Online citations, reference lists, and bibliographies.
← Back to Search

Policy Options To Accelerate Variety Change Among Smallholder Farmers In South Asia And Africa South Of The Sahara

D. Spielman, M. Smale
Published 2017 · Geography

Cite This
Download PDF
Analyze on Scholarcy
Share
The genetic improvement of food staple crops cultivated by small-scale farmers is a well-established route to increasing agricultural productivity and improving rural livelihoods. But in developing countries where seed markets are commercially active or advancing in that direction, undue emphasis in both policy and research is often placed on the adoption of improved cultivars rather than varietal turnover, or the replacement of an already improved variety with a more recently released improved variety. Strong and consistent rates of varietal turnover contribute to sustaining yield gains over time, protecting those gains from both biotic and abiotic stresses, increasing the sustainability of intensive cropping systems, and improving the quality of the commodity itself for storage, processing, and consumption. This paper explores the importance of varietal turnover in advanced and transitional seed systems for food staples in South Asia and Africa south of the Sahara. We first review the measurement of varietal turnover over spatial and temporal dimensions before examining evidence on policies designed to accelerate varietal turnover rates. We then suggest a sequence of regulatory reforms and public investments designed to accelerate varietal turnover while drawing attention to the economic trade-offs, unintended consequences, and operational challenges of such reforms and investments.
This paper references
Policies to promote cereal intensification in Ethiopia: A review of evidence and experience
D. Byerlee (2007)
The Theory of Disease Management.
J. L. Apple (1977)
Variety testing and release approaches in DTMA project countries in Sub-Saharan Africa
P. Setimela (2009)
10.1016/J.FOODPOL.2014.01.001
The seed and agricultural biotechnology industries in India: An analysis of industry structure, competition, and policy options
D. Spielman (2014)
10.1596/978-1-4648-0772-5
Enabling the business of agriculture 2016 : comparing regulatory good practices
Mark E. Cackler (2016)
10.2307/1242837
Measuring the Potential Contribution of Plant Breeding to Crop Yields: Flue-Cured Tobacco, 1954–87
B. Babcock (1991)
10.2139/ssrn.2027051
Research Investments and Market Structure in the Food Processing, Agricultural Input, and Biofuel Industries Worldwide
K. Fuglie (2011)
Bangladesh Integrated Household Survey (BIHS) 2011-2012. Dataset
A Ahmed (2013)
10.1016/J.GFS.2018.12.007
Does providing agricultural and nutrition information to both men and women improve household food security? Evidence from Malawi
C. Ragasa (2019)
10.1079/9781780644011.0239
Scientific strength in rice improvement programmes, varietal outputs and adoption of improved varieties in South Asia.
S. Pandey (2015)
10.22004/AG.ECON.33671
THE SEED INDUSTRY IN U.S. AGRICULTURE: AN EXPLORATION OF DATA AND INFORMATION ON CROP SEED MARKETS, REGULATION, INDUSTRY STRUCTURE, AND RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT
J. Fernandez-Cornejo (2004)
Transforming Demand Assessment and Supply Responses in Ethiopia’s Seed System and Market
D. J. Spielman (2012)
Market Inefficiencies and the Adoption of Agricultural Technologies in Developing Countries. White paper prepared for the Agricultural Technology Adoption Initiative
K. Jack (2013)
10.1080/15427528.2012.670695
Farmers' Seed Sources and Seed Quality: 1. Physical and Physiological Quality
Z. Bishaw (2012)
10.1016/S0306-9192(00)00042-7
Policies for African seed enterprise development
R. Tripp (2001)
South Africa’s Approach to Variety Acceptance and Seed Quality Control.
E. Goldschagg (2016)
End Point Royalties (EPRs): Fact Sheet
The support for farmer-led seed systems in African seed laws
Sanne Herpers (2017)
10.1111/0002-9092.00101
Government Spending, Growth and Poverty in Rural India
S. Fan (1999)
10.3362/9781780445588
New seed and old laws: regulatory reform and the diversification of national seed systems.
R. Tripp (1997)
Lessons Learnt from the Implementation of the E-voucher Pilot
Chinyama Lukama (2017)
10.2307/1242432
An Analytical Model of Farmers' Demand for Replacement Seed
P. Heisey (1991)
Paying for agricultural productivity
J. Alston (1997)
Measuring the Contribution of New Varieties to Increasing Wheat Yields
J. Brennan (1984)
10.1086/451461
Adoption of Agricultural Innovations in Developing Countries: A Survey
G. Feder (1985)
Private-Sector Agricultural Research and Innovation in Bangladesh: Overview, Impact, and Policy Options. Agricultural Science and Technology Indicators Initiative Project Paper
H Ar-Rashid (2012)
10.2499/9780896296695
Proven successes in agricultural development : a technical compendium to Millions Fed
D. Spielman (2010)
The Architecture of the Pakistani Seed System: A Case of MarketRegulation Dissonance.” Ch. 5 in Agriculture and the Rural Economy in Pakistan: Issues, Outlooks, and Policy Priorities, edited
M. A. Rana (2016)
Assessing the Benefits of International Wheat Breeding Research : An Overview of the Global Wheat Impacts Study
P. Heisey (1999)
10.1016/S0306-9192(97)00033-X
Seed regulation: choices on the road to reform
R. Tripp (1997)
10.1016/J.WORLDDEV.2012.11.006
Disrupting Demand for Commercial Seed: Input Subsidies in Malawi and Zambia
N. Mason (2013)
10.1002/AGR.20221
Private‐sector investment in R&D: a review of policy options to promote its growth in developing‐country agriculture
A. Naseem (2010)
An Evaluation of the Impact of E-Verification on Counterfeit Agricultural Inputs and Technology Adoption in Uganda: Baseline Report
M. Ashour (2015)
Transforming Demand Assessment and Supply Responses in Ethiopia's Seed System and Market. Report prepared for the Agricultural Transformation Agency
D J Spielman (2012)
10.1016/S0304-3878(97)00005-9
Research, productivity, and output growth in Chinese agriculture
Shenggan Fan (1997)
Measuring the Impacts of Agricultural Input Subsidies in Sub-Saharan Africa: Evidence from Malawi's Farm Input Subsidy Program
G. Shively (2013)
An Innovation Market Approach to Analyzing Impacts of Mergers and Acquisitions in the Plant Biotechnology Industry
Margaret F. Brennan (2005)
Bangladesh, India, and Nepal Sign Historic Agreement in the Evaluation of Rice Varieties
Access to foundation seed of varieties in the public domain
W. Heemskerk (2017)
10.1111/AGEC.12073
Input subsidy programs in sub-Saharan Africa: a synthesis of recent evidence
T. Jayne (2013)
10.1201/B10185
Economic analysis of diversity in modern wheat
Erika C.H. Meng (2009)
10.1079/9781780644011.0206
Assessing the effectiveness of maize and wheat improvement from the perspectives of varietal output and adoption in East and Southern Africa.
H. Groote (2015)
The Philippine hybrid rice program : a case for redesign and scaling down
C. David (2007)
10.1080/03031853.2013.798067
Political and economic features of the maize seed industry in southern Africa
G. Kassie (2013)
10.2135/CROPSCI2002.1766
Dimensions of Diversity in Modern Spring Bread Wheat in Developing Countries from 1965
M. Smale (2002)
10.1016/S1574-0072(01)10007-1
The agricultural innovation process: Research and technology adoption in a changing agricultural sector
David L. Sunding (1999)
Seed Demand and Supply Responses in Ethiopia's Teff Seed System
D J Spielman
10.2499/0896291162rr113
A meta-analysis of rates of return to agricultural R&D : ex pede Herculem?
J. Alston (2000)
The Abbreviated Women's Empowerment in Agriculture Index (A-WEAI)
H. Malapit (2017)
10.1079/9781780644011.0265
Analysing scientific strength and varietal generation, adoption and turnover in Peninsular India: the case of sorghum, pearl millet, chickpea, pigeonpea and groundnut.
D. Charyulu (2015)
10.1093/WBRO/6.1.57
TECHNOLOGICAL CHANGE AND COMMERCIALIZATION IN AGRICULTURE: The Effect on the Poor
H. Binswanger (1991)
Maize technology development and transfer
S. I. Shibairo (1998)
10.1023/A:1007803108805
Research Investment and the Economic Returns To Chinese Agricultural Research
S. Fan (2000)
United States Agency for International Development
Erin Doheny (2011)
The Seed Industry in Pakistan: Regulation, Politics, and Entrepreneurship. Pakistan Strategy Support Program Working Paper 19
M A Rana (2014)
10.22004/AG.ECON.259743
SOME EFFECTS OF THE U.S. PLANT VARIETY PROTECTION ACT OF 1970
R. Perrin (1983)
Economic Growth and Agriculture
Mitsuharu Inage (1961)
Overview of the evolution of agricultural mechanization in Nepal: A focus on tractors and combine harvesters
H. Takeshima (2017)
Diffusion of innovations (3rd ed
E. M. Rogers (1983)
Understanding the Measurement of Women’s Autonomy: Illustrations from Bangladesh and Ghana
G. Seymour (2017)
10.1126/SCIENCE.1078710
Assessing the Impact of the Green Revolution, 1960 to 2000
R. Evenson (2003)
Fertilizer Use in African Agriculture: Lessons Learned and Good Practice Guidelines
M. Morris (2007)
10.1016/J.FCR.2014.06.021
How an improved sorghum variety evolves in a traditional seed system in Mali: Effects of farmers’ practices on the maintenance of phenotype and genetic composition
M. Deu (2014)
Mapping Indian Agricultural Emissions: Lessons for Food System Transformation and Policy Support for Climate-Smart Agriculture
N. Patra (2017)
Assessing the impact of the Green Revolution
R. Evenson (2003)
10.1016/J.FOODPOL.2010.01.005
Challenges of the maize seed industry in eastern and southern Africa: A compelling case for private–public intervention to promote growth
A. S. Langyintuo (2010)
10.1016/j.agsy.2016.05.015
Towards better metrics and policymaking for seed system development: Insights from Asia's seed industry
D. Spielman (2016)
10.1007/s12571-015-0511-4
Subsidies promote use of drought tolerant maize varieties despite variable yield performance under smallholder environments in Malawi
S. Holden (2015)
10.2139/SSRN.3070116
Addressing transboundary cooperation in the Eastern Nile through the Water-Energy-Food Nexus: Insights from an E-survey and key informant interviews
Helen Berga (2017)
10.22004/ag.econ.284036
MAIZE SEED INDUSTRY IN THAILAND: DEVELOPMENT, CURRENT SITUATION, AND PROSPECT
O. Napasintuwong (2015)
Agricultural Extension, Adoption and Diffusion in Ethiopia
Tenkir Bonger (2004)
10.1080/00220388.2015.1081171
Private Sector Incentives and the Diffusion of Agricultural Technology: Evidence from Developing Countries
D. Spielman (2013)
India’s Seed Industry Reforms: Prospects and Issues.
S. Pal (2002)
10.22004/AG.ECON.117213
Privatization, public r&d policy, and private r&d investment in China's agriculture
R. Hu (2011)
Seeding the Future: An Analysis of Seed System Development in Bangladesh.
