← Back to Search
A Realist Synthesis Of Cross-border Patient Movement From Low And Middle Income Countries To Similar Or Higher Income Countries
J. Durham, Sarah J Blondell
Published 2017 · Sociology, Business, Medicine
Download PDFAnalyze on Scholarcy
Patient travel across borders to access healthcare is becoming increasingly common and widespread. Patients moving from high income to middle income countries for healthcare is well documented, with patients seeking treatments that are cheaper or more readily available than at home. Less well understood is when patients move from one low income country to another or from a low income country to a higher income country. In this paper, a realist review was undertaken to explore why, in what contexts and how patients from lower income countries travel to countries with the same, or more advanced, economies for planned healthcare. Based on an initial scoping of the literature and discussions with key informants, we generated an initial theory and set of propositions about why, how, who and in what contexts people cross international borders for planned healthcare. We then systematically located and synthesized (1) peer-reviewed studies from the Scopus, Embase, Web of Science and Econlit databases; (2) non-indexed reports using key informants and Google; and (3) papers from the reference lists of included documents, to glean supportive or contradictory evidence for our initial propositions. As we reviewed the literature and extracted our data, we drew on the work of Pierre Bourdieu to understand the interplay between material and non-material capital and cognitive processes in decisions to cross borders for healthcare. Patient travel was largely undertaken due to a lack of services in the home country and/or unacceptability of local services, with decisions on when, and where, to travel, usually made within the patient’s social networks. They were able to travel via use of multiple resources, including social networks, economic and cultural capital, and habitus. Those patients with greater volumes of the aforementioned factors had greater healthcare options; however, even those with limited resources engaged in patient travel. Patient movement challenges traditional ways of thinking about public health and the notion of health systems contained within the nation state. Further research is needed to better understand the effects of patient travel, and how to harness the benefits of patient travel without exacerbating existing health inequalities.
This paper references
Realist review - a new method of systematic review designed for complex policy interventions
R. Pawson (2005)
En route: Transport and Embodiment in International Medical Travel Journeys Between Indonesia and Malaysia
M. Ormond (2015)
Large-system transformation in health care: a realist review.
A. Best (2012)
Rethinking health systems strengthening: key systems thinking tools and strategies for transformational change.
R. C. Swanson (2012)
Cross-border reproductive care: a future research agenda.
M. C. Inhorn (2011)
Value as a medical tourism driver
Hsiu‐Yuan Wang (2012)
Complicating Common Ideas about Medical Tourism: Gender, Class, and Globality in Yemenis’ International Medical Travel
B. Kangas (2011)
The Sociology of Markets
N. Fligstein (2007)
The Future Research Agenda
Catherine Barr (2012)
Medical tourism: assessing the evidence on treatment abroad.
N. Lunt (2010)
RAMESES publication standards: realist syntheses
G. Wong (2013)
Systems Thinking for Transformational Change in Health.
C. Willis (2014)
Expecting the unexpected: applying the Develop-Distort Dilemma to maximize positive market impacts in health.
D. Peters (2012)
The burden of pursuing treatment abroad: Three stories of medical travelers from Yemen
B. Kangas (2010)
A typology of cross-border patient mobility.
I. Glinos (2010)
Forms of Capital
P. Bourdieu (2002)
Assisted Reproductive Technologies and Fertility “Tourism”: Examples from Global Dubai and the Ivy League
Mph Marcia C. Inhorn (2012)
Realist synthesis: an introduction. ESRC Research Methods Programme. University of Manchester RMP Methods Paper 2
R Pawson (2004)
Health Policy Plan. 2012;27(suppl 4):iv44–53
DH Peters (2012)
Making health markets work better for poor people: the case of informal providers.
G. Bloom (2011)
Research protocol: a realist synthesis of cross-border patient mobility from low-income and middle-income countries
J. Durham (2014)
Patients without borders: Medical tourism and medical migration in Southern Africa, Migration
J Crush (2012)
Promoting medical tourism to India: messages, images, and the marketing of international patient travel.
