Responsiveness Of Dairy Cows To Human Approach And Novel Stimuli
J. Gibbons, A. Lawrence, M. Haskell
Published 2009 · Psychology
Download PDFAnalyze on Scholarcy
This study investigated intra-test and inter-test consistency of dairy cattle behavioural responses to a series of tests involving human approach and exposure to novelty. Thirtysix lactating Holstein–Friesian cows were each subjected to three human approach tests and three novel stimuli tests. Flight response score was assessed by an experimenter approaching cows when they were in the passageway of the home-pen (AP), lying down (AL) and at the feedface (FF). Each human approach test was repeated on each cow three times. The intra-animal repeatability estimates were 0.65, 0.40, 0.27 for AP, AL and FF tests, respectively. Repeatability evaluates an individual’s consistency across tests by comparing it to the variation within the group. Cows showed moderate consistency in their flight response scores to the different approach tests (W35 = 0.56, P < 0.01). Three novel stimuli (water spray, striped boards and flashing light) were individually presented once to each cow. Investigatory and reactivity behavioural responses were assessed. Cows showed the greatest reactivity response to the water spray compared to the striped boards (U1 = 56, P < 0.001) and flashing light (U1 = 66, P < 0.001). No statistically significant agreement existed between the novel stimuli reactivity and investigatory responses with the AP flight response scores. In conclusion, consistency over time was demonstrated over a relatively short period for the AP test and consistency between human approach situations was shown, however, consistency between human and novel situations was not found.
This paper references
Individual differences in temperament of domestic dairy goats: constancy and change
D. Lyons (1988)
Behavioral agitation during handling of cattle is persistent over time
T. Grandin (1993)
The relation between fear and exploratory behavior.
K. Montgomery (1955)
Explorations in behavioral consistency: properties of persons, situations, and behaviors.
D. Funder (1991)
Temperament traits in cattle : measurement and preliminary genetic analysis
N. Ball (2003)
The relationship between body condition score and reproductive performance.
J. Pryce (2001)
Effects of genetic selection for milk yield on energy balance, levels of hormones, and metabolites in lactating cattle, and possible links to reduced fertility ☆
R. Veerkamp (2003)
The effect of concentrate: silage ratio and of hoof trimming on lameness in dairy cattle
F. Manson (1989)
Temperament: Early Developing Personality Traits
A. Buss (1984)
Skeletal muscularity and heart function in growing piglets.
R. Geers (1990)
Unrepeatable Repeatabilities: A Common Mistake
C. M. Lessells (1987)
Repeatability: Its role in evolutionary studies of mating behavior
C. R. Boake (2005)
Dairy cows' fear of people: social learning, milk yield and behaviour at milking.
L. Munksgaard (2001)
Genetic relationships between calving interval and body condition score conditional on milk yield.
J. Pryce (2002)
Individual variation in the behaviour of pigs-noise or functional coping strategies?
P. Jensen (1995)
Destabilizing selection as a factor of domestication.
D. Belyaev (1979)
Influences on the avoidance and approach behaviour of dairy cows towards humans on 35 farms
S. Waiblinger (2003)
The relationship between body energy traits and production and fitness traits in first-lactation dairy cows.
E. Wall (2007)
Shyness and boldness in humans and other animals.
D. Sloan Wilson (1994)
Declining fertility in dairy cattle: changes in traditional and endocrine parameters of fertility.
M. Royal (2000)
Personality: Strategies and Issues
R. Liebert (1987)
Genomics Meets Ethology: A New Route to Understanding Domestication, Behavior, and Sustainability in Animal Breeding
P. Jensen (2005)
Mapping quantitative trait loci affecting feather pecking behavior and stress response in laying hens.
A. Buitenhuis (2003)
Long-term consistency of selected animal-related welfare parameters in dairy farms
C. Winckler (2007)
Genetics and the Behaviour of Domestic Animals
P. McGreevy (1998)
Bayesian Analysis of Genetic Associations of Skin Lesions and Behavioural Traits to Identify Genetic Components of Individual Aggressiveness in Pigs
S. Turner (2008)
Development of a behavioural test of sensory responsiveness in the growing pig.
G. Hutson (2000)
From mice to men: what can we learn about personality from animal research?
S. Gosling (2001)
Behavioural responses of dairy cows toward novel stimuli presented in the home environment
M. S. Herskin (2004)
Recovery of inter-block information when block sizes are unequal
H. Patterson (1971)
Nonparametric Statistics for the Behavioral Sciences.
F. N. David (1956)
Consistency of temperament in bighorn ewes and correlates with behaviour and life history
D. Réale (2000)
Studies of feather pecking in poultry.
H. Blokhuis (1998)
Is fearfulness a trait that can be measured with behavioural tests? A validation of four fear tests for Japanese quail
Katherine A. Miller (2006)
Genetic background of maternal behaviour and its relation to offspring survival
K. Grandinson (2005)
Assessing the ‘whole animal’: a free choice profiling approach
F. Wemelsfelder (2001)
Behavioural responses of domestic pigs and cattle to humans and novel stimuli
P. Hemsworth (1996)
Behaviour of cattle in yards. II. A study of temperament
N. M. Tulloh (1961)
Associations between behavioural indicators and inflammatory disease in dairy cows. In: 'ISAE 2006: Proceedings of the 40th International Congress of the ISAE, University of Bristol, August 8-12'
A McMullan (2006)
The relation between fear induced by novel stimulation and exploratory drive.