F. Naher (2015)
10.9783/9780812294217-008
The Architecture of the Pakistani Seed System: A Case of Market-Regulation Dissonance
M. A. Rana (2015)
10.1111/j.1467-8489.2008.00435.x
Wheat Breeding, Productivity and Slow Variety Change: Evidence from the Punjab of India after the Green Revolution
M. Smale (2008)
The rate of crop varietal replacement on farms: measures and empirical results for wheat
J. Brennan (1991)
10.2307/525223
Africa's Emerging Maize Revolution
D. Byerlee (1997)
Ch. 5 in "Seed Development Programs in Sub-Saharan Africa: A Review of Experiences
M Smale (2007)
Smallholder Farming and Crop Variety Choice: Maize Variety Choice in Zambia
H. De Groote (2014)
10.2139/ssrn.3016592
Intertemporal Choice and Income Regularity: Non-Fungibility in a Lab-in-The-Field Experiment
B. Kramer (2017)
10.1111/AGEC.12095
Demand for maize hybrids and hybrid change on smallholder farms in Kenya
M. Smale (2014)
10.1007/s10658-013-0269-5
Health of farmer-saved maize seed in north-east Nigeria
P. Biemond (2013)
10.1111/j.1574-0862.1996.tb00428.x
Science under scarcity
J. Oehmke (1996)
Creating space for ‘informal’ seed systems in a plant variety protection system that is based on UPOV 1991
B. Jonge (2017)
Diagnostic study of farmers seed quality and variety preference in southern Mali
Marthe Diallo (2009)
10.2139/ssrn.2263042
An Obstacle to Africa's Green Revolution: Too Few New Varieties
D. Gisselquist (2013)
10.1080/15427528.2012.751472
Integrated Seed Sector Development in Africa: A Basis for Seed Policy and Law
N. P. Louwaars (2013)
10.1017/S0021859615000155
Exploring the supply and demand factors of varietal turnover in Indian wheat
V. V. Krishna (2016)
Financing seed business
Eline Minneboo (2017)
10.2307/1244415
Wheat Rusts and the Costs of Genetic Diversity in the Punjab of Pakistan
P. Heisey (1997)
10.1016/S0306-9192(01)00022-7
The impact of economic reforms on R&D by the Indian seed industry
C. Pray (2001)
10.1017/S1074070800003114
Factors Influencing Wheat Yield and Variability: Evidence from Manitoba, Canada
R. Carew (2009)
Bangladesh Integrated Household Survey (BIHS) 2011–2012
A. Ahmed (2013)
Addressing transboundary cooperation in the Eastern Nile through the water-energy-food nexus: Insights from an esurvey and key informant
Helen Berga (2017)
The Seed Industry in Pakistan: Regulation, Politics, and Entrepreneurship
M. A. Rana (2014)
10.1111/J.1744-7976.2003.TB00181.X
Quantifying the Contribution of Plant Breeders’Rights and Transgenic Varieties to Canola Yields: Evidence from Manitoba
R. Carew (2003)
10.1016/S0048-7333(01)00123-8
The effects of the US Plant Variety Protection Act on wheat genetic improvement
J. Alston (2002)
Food and Nutrition Security in Transforming Ghana: A Descriptive Analysis of National Trends and Regional Patterns
O. Ecker (2017)
Assessing the health and nutrition risks of smallholder poultry production in Burkina Faso: Insights from formative research
A. Gelli (2017)
e-Verification of Agricultural Inputs: Progress in Uganda
10.1079/9781780644011.0000
Crop Improvement, Adoption and Impact of Improved Varieties in Food Crops in Sub-Saharan Africa
Travis S. Walker (2015)
Does Plant Variety Intellectual Property Protection Improve Farm Productivity? Evidence from Cotton Varieties
A. Naseem (2005)
10.1007/s12571-014-0357-1
Taking stock of the genetically modified seed sector worldwide: market, stakeholders, and prices
S. Bonny (2014)
10.1086/346177
South‐North Trade, Intellectual Property Jurisdictions, and Freedom to Operate in Agricultural Research on Staple Crops*
Eran Binenbaum (2003)
Cooking Contests for Healthier Recipes: Impacts on Nutrition Knowledge and Behaviors in Bangladesh
B. Kramer (2017)
10.1093/WBER/LHZ005
Cash Transfers and Management Advice for Agriculture: Evidence from Senegal
Kate Ambler (2017)
Crop Genetic Resources: An Economic Appraisal
Kelly A. Day-Rubenstein (2012)
Harmonizing Seed Regulations to World Best Practice: Variety Introduction.
