Online citations, reference lists, and bibliographies.
← Back to Search

The Increase In Animal Mortality Risk Following Exposure To Sparsely Ionizing Radiation Is Not Linear Quadratic With Dose

Benjamin M. Haley, T. Paunesku, D. Grdina, G. Woloschak
Published 2015 · Medicine

Save to my Library
Download PDF
Analyze on Scholarcy
Share
Introduction The US government regulates allowable radiation exposures relying, in large part, on the seventh report from the committee to estimate the Biological Effect of Ionizing Radiation (BEIR VII), which estimated that most contemporary exposures- protracted or low-dose, carry 1.5 fold less risk of carcinogenesis and mortality per Gy than acute exposures of atomic bomb survivors. This correction is known as the dose and dose rate effectiveness factor for the life span study of atomic bomb survivors (DDREFLSS). It was calculated by applying a linear-quadratic dose response model to data from Japanese atomic bomb survivors and a limited number of animal studies. Methods and Results We argue that the linear-quadratic model does not provide appropriate support to estimate the risk of contemporary exposures. In this work, we re-estimated DDREFLSS using 15 animal studies that were not included in BEIR VII’s original analysis. Acute exposure data led to a DDREFLSS estimate from 0.9 to 3.0. By contrast, data that included both acute and protracted exposures led to a DDREFLSS estimate from 4.8 to infinity. These two estimates are significantly different, violating the assumptions of the linear-quadratic model, which predicts that DDREFLSS values calculated in either way should be the same. Conclusions Therefore, we propose that future estimates of the risk of protracted exposures should be based on direct comparisons of data from acute and protracted exposures, rather than from extrapolations from a linear-quadratic model. The risk of low dose exposures may be extrapolated from these protracted estimates, though we encourage ongoing debate as to whether this is the most valid approach. We also encourage efforts to enlarge the datasets used to estimate the risk of protracted exposures by including both human and animal data, carcinogenesis outcomes, a wider range of exposures, and by making more radiobiology data publicly accessible. We believe that these steps will contribute to better estimates of the risks of contemporary radiation exposures.
This paper references
dplyr: A grammar of data manipulation
H Wickham (2014)
dplyr: A grammar of data manipulation [Internet
H Wickham (2014)
United Nations Scientific Committee on the Effects of Atomic Radiation. Effects of ionizing radiation Annex A: Epidemiological studies of radiation and cancer
(2006)
Mixed Effects Cox Models
T. Therneau (2015)
10.18637/JSS.V036.I03
Conducting Meta-Analyses in R with the metafor Package
W. Viechtbauer (2010)
German Comission on Radiological Protection-SSK. Comments on the 2006 draft of the ICRP recommendations
(2006)
Elegant graphics for data analysis
H Wickham
10.1093/RPD/NCP262
Effects of Ionizing Radiation: United Nations Scientific Committee on the Effects of Atomic Radiation: UNSCEAR 2006 Report, Volume 1—Report to the General Assembly, with Scientific Annexes A and B
M. Charles (2010)
10.1259/BJR/63353075
Evidence for beneficial low level radiation effects and radiation hormesis.
L. Feinendegen (2005)
10.1016/j.ijrobp.2007.11.071
Low-dose hyper-radiosensitivity: past, present, and future.
B. Marples (2008)
SOURCES AND EFFECTS OF IONIZING RADIATION : United Nations Scientific Committee on the Effects of Atomic Radiation UNSCEAR 2000 Report to the General Assembly, with Scientific Annexes
岩崎 民子 (2002)
10.18637/JSS.V067.I01
Fitting Linear Mixed-Effects Models Using lme4
Douglas Bates (2014)
pander: An R pandoc writer [Internet
G. Daróczi (2014)
10.2307/2347496
A Method for Computing Profile-Likelihood- Based Confidence Intervals
D. Venzon (1988)
Export tables to LaTeX or HTML
D B Dahl (2014)
THE NATIONAL ACADEMIES PRESS
K. Boulding (1813)
10.1259/BJR/88081058
Radiation protection in humans: extending the concept of as low as reasonably achievable (ALARA) from dose to biological damage.