K. Montgomery (1955)
Establishment of cattle-human relationships
X. Boivin (1992)
A temperament theory of personality development
A. Buss (1975)
Consistency of individual behavioural characteristics of dairy cows in their home pen
L. Schrader (2002)
Reactivity to humans: A temperament trait of horses which is stable across time and situations
Léa Lansade (2008)
Identification of quantitative trait loci affecting cattle temperament.
B. Gutíerrez-Gil (2008)
Individual differences in behavioural responses of pigs exposed to non-social and social challenges
A. Lawrence (1991)
Individual differences in the reaction of beef cattle to situations involving social isolation, close proximity of humans, restraint and novelty
R. J. Kilgour (2006)
Repeatability and reliability of an approach test to determine calves'responsiveness to humans: "a brief report"
B. J. Lensink (2003)
Effects of early handling on heifers' subsequent reactivity to humans and to unfamiliar situations
A. Boissy (1988)
Proceedings of the 31st International Congress of the International Society for Applied Ethology
A.C. Lindberg (1996)
Estimates of the genetic parameters and repeatability of behavioural traits of sheep in an arena test
B. T. Wolf (2008)
Nature over nurture: temperament personality and lifespan
R. McCrae (2000)
Human-livestock interactions - the stockperson and the productivity and welfare of intensively farmed animals, P.H. Hemsworth and G.C. Coleman : book review
C.M.E. McCrindle (1998)
Do beef cattle react consistently to different handling situations?
L. Grignard (2001)
Optimal Genetic Improvement for the High Producing Cow
B. Cassell (2001)
Handbook of infant development
J. D. Osofsky (1979)
Temperament in infancy.
J. E. Bates (1987)
On-farm welfare assessment in dairy cattle and buffaloes: evaluation of some animal-based parameters
F. Napolitano (2005)
Evaluation of on-farm methods for testing the human–animal relationship in dairy herds with cubicle loose housing systems—test–retest and inter-observer reliability and consistency to familiarity of test person
T. Rousing (2004)
Reliability and inter-test relationship of tests for on-farm assessment of dairy cows’ relationship to humans
I. Windschnurer (2008)
Discrimination of people by dairy cows based on handling.
L. Munksgaard (1997)
Habituation and extinction in an approach–avoidance test: An example with sheep
H. W. Erhard (2006)
Solving livestock handling problems
T. Grandin (1994)
Undesirable side effects of selection for high production efficiency in farm animals: a review
W. M. Rauw (1998)
Assessment of stress during handling and transport.
T. Grandin (1997)
Nature over nurture: temperament, personality, and life span development.
R. McCrae (2000)
The relationship between reaction to sudden, intermittent movements and sounds and temperament.
J. Lanier (2000)
This paper is referenced by
Genetics of cattle temperament and its impact on livestock production and breeding – a review
J. Friedrich (2015)
Consistency of temperament traits and their relationships with milk yield in lactating primiparous F1 Holstein - Gyr cows
Maria G. Marçal-Pedroza (2020)
A Novel Protocol to Assess Acclimation Rate in Bos taurus Heifers during Yard Weaning
Jessica E Monk (2018)
Methane production in different breeds, grazing different pastures or fed a total mixed ration, as measured by a Laser Methane Detector
Susanna Maria Grobler (2014)
Genetic selection for temperament traits in dairy and beef cattle
M. Haskell (2014)
Novel object response in beef cattle grazing a pasture as a group
Masahiko Hirata (2018)
Personality Research in Mammalian Farm Animals: Concepts, Measures, and Relationship to Welfare
Marie-Antonine Finkemeier (2018)
Development of approach and handling tests for the assessment of reactivity to humans of sows housed in stall or in group
C. Clouard (2011)
Improving the Welfare of Laboratory-Housed Primates Through the Use of Positive Reinforcement Training: Practicalities of Implementation
V. A. Bowell (2010)
Responsiveness of beef cattle (Bos taurus) to human approach, novelty, social isolation, restraint and trade-offs between feeding and social companionship.
Masahiko Hirata (2016)
Early domestication? : Phenotypic alterations of Red Junglefowl selected for divergent fear of humans
B. Agnvall (2016)
How does the Behaviour of Dairy Cows during Recording Affect an Image Processing Based Calculation of the Udder Depth
Jennifer Salau (2018)
The body language of dairy calves – Investigating emotions through ear posture, tail posture, and stepping behaviour
Kirste Mccrea (2019)
Relationships between young stallions' temperament and their behavioral reactions during standardized veterinary examinations
Marie Peeters (2012)
ANIMAL BEHAVIOR AND WELL-BEING SYMPOSIUM: Interaction between coping style/personality, stress, and welfare: Relevance for domestic farm animals.
J. M. Koolhaas (2016)
Avoidance-related behavioural variables and their relationship to milk yield in pasture-based dairy cows
Madodana S. Dodzi (2011)
Economic and livestock health impacts of birds on dairies: Evidence from a survey of Washington dairy operators
J. Elser (2019)
On the use of a laser methane detector in dairy cows
M. G. .. Chagