacturing
T. W. Black (1963)
Molecular Engineering’, Science 123(3191): 315–17
Von Hippel (1956)
Searching for S-P Analogues of (SN)x’, in R.B
Carter (1980)
Materials Design and Molecular Understanding A Scientific Autobiography
Arthur R. von Hippel (1980)
Wohltjen interview; Bill Tolles, interview with Cyrus Mody
Alan Macdiarmid
Molecular disjunctions : staking claims at the nanoscale
A. Nordmann (2004)
Process Innovation and Learning by Doing in Semiconductor Manufacturing
N. Hatch (1998)
From a presentation by Robert Wisnieff at the SCI-CHF Innovation Day symposium
VacuumTubeTechnology and Enthusiasm in theWorld of Highend Radio’, unpublished paper for Physics
Downes (2006)
Making SiliconValley: Innovation and the Growth of High Tech (Cambridge
Lécuyer (2005)
A New Microscope for Microelectronics Research’,Westinghouse Engineer (November): 186–190
I. M. Mackintosh (1964)
How We Invented the Transistor
William Shockley
Physical limits in digital electronics
R. Keyes (1975)
Thermoelectric Properties of Some Cerium Sulfide Semiconductors from 4° to 1300°K
F. M. Ryan (1962)
Ultimate computing - biomolecular consciousness and nanotechnology
S. Hameroff (1987)
The Cold War and American Science: The Military-Industrial-Academic Complex at MIT and Stanford
R. Geiger (1993)
The search for organic unimolecular rectifiers
R. Metzger (2008)
The Career Job Reservation System. Is the Issuance System Best Serving the Needs of the Air Force
E. Marshall (1990)

This paper is referenced by
From Bench to Brand and Back: The Co-Shaping of Materials and Chemists in the Twentieth Century
P. Teissier (2017)
Nanoemulsions of Essential Oils: New Tool for Control of Vector-Borne Diseases and In Vitro Effects on Some Parasitic Agents
J. Echeverría (2019)
Soft nanotechnology: "structure" vs. "function".
G. Whitesides (2009)
Reconsidering human dignity in the new era
K. Zdravkova (2019)
Bounding an emerging technology: Para-scientific media and the Drexler-Smalley debate about nanotechnology
S. Kaplan (2011)
From Road to Lab to Math: The Co-Evolution of Technological, Regulatory, and Organizational Innovations for Automotive Crash Testing
P. Leonardi (2010)
University research commercialization in emerging economies: a glimpse into the ‘black box’
D. Chatterjee (2018)
Forming interdisciplinary expertise: one organization's journey on the road to translational nanomedicine
S. T. Ku (2012)
Fabrication, functionalization and electrical conductance modulation of nanoparticle based molecular electronic Nano-devices
Ishtiaq Hassan Wani (2018)
Large-Area, Ensemble Molecular Electronics: Motivation and Challenges.
A. Vilan (2017)
Nanotechnology, Anthropomorphic Matter and Human Machinery: An Exploration of the Longue Durée of Technological Vision
Åsa Boholm (2014)
Computing with molecules.
Randal E. Jones (2009)
New patterns of scientific growth: How research expanded after the invention of scanning tunneling microscopy and the discovery of Buckminsterfullerenes
Thomas Heinze (2013)
Industry Location Shift through Technological Change - A Study of the US Semiconductor Industry (1947-1987)
Jonathan D. Kowalski (2012)
Broad Concerns about Nanotechnology Patents: Symptoms and Diagnosis
T. Cottier (2012)
What has nanotechnology taught us about contemporary technoscience
R. Jones (2011)
Exploring the Nanotechnology Landscape for Competitive Advantage Using SAO-Mining
Roel C. Boekel (2017)
High-Yield Functional Molecular Electronic Devices.
Hyunhak Jeong (2017)
Modern Electrochemistry in Nanobiology and Sensorics
J. Soloducho (2014)
Transport through a benzene ring: A Green's function approach
Edson Costa Dias (2014)
The Future Of Nanotechnologies
V. Mangematin (2012)
Molecular rectifiers based on five-coordinate iron(iii)-containing surfactants.
C. Verani (2018)
On-Surface Synthesis of Single Conjugated Polymer Chains for Single-Molecule Devices
Yuji Okawa (2016)
Nanoparticle sintering in atomic layer deposition of supported catalysts: Kinetic modeling of the size distribution
F. Grillo (2018)
Crystallizing Innovation: The Emergence of the LCD at RCA, 1951-1976
B. Gross (2011)
Molecular Electronics: History and Fundamentals
Santiago Marqués-González (2016)
Qualitative and Quantitative Modeling of Molecules by Corralling Electronic States
David B. Green (2019)
Controlled chain polymerisation and chemical soldering for single-molecule electronics.
Y. Okawa (2012)
Connecting single conductive polymers to a single functional molecule
Yuji Okawa (2010)
Analytical solution of electronic transport through a benzene molecule using lattice Green's functions.
Edson Costa Dias (2015)
Scaling Moore’s Wall: A Public-Private Partnership in Search of a Technological Revolution
H. Khan (2015)
Lab-on-a-chip in The Netherlands-How can the development be understood and what can be expected of the future?
Rainer Ilgen (2012)
See more
Semantic Scholar Logo Some data provided by SemanticScholar