K. Prasad (2004)
Dose and dose-rate effectiveness factor (DDREF) Recommendation by German Commission on Radiological Protection with scientific grounds
(2014)
pander: An R pandoc writer
G Daróczi (2014)
10.2172/376402
International radiobiology archives of long-term animal studies. I. Descriptions of participating institutions and studies
G. Gerber (1996)
10.18637/JSS.V021.I12
Reshaping Data with the reshape Package
H. Wickham (2007)
10.1136/oem.2008.043265
Is cancer risk of radiation workers larger than expected?
P. Jacob (2009)
10.1007/978-1-4613-1567-4_20
Ionizing Radiation Induced Mutagenesis: Molecular Genetic Changes and Role of DNA Lesions and Repair
L. Breimer (1988)
National Council on Radiation Protection and Measurements. Report No. 160-Ionizing radiation exposure of the population of the United States
(2009)
10.1667/0033-7587(2000)154[0178:RRCRAL]2.0.CO;2
Radiation-Related Cancer Risks at Low Doses among Atomic Bomb Survivors
D. Pierce (2000)
10.1007/s00411-013-0472-y
Uncomfortable issues in radiation protection posed by low-dose radiobiology
C. Mothersill (2013)
10.1007/s00411-010-0270-8
Tissue and data archives from irradiation experiments conducted at Argonne National Laboratory over a period of four decades
Qiong Wang (2010)
10.1667/RR3306.1
Issues in Low Dose Radiation Biology: The Controversy Continues. A Perspective
W. Morgan (2013)
10.17226/9526
Health Risks from Exposure to Low Levels of Ionizing Radiation: BEIR VII Phase 2
Division on Earth (2006)
10.1080/09553008114550311
Influence of Dose and its Distribution in Time on Dose-response Relationships for Low-LET Radiations
A. Howard (1981)
10.2307/3579391
Studies of the mortality of atomic bomb survivors. Report 12, Part I. Cancer: 1950-1990.
D. Pierce (1996)
10.1667/RRAV20.1
Mean Inactivation Dose: A Useful Concept for Intercomparison of Human Cell Survival Curves
B. Fertil (2012)
10.1148/radiol.2481071451
Effective doses in radiology and diagnostic nuclear medicine: a catalog.
F. Mettler (2008)
10.1667/RRAV06.1
Studies of the Mortality of Atomic Bomb Survivors.Report 12, Part I. Cancer: 1950–1990
D. Pierce (2012)
10.1016/j.cell.2011.02.013
Hallmarks of Cancer: The Next Generation
D. Hanahan (2011)
10.1073/pnas.2235592100
Cancer risks attributable to low doses of ionizing radiation: Assessing what we really know
D. Brenner (2003)
Linear Mixed-Effects Models using 'Eigen' and S4
D. Bates (2015)
Low-dose extrapolation of radiation-related cancer risk.
J. Valentin (2005)
R: A language and environment for statistical computing.
R. Team (2014)
10.1667/RR2629.1
Studies of the Mortality of Atomic Bomb Survivors, Report 14, 1950–2003: An Overview of Cancer and Noncancer Diseases
K. Ozasa (2012)
10.1038/bjc.1988.2
Ionizing radiation-induced mutagenesis.
L. Breimer (1988)
10.1148/radiol.2511081296
Recurrent CT, cumulative radiation exposure, and associated radiation-induced cancer risks from CT of adults.
A. Sodickson (2009)
10.1667/RR1091.1
New Models for Evaluation of Radiation-Induced Lifetime Cancer Risk and its Uncertainty Employed in the UNSCEAR 2006 Report
M. Little (2008)
10.1007/978-0-387-98141-3
ggplot2 - Elegant Graphics for Data Analysis
H. Wickham (2009)
10.1088/0952-4746/23/4/M02
Studies of mortality of atomic bomb survivors. Report 13: Solid cancer and noncancer disease mortality: 1950-1997.