V. Crooks (2011)
Poverty and Access to Health Care in Developing Countries
David H. Peters (2008)
A Framework for Exploring the Policy Implications of UK Medical Tourism and International Patient Flows
N. Lunt (2013)
Assessing the outcomes of participatory research: protocol for identifying, selecting, appraising and synthesizing the literature for realist review
J. Jagosh (2011)
Traveling for Medical Care in a Global World
B. Kangas (2010)
Retrospective appraisal of cancer patients from Vientiane Capital City, Lao People's Democratic Republic (PDR), seeking treatment in Thailand.
Kongmany Chaleunvong (2013)
Purchasing health services abroad: practices of cross-border contracting and patient mobility in six European countries.
I. Glinos (2010)
Medical tourism and policy implications for health systems: a conceptual framework from a comparative study of Thailand, Singapore and Malaysia
N. Pocock (2011)
The Science of Evaluation: A Realist Manifesto
M. Keary (2014)
Markets, information asymmetry and health care: towards new social contracts.
G. Bloom (2008)
On the Concept of Health Capital and the Demand for Health
M. Grossman (1972)
Prospects and Problems of Medical Tourism in Bangladesh
M. Mamun (2013)
A realist manifesto
Pawson R. The science of evaluation (2017)
Overcoming barriers to health service access: influencing the demand side.
T. Ensor (2004)
Africa's middle class women bring entrepreneurial opportunities in breast care medical tourism to South Africa.
F. Ahwireng-Obeng (2011)
The rise of a transnational healthcare paradigm: Thai hospitals at the crossroads of new patient flows
Audrey Bochaton (2013)
Making Fun out of Difference: Ethnicity–Race and Humour in a London School
Sarah Reid (2015)
Logic in Practice
T. G. (1934)
The future of health markets
S. Bennett (2014)
Protocol: a realist review of user fee exemption policies for health services in Africa
E. Robert (2012)
Outline of a theory of practice
P. Bourdieu (1972)
Global track , national vehicle : Transnationalism in medical tourism in
M Toyota (2013)
Strategies for engaging the private sector in sexual and reproductive health: how effective are they?
D. Peters (2004)
Country and lending groups
Evidence-based policy: a realist perspective: Sage publications
R. Pawson (2006)
South-South medical tourism and the quest for health in Southern Africa.
J. Crush (2015)
The impact of psychological distance on Chinese customers when selecting an international healthcare service country.
J. Zhang (2013)
Globalization and Reproductive Tourism in the United Arab Emirates
M. C. Inhorn (2010)
Transnational medical spaces: Opportunities and restrictions
G. Zanini (2013)
4. Principles of an Economic Anthropology
P. Bourdieu (2010)
Solidarity by demand? Exit and voice in international medical travel - the case of Indonesia.
M. Ormond (2015)
A framework for the study of access to medical care.
L. Aday (1974)
Internet-based medical education: a realist review of what works, for whom and in what circumstances
G. Wong (2010)
Improving access to quality care for female slum dwellers in urban Maharashtra, India: Researching the need for transformative social protection in health
J. Michielsen (2011)
Understanding how appraisal of doctors produces its effects: a realist review protocol
N. Brennan (2014)
Therapeutic Itineraries in a Global World: Yemenis and their search for biomedical treatment abroad
B. Kangas (2002)
Principles of an economic anthropology
P. Bourdieu (2005)
Bangladesh–India bilateral trade: An investigation into trade in services. Dhaka: South Asia Network of Economic Research Institutes (SANEI) Study Programme, Centre for Policy Dialogue
M. Rahman (2000)
South-South and North-South medical tourism: The case of South Africa, Travelling Well: Essays in Medical TourismTransdisciplinary transdisciplinaires en Studies in Population santé des populations
J Crush (2012)
Realist synthesis training materials
G Wong (2013)
Cross-border mobility and social networks: Laotians seeking medical treatment along the Thai border.
Audrey Bochaton (2015)
Pluralism and marketisation in the health sector : meeting health needs in contexts of social change in low and middle-income countries
G. Bloom (2001)
Realist synthesis - an introduction
R. Pawson (2004)
Transnational health care: from a global terminology towards transnational health region development.