D. Gisselquist (2016)
Ethiopian Seed Enterprise Strategy Refresh
Dalberg Global Development Advisors. (2012)
10.1016/J.FOODPOL.2015.12.009
Dynamics of variety change on wheat farms in Pakistan: A duration analysis
H. Nazli (2016)
10.1016/0040-1625(93)90053-A
The adoption of agricultural innovations: A review
G. Feder (1993)
The diffusion of hybrid maize in western Kenya
Nairobi (1974)
10.1080/10440046.2010.484689
Integrating Genetic Resource Conservation and Sustainable Development into Strategies to Increase the Robustness of Seed Systems
W. S. de Boef (2010)
10.1111/J.1477-9552.2008.00171.X
But are they Meritorious? Genetic Productivity Gains under Plant Intellectual Property Rights
Deepthi E. Kolady (2009)
Understanding the Seed Industry: Contemporary Trends and Analytical Issues
B. Ramaswami (2006)
Accelerating the transfer of wheat breeding gains to farmers : a study of the dynamics of varietal replacement in Pakistan
P. Heisey (1990)
Maize Seed Industries: A Conceptual Framework.
M. L. Morris (1998)
10.1007/978-94-015-7358-0
Ecological Diversity and Its Measurement
A. Magurran (1988)
10.1596/1813-9450-2086
Deregulating Technology Transfer in Agriculture: Reform's Impact on Turkey in the 1980s
D. Gisselquist (1999)
Gender, climate change, and resilient food systems: lessons from strategic adaptation by smallholder farmers in Cameroon
L. Nkengla-Asi (2017)
10.1111/1467-8276.00043
The Creation and Spread of Technology and Total Factor Productivity in China's Agriculture
S. Jin (2002)
10.1146/annurev.economics.102308.124433
Microeconomics of Technology Adoption.
A. Foster (2010)
10.1186/s40066-017-0108-6
Characteristics of maize cultivars in Africa: How modern are they and how many do smallholder farmers grow?
Tsedeke Abate (2017)
Variety release and policy options.
Z. Bishaw (2009)
Grain yields and the American food supply-an analysis of yield changes and possibilities. Chicago, Ill.
D. Johnson (1962)
10.2307/1905380
HYBRID CORN: AN EXPLORATION IN THE ECONOMIC OF TECHNOLOGICAL CHANGE
Z. Griliches (1957)
Item 3.3 of the Provisional Agenda, Commission on Genetic Resources for Food and Agriculture
Fao (2006)
10.2307/1309796
Sustaining Agricultural Yields
D. L. Plucknett (1986)
10.1111/J.1574-0862.2003.TB00131.X
Determinants of spatial diversity in modern wheat: examples from Australia and China
M. Smale (2003)
10.1016/J.AGSY.2018.06.003
Selective attention and information loss in the lab-to-farm knowledge chain: The case of Malawian agricultural extension programs
Chiyu Niu (2018)
10.1016/J.FOODPOL.2015.07.008
Farmer seed networks make a limited contribution to agriculture? Four common misconceptions
O. Coomes (2015)
The role of agriculture in economic development
G. Meijerink (2007)
10.4324/9780203840436
New seeds and poor people
M. Lipton (1989)
10.1007/BF02858829
Genetic diversity in major farm crops on the farm and in reserve
D. Duvick (2008)
10.1016/J.AGSY.2017.10.009
Women's Land Rights as a Pathway to Poverty Reduction: A Framework and Review of Available Evidence
R. Meinzen-Dick (2017)
RECENT IFPRI DISCUSSION PAPERS For earlier discussion papers, please go to www.ifpri.org/publications/discussion_papers. All discussion papers can be downloaded free of charge
(2016)
10.1300/J153v04n01_02
The Importance of the Farmers' Seed Systems in a Functional National Seed Sector
C. Almekinders (2002)
10.1016/S1096-7508(01)00038-6
LIBERALIZATION'S IMPACT ON THE INDIAN SEED INDUSTRY: COMPETITION, RESEARCH, AND IMPACT ON FARMERS
C. Pray (1999)
10.2307/2230054
Agricultural Development: An International Perspective.
G. Hallett (1971)
India.” In Maize Seed Industries in Developing Countries, edited
S. Pal (1998)
10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199683529.001.0001
Agricultural Input Subsidies: The Recent Malawi Experience
E. Chirwa (2013)
Public variety use agreements
W. Heemskerk (2017)
Effective seed quality assurance
P. Gildemacher (2017)
10.2307/1244551
The Contribution of Genetic Resources and Diversity to Wheat Production in the Punjab of Pakistan
J. Hartell (1998)
The Effects of the U.S. Plant Variety Protection Act on Wheat Genetic Improvement. EPTD Discussion Paper 62
J M Alston (2000)
Seed Marketing.” Ch. 5 in “Seed Development Programs in SubSaharan Africa: A Review of Experiences,
M. Smale (2007)
10.1016/S0140-6736(88)92673-6
India
Kosturi Ghosh (1988)
Enabling the business of agriculture 2016 comparing regulatory good practices
A. Kibaroğlu (2016)
10.2139/SSRN.2483989
Direct Seed Marketing Program in Ethiopia in 2013: An Operational Evaluation to Guide Seed-Sector Reform
T. Benson (2014)
10.1007/BF02860788
Maize Seed Industries in Developing Countries
M. Eubanks (2008)
10.1111/AGEC.12080
Impacts of subsidized hybrid seed on indicators of economic well‐being among smallholder maize growers in Zambia
N. Mason (2013)
Private-Sector Agricultural Research and Innovation in Zambia Overview, Impact, and Policy Options
M. Mwala (2012)
The Asian Green Revolution.” Ch. 3 in Proven Successes in Agricultural Development: A Technical Compendium to Millions Fed, edited by D
P.B.R. Hazell (2010)



This paper is referenced by
10.1177/0030727019900520
Sticking with the old seed: Input value chains and the challenges to deliver genetic gains to smallholder maize farmers
P. Rutsaert (2020)
10.1177/0030727019827028
Understanding the relations between farmers’ seed demand and research methods: The challenge to do better
C. Almekinders (2019)
The Effects of a CAADP-Compliant Budget on Poverty and Inequality in Ghana
Stephen Younger (2017)
The Central Position of Agriculture Within the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development
B. Omilola (2017)
Growth of Modern Service Providers for the African Agricultural Sector: An Insight from a Public Irrigation Scheme in Ghana
Hiroyuki Takeshima (2017)
10.4160/23096586RTBWP20191
Characterizing Nigeria’s cassava seed system and the use of planting material in three farming communities
T. Pircher (2019)
US Trade Wars with Emerging Countries in the 21st Century: Make America and Its Partners Lose Again
Antoine Bouët (2017)
10.1007/S10460-018-9862-8
What happens after technology adoption? Gendered aspects of small-scale irrigation technologies in Ethiopia, Ghana, and Tanzania
S. Theis (2018)
10.1016/j.gfs.2019.100324
Varietal replacement rate: Prospects and challenges for global food security
Rakhee Singh (2020)
Nutrition-sensitive agriculture: What have we learned and where do we go from here?
M. Ruel (2017)
10.5772/intechopen.94212
Varietal Release, Notification and Denotification System in India
S. Chand (2020)
10.1080/15427528.2018.1476998
Understanding root, tuber, and banana seed systems and coordination breakdown: a multi-stakeholder framework
J. Bentley (2018)
10.1007/978-3-319-92798-5_8
Access to Early Generation Seed: Obstacles for Delivery of Climate-Smart Varieties
Laura Cramer (2019)
10.1080/15427528.2020.1737296
Exploring the marketing environment for maize seed in Kenya: how competition and consumer preferences shape seed sector development
P. Rutsaert (2020)
Improving efficiency of seed system by appropriating farmer’s rights in India through adoption and implementation of policy of quality declared seed schemes in parallel
Rc Agrawal (2018)
10.1007/s12571-018-0874-4
Why interventions in the seed systems of roots, tubers and bananas crops do not reach their full potential
C. Almekinders (2018)
Semantic Scholar Logo Some data provided by SemanticScholar