Charles Mw (2003)
10.18637/JSS.V040.I01
The Split-Apply-Combine Strategy for Data Analysis
H. Wickham (2011)
10.1186/1752-0509-6-120
Likelihood based observability analysis and confidence intervals for predictions of dynamic models
C. Kreutz (2012)
10.1001/JAMA.1991.03470050119039
Radioactivity and Health: A History
V. E. Archer (1991)
10.1056/NEJMRA072149
Computed tomography--an increasing source of radiation exposure.
D. Brenner (2007)
A Package for Survival Analysis in S
T. Therneau (1994)
Regression Models and Life-Tables
D.
10.3109/09553002.2010.522686
Radiation-induced genomic instability: Are epigenetic mechanisms the missing link?
U. Aypar (2011)
10.1080/01621459.1983.10477968
Bayes Methods for Combining the Results of Cancer Studies in Humans and other Species
W. H. Dumouchel (1983)
10.2307/2288632
Bayes Methods for Combining the Results of Cancer Studies in Humans and Other Species: Comment
D. Krewski (1983)
10.18637/JSS.V035.B01
ggplot2: Elegant Graphics for Data Analysis
P. Valero-Mora (2010)
10.2307/3579526
Comments on the article "Studies of the mortality of atomic bomb survivors. Report 12, part I. Cancer: 1950-1990" by D. A. Pierce, Y. Shimizu. D. L. Preston, M. Vaeth and K. Mabuchi (Radiat. Res. 146, 1-27, 1996)
M. Little (1997)
10.1111/J.1541-0420.2011.01616.X
ggplot2: Elegant Graphics for Data Analysis by WICKHAM, H.
L. Wilkinson (2011)
10.1001/jama.2013.83
Initiatives focus on limiting radiation exposure to patients during CT scans.
D. Goodman (2013)
10.1126/science.1203486
Cancer Immunoediting: Integrating Immunity’s Roles in Cancer Suppression and Promotion
R. Schreiber (2011)
10.1097/HP.0000000000000189
Comments on the DDREF Estimate of the BEIR VII Committee
D. Hoel (2015)
xtable: Export tables to LaTeX or HTML [Internet
DB Dahl (2014)
10.1098/RSTL.1825.0026
XXIV. On the nature of the function expressive of the law of human mortality, and on a new mode of determining the value of life contingencies. In a letter to Francis Baily, Esq. F. R. S. &c
B. Gompertz (1825)
10.18356/4CF5A86D-EN
Uncertainties in risk estimates for radiation-induced cancer
Unscear (2015)
10.1080/09553000802460214
Progress in updating the European Radiobiology Archives
S. Tapio (2008)
coxme: Mixed effects Cox models. [Internet
T. Therneau (2012)
10.1098/rspl.1815.0271
On the Nature of the Function Expressive of the Law of Human Mortality, and on a New Mode of Determining the Value of Life Contingencies. [Abstract]
B. Gompertz (1815)
10.1016/0197-2456(86)90046-2
Meta-analysis in clinical trials.
R. Dersimonian (1986)
10.1016/0883-2897(88)90020-7
NCRP report no. 93: Ionizing radiation exposure of the population of the United States: National Council on Radiation Protection and Measurements, Bethesda, Maryland (1987). US$15.00
W. Eckelman (1988)
10.1097/HP.0b013e3181febad3
PAST AND FUTURE WORK ON RADIOBIOLOGY MEGA-STUDIES: A CASE STUDY AT ARGONNE NATIONAL LABORATORY
Benjamin P. Haley (2011)
10.1097/HP.0b013e3181b1871b
LOW-DOSE EXTRAPOLATION OF RADIATION HEALTH RISKS: SOME IMPLICATIONS OF UNCERTAINTY FOR RADIATION PROTECTION AT LOW DOSES
C. Land (2009)
10.1088/0952-4746/23/4/m02
Studies of mortality of atomic bomb survivors. Report 13: Solid cancer and noncancer disease mortality: 1950-1997.
