← Back to Search
Comparison Of Two Metaphyseal-fitting (short) Femoral Stems In Primary Total Hip Arthroplasty: Study Protocol For A Prospective Randomized Clinical Trial With Additional Biomechanical Testing And Finite Element Analysis
I. Tatani, A. Panagopoulos, I. Diamantakos, G. Sakellaropoulos, Sp. G Pantelakis, P. Megas
Published 2019 · Medicine
Download PDFAnalyze on Scholarcy
BackgroundTotal hip replacement has recently followed a progressive evolution towards principles of bone- and soft-tissue-sparing surgery. Regarding femoral implants, different stem designs have been developed as an alternative to conventional stems, and there is a renewed interest towards short versions of uncemented femoral implants. Based on both experimental testing and finite element modeling, the proposed study has been designed to compare the biomechanical properties and clinical performance of the newly introduced short-stem Minima S, for which clinical data are lacking with an older generation stem, the Trilock Bone Preservation Stem with an established performance record in short to midterm follow-up.Methods/designIn the experimental study, the transmission of forces as measured by cortical surface-strain distribution in the proximal femur will be evaluated using digital image correlation (DIC), first on the non-implanted femur and then on the implanted stems. Finite element parametric models of the bone, the stem and their interface will be also developed. Finite element predictions of surface strains in implanted composite femurs, after being validated against biomechanical testing measurements, will be used to assist the comparison of the stems by deriving important data on the developed stress and strain fields, which cannot be measured through biomechanical testing. Finally, a prospective randomized comparative clinical study between these two stems will be also conducted to determine (1) their clinical performance up to 2 years’ follow-up using clinical scores and gait analysis (2) stem fixation and remodeling using a detailed radiographic analysis and (3) incidence and types of complications.DiscussionOur study would be the first that compares not only the clinical and radiological outcome but also the biomechanical properties of two differently designed femoral implants that are theoretically classified in the same main category of cervico-metaphyseal-diaphyseal short stems. We can hypothesize that even these subtle variations in geometric design between these two stems may create different loading characteristics and thus dissimilar biomechanical behaviors, which in turn could have an influence to their clinical performance.Trial registrationInternational Standard Randomized Controlled Trial Number, ID: ISRCTN10096716. Retrospectively registered on May 8 2018.
This paper references
Bone remodeling characteristics of a short-stemmed total hip replacement.
Hsiang-Ho Chen (2009)
Current concepts, classification, and results in short stem hip arthroplasty.
F. Falez (2015)
Changes in strain distribution of loaded proximal femora caused by different types of cementless femoral stems.
R. Decking (2006)
Repeatability of digital image correlation for measurement of surface strains in composite long bones.
S. Väänänen (2013)
Stable, dependable fixation of short-stem femoral implants at 5 years.
R. Patel (2013)
Total hip arthroplasty with an uncemented tapered femoral component.
J. McLaughlin (2008)
Towards the standardization of in vitro load transfer investigations of hip prostheses
X. Ke (1999)
Strain pattern following surface replacement of the hip
M. Ganapathi (2008)
the positive synergy of finite-element models and in vitro experiments
L Cristofolini (2019)
Predictive value of early radiographic findings in cementless total hip arthroplasty femoral components: an 8- to 12-year follow-up.
C. Khalily (1998)
Uncemented porous-coated anatomic total hip replacement. Results at six years in a consecutive series.
Y. Kim (1993)
Traumatic arthritis of the hip after dislocation and acetabular fractures: treatment by mold arthroplasty. An end-result study using a new method of result evaluation.
W. Harris (1969)
Using digital image correlation to determine bone surface strains during loading and after adaptation of the mouse tibia.
P. Sztefek (2010)
An in vitro study of the strain distribution in human femora with anatomical and customised femoral stems.
P. O. Østbyhaug (2009)
Publisher's Note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations
A new method of classifying prognostic comorbidity in longitudinal studies: development and validation.
M. Charlson (1987)
Cross-sectional geometry of Pecos Pueblo femora and tibiae--a biomechanical investigation: I. Method and general patterns of variation.
C. Ruff (1983)
Kim JS Joo JH Park JW. A prospective short-term outcom Kim YH (2019)
Ectopic ossification following total hip replacement. Incidence and a method of classification.
A. Brooker (1973)
Accuracy of migration analysis in hip arthroplasty. Digitized and conventional radiography, compared to radiostereometry in 51 patients.
Henrik Malchau (1995)
A conservative femoral replacement for total hip arthroplasty. A prospective study.