T. Mainil (2012)
Patient-centred access to health care: conceptualising access at the interface of health systems and populations
Jean-Frédéric Lévesque (2013)
Access to Health Care in Contexts of Livelihood Insecurity: A Framework for Analysis and Action
B. Obrist (2007)
A time-responsive tool for informing policy making: rapid realist review
J. Saul (2013)
Improving Service Encounters through Resource Sensitivity: The Case of Health Care Delivery in an Appalachian Community
R. G. Lee (1999)
Evidence-based policy: The promise of
R Pawson (2002)
The movement of patients across borders: challenges and opportunities for public health.
Matthias Helble (2011)
Evidence-based Policy: A Realist Perspective
D. Anthony (2007)
Jennifer Largesystem transformation in health care : A realist review
A Best (2005)
Addressing access barriers to health services: an analytical framework for selecting appropriate interventions in low-income Asian countries.
B. Jacobs (2012)
Decision Factors in Medical Tourism: Evidence from Burmese Visitors to a Hospital in Bangkok
Nay Lynn Yin (2014)
Transformative Mixed Methods Research
D. Mertens (2010)
A cross-cultural study of perceptions of medical tourism among Chinese, Japanese and Korean tourists in Korea
J. Y. Yu (2012)
Evidence-based Policy: The Promise of `Realist Synthesis'
R. Pawson (2002)
No. 57: Patients without Borders: Medical Tourism and Medical Migration in Southern Africa
J. Crush (2012)
Policy guidance on threats to legislative interventions in public health: a realist synthesis
G. Wong (2011)
Doctors that Harm, Doctors that Heal: Reimagining Medicine in Post-Conflict Aceh, Indonesia
C. Smith (2015)
Neoliberal governance and international medical travel in Malaysia
R. Holliday (2014)
More than medical tourism: lessons from Indonesia and Malaysia on South–South intra-regional medical travel
M. Ormond (2017)
Global track, national vehicle: Transnationalism in medical tourism in Asia
M Toyota (2013)
Health systems, systems thinking and innovation.
R. Atun (2012)
Export of health services from developing countries: the case of Tunisia.
Marc Lautier (2008)
“I am From Busia!”: Everyday Trading and Health Service Provision at the Kenya–Uganda Border as Place-Making Activities
W. L. Allen (2013)
Everybody's business: Strengthening health systems to improve health outcomes: WHO's Framework for Action Geneva: World Health Organization
Handbook of Theory and Research for the Sociology of Education
J. G. Richardson (1986)
Giving birth across the border: the San Diego-Tijuana connection.
S. Guendelman (1992)
Exploring dimensions of access to medical care.
R. Andersen (1983)
Patient Mobility in the Global Marketplace: A Multidisciplinary Perspective
N. Lunt (2014)
Cultural capital and social inequality in health
T. Abel (2008)
Perceptions of an 'international hospital' in Thailand by medical travel patients: cross-cultural tensions in a transnational space.
A. Whittaker (2015)
Rich doctors and poor patients: Market failure and health care systems in developing countries
B. Ghosh (2008)
Understanding medical tourists: Word-of-mouth and viral marketing as potent marketing tools
Eugene Yeoh (2013)
Hope from Abroad in the International Medical Travel of Yemeni Patients
B. Kangas (2007)
Decisive factors in medical tourism destination choice: A case study of Isfahan, Iran and fertility treatments
F. Moghimehfar (2011)
Human resources for health in six healthcare arenas under stress: a qualitative study
J. Durham (2015)
Making markets work for the poor: rationale and practice
D. Elliot (2008)
Systems thinking for strengthening health systems in LMICs: need for a paradigm shift.
T. Adam (2012)
Development as Freedom
M. Turshen (2001)
Contemporary medical tourism: Conceptualisation, culture and commodification
J. Connell (2013)
This paper is referenced by
Cross-border medical travels from Cambodia: pathways to care, associated costs and equity implications.
M. Liverani (2020)
Cross-border healthcare and prognosis of HIV infection in the triple border Brazil-Paraguay-Argentina.
R. Zaslavsky (2019)
Korean and conventional medicine tourism industry trends as indicated in medical tourism advertisement images: qualitative research using data from medical Korea 2015
Jung-Hyun Lee (2018)