M. Charles (2003)



This paper is referenced by
10.1002/cncy.22298
Shining a new light on radiation's dark dide
B. Nelson (2020)
10.1371/journal.pone.0231510
Analyses of cancer incidence and other morbidities in gamma irradiated B6CF1 mice
Alia Zander (2020)
10.1093/jrr/rrx093
Typical doses and dose rates in studies pertinent to radiation risk inference at low doses and low dose rates
W. Rühm (2018)
10.5455/JEOS.20160412075846
Dose and dose-rate effectiveness of radiation: first objectivity then conclusions -
S. Jargin (2016)
10.1016/J.LSSR.2020.09.001
Cancer incidence risks above and below 1 Gy for radiation protection in space
Luana Hafner (2020)
10.1080/09553002.2019.1572249
Radiation databases and archives – examples and comparisons
Alia Zander (2019)
10.1080/09553002.2017.1319090
Risk of solid cancer in low dose-rate radiation epidemiological studies and the dose-rate effectiveness factor
R. Shore (2017)
10.1016/j.cbi.2018.12.007
The impact of dose rate on the linear no threshold hypothesis.
A. Brooks (2019)
10.1667/RADE-20-00034.1
A Mathematical Model for Stem Cell Competition to Maintain a Cell Pool Injured by Radiation
Kouki Uchinomiya (2020)
10.1080/09553002.2019.1625458
Establishing the Japan-Store house of animal radiobiology experiments (J-SHARE), a large-scale necropsy and histopathology archive providing international access to important radiobiology data
Takamitsu Morioka (2019)
10.1007/s00411-017-0707-4
Dose and dose rate extrapolation factors for malignant and non-malignant health endpoints after exposure to gamma and neutron radiation
V. Tran (2017)
10.13188/2471-4879.1000005
Biological Effectiveness of Ionizing Radiation : Acute vs . Protracted Exposures
S. Jargin (2016)
10.5453/JHPS.53.47
NCRP Commentary No. 27「最近の疫学研究の直線しきい線量なしモデルと放射線防護への示唆」の概要
信行 浜田 (2018)
10.1667/RADE-19-00003.1
Estimation of Dose-Rate Effectiveness Factor for Malignant Tumor Mortality: Joint Analysis of Mouse Data Exposed to Chronic and Acute Radiation
Kazutaka Doi (2020)
10.1080/09553002.2019.1589026
Big data in radiation biology and epidemiology; an overview of the historical and contemporary landscape of data and biomaterial archives
P. Schofield (2019)
10.1080/09553002.2018.1558303
Funding for radiation research: past, present and future
Kunwoo Cho (2019)
10.1177/0146645318756233
The mandate and work of ICRP Committee 1 on radiation effects
W. Rühm (2018)
10.1098/rspb.2017.1070
A restatement of the natural science evidence base concerning the health effects of low-level ionizing radiation
A. McLean (2017)
10.1101/2020.03.26.009845
Analyses of cancer incidence and other morbidities in gamma irradiated B6CF1 mice
Alia Zander (2020)
10.1177/0146645318756235
Evidence for dose and dose rate effects in human and animal radiation studies
M. Little (2018)
10.1080/09553002.2017.1294773
Biological basis of radiation protection needs rejuvenation
T. Paunesku (2017)
10.1177/0146645316629336
Dose-rate effects in radiation biology and radiation protection
W. Rühm (2016)
10.1080/23312009.2018.1450944
Reactor accident chemistry an update
M. Foreman (2018)
10.1118/1.4957466
TU-D-204-02: The Linear No-Threshold Model (LNT): Made to Be Tested, Made to Be Questioned.
R. Miller (2016)
10.1088/1361-6498/aad348
Implications of recent epidemiologic studies for the linear nonthreshold model and radiation protection.
R. Shore (2018)
10.1007/s00411-015-0613-6
Dose and dose-rate effects of ionizing radiation: a discussion in the light of radiological protection
W. Rühm (2015)
10.1097/HP.0000000000000429
Low Dose Effects: Benefit or Harm?
G. Woloschak (2016)
Semantic Scholar Logo Some data provided by SemanticScholar