B. Morrey (2000)
The Accuracy and Reproducibility of Radiographic Assessment of Stress-Shielding: A Postmortem Analysis*
C. Engh (2000)
Estimation of pelvis kinematics in level walking based on a single inertial sensor positioned close to the sacrum: validation on healthy subjects with stereophotogrammetric system
F. Bugané (2014)
Short bone-conserving stems in cementless hip arthroplasty.
H. Khanuja (2014)
Characterization of Femoral Component Initial Stability and Cortical Strain in a Reduced Stem-Length Design.
S. R. Small (2017)
Biomechanical evaluation of two types of short-stemmed hip prostheses compared to the trust plate prosthesis by three-dimensional measurement of micromotions.
A. Fottner (2009)
Perspectives on metaphyseal conservative stems
F. Falez (2008)
The Self-Administered Patient Satisfaction Scale for Primary Hip and Knee Arthroplasty
N. Mahomed (2011)
The importance of patient expectations in predicting functional outcomes after total joint arthroplasty.
N. Mahomed (2002)
Clinical Performance, Patient Reported Outcome, and Radiological Results of a Short, Tapered, Porous, Proximally Coated Cementless Femoral Stem: Results up to Seven Years of Follow-Up.
M. Ulivi (2018)
Roentgen stereophotogrammetry. Review of orthopedic applications.
J. Kärrholm (1989)
Estimation of spatial-temporal gait parameters in level walking based on a single accelerometer: Validation on normal subjects by standard gait analysis
F. Bugané (2012)
Finite element modelling of primary hip stem stability: the effect of interference fit.
M. R. Abdul-Kadir (2008)
Strain distribution in the proximal human femur. An in vitro comparison in the intact femur and after insertion of reference and experimental femoral stems.
Y. Kim (2001)
J Kärrholm (1989)
The short stem: a thinking man's alternative to surface replacement.
S. Stulberg (2008)
Short-stemmed uncemented femoral component for primary hip arthroplasty.
B. Morrey (1989)
A proposal for the study of cementless short-stem hip prostheses.
F. Gómez-García (2016)
Current trends in total hip arthroplasty.
C. Eingartner (2007)
Pre-clinical validation of joint prostheses: a systematic approach.
M. Viceconti (2009)
High Survival of Uncemented Proximally Porous-coated Titanium Alloy Femoral Stems in Osteoporotic Bone
J. Meding (2010)
In-vitro biomechanical evaluation of stress shielding and initial stability of a low-modulus hip stem made of β type Ti-33.6Nb-4Sn alloy.
Go Yamako (2014)
The use of an artificial femoral head for arthroplasty of the hip joint.
J. Judet (1950)
Extracting accurate strain measurements in bone mechanics: A critical review of current methods.
L. Grassi (2015)
Numerical simulation of the insertion process of an uncemented hip prosthesis in order to evaluate the influence of residual stress and contact distribution on the stem initial stability
Aida Georgeta Monea (2014)
Hydroxyapatite-coated Titanium Porous Plasma Spray Tapered Stem: Experience at 15 to 18 Years
A. Lombardi (2006)
Influence of shoes and heel strike on the loading of the hip joint.
G. Bergmann (1995)
The effect of modular tapered fluted stems on proximal stress shielding in the human femur.
William P. Hnat (2009)
Validation study of WOMAC: a health status instrument for measuring clinically important patient relevant outcomes to antirheumatic drug therapy in patients with osteoarthritis of the hip or knee.
N. Bellamy (1988)
Mapping the strain distribution on the proximal femur with titanium and flexible-stemmed implants using digital image correlation.
E. Tayton (2010)
Long-term Results and Bone Remodeling After THA With a Short, Metaphyseal-fitting Anatomic Cementless Stem
Young-Hoo Kim (2014)
Mechanical validation of whole bone composite femur models.
L. Cristofolini (1996)
How accurately can subject-specific finite element models predict strains and strength of human femora? Investigation using full-field measurements.
L. Grassi (2016)
Comparison of porous-coated titanium femoral stems with and without hydroxyapatite coating.
Y. Kim (2003)
Long-Term Results of Use of the Anatomic Medullary Locking Prosthesis in Total Hip Arthroplasty*
C. Engh (1997)
Power 3: a flexible statistical power analysis program for the social, behavioral, and biomedical sciences
F Faul (2007)
Porous-coated hip replacement. The factors governing bone ingrowth, stress shielding, and clinical results.
C. Engh (1987)
Mechanical and biological results of short-stem hip implants: consideration on a series of 74 cases
S. Barreca (2014)
Total Hip Stem Classification System
H. S. T. McTighe (2014)
The influence of design parameters on cortical strain distribution of a cementless titanium femoral stem.
R. Gillies (2002)
Experimental investigation of bone remodelling using composite femurs.
V. Waide (2003)
The short stem: promises and pitfalls.
S. D. Stulberg (2013)
Primary stability of custom and anatomical uncemented femoral stems: a method for three-dimensional in vitro measurement of implant stability.
P. O. Østbyhaug (2010)
Hydroxyapatite-coated Femoral Components: 15-Year Minimum Followup
W. Capello (2006)
A clinical study of the results of cementless total hip replacement
Y. Itami (2004)
Minimum ten-year follow-up of a straight-stemmed, plasma-sprayed, titanium-alloy, uncemented femoral component in primary total hip arthroplasty.
J. Meding (2004)
Cementless metaphyseal fitting anatomic total hip arthroplasty with a ceramic-on-ceramic bearing in patients thirty years of age or younger.
Y. Kim (2012)
Two- to 4-Year Followup of a Short Stem THA Construct: Excellent Fixation, Thigh Pain a Concern
Richard L Amendola (2017)
Accuracy of DEXA measurement of bone mineral density after total hip arthroplasty.
B. Cohen (1995)
The rationale for short uncemented stems in total hip arthroplasty.
R. Patel (2014)
Influence of thigh muscles on the axial strains in a proximal femur during early stance in gait.
L. Cristofolini (1995)
The effect of stem alignment on results of total hip arthroplasty with a cementless tapered-wedge femoral component.
B. Min (2008)
Short-stem prostheses in primary total hip arthroplasty
Shaochuan Huo (2016)
Digital image correlation techniques for strain measurement in a variety of biomechanical test models.
Sarah E Hensley (2017)
Favorable Results of a Short, Tapered, Highly Porous, Proximally Coated Cementless Femoral Stem at a Minimum 4-Year Follow-Up.
Anthony Albers (2016)
"Modes of failure" of cemented stem-type femoral components: a radiographic analysis of loosening.
T. Grün (1979)
Changes in Strain Patterns After Implantation of a Short Stem With Metaphyseal Anchorage Compared to a Standard Stem: An Experimental Study in Synthetic Bone
J. Gronewold (2014)
Long-term results of the cementless porous-coated anatomic total hip prosthesis.
Y. Kim (2005)
Midterm results of “thrust plate
B Fink (2007)
A femoral component inserted without cement in total hip arthroplasty. A study of the Tri-Lock component with an average ten-year duration of follow-up.
B. R. Love (1999)
Validating the SF-36 health survey questionnaire: new outcome measure for primary care.
J. Brazier (1992)
Biomechanical comparison of newly designed stemless prosthesis and conventional hip prosthesis--an experimental study.
C. Tai (2005)
Investigating Ceiling Effects in Longitudinal Data Analysis
L. Wang (2009)
Cementless titanium tapered-wedge femoral stem: 10- to 15-year follow-up.
A. Marshall (2004)
Roentgenographic assessment of the biologic fixation of porous-surfaced femoral components.
C. Engh (1990)
Strain measurements in femurs implemented with hip prostheses
L Cristofolini (1997)
Experimental validation of finite element model for proximal composite femur using optical measurements.
L. Grassi (2013)
Experimental validation of a finite element model of the proximal femur using digital image correlation and a composite bone model.
A. Dickinson (2011)
A prospective short-term outcome study of a short metaphyseal fitting total hip arthroplasty.
Young-Hoo Kim (2012)
Sports Activity After Short-Stem Hip Arthroplasty
F. Schmidutz (2012)
Correlation between femoral neck version and strain on the femur after insertion of femoral prosthesis
N. Umeda (2003)
Hip joint loading during walking and running, measured in two patients.
G. Bergmann (1993)
Short Stems in Total Hip Replacement: Current Status and Future
C. Castelli (2014)
Mechanical testing of bones: the positive synergy of finite–element models and in vitro experiments
L. Cristofolini (2010)
Midterm results of "thrust plate" prosthesis.
B. Fink (2007)
G*Power 3: A flexible statistical power analysis program for the social, behavioral, and biomedical sciences
F. Faul (2007)
Development and in vitro validation of a simplified numerical model for the design of a biomimetic femoral stem.
Bruno Jetté (2018)
IMU-Based Joint Angle Measurement for Gait Analysis
T. Seel (2014)
This paper is referenced by
Comparative analysis of the biomechanical behavior of two different design metaphyseal-fitting short stems using digital image correlation
I. Tatani (2020)
Bone remodelling and integration of two different types of short stem: a dual-energy X-ray – absorptiometry study
F. Falez (2020)
Cementless Hip Implants: History and Current Status of the Issue
I. Shubnyakov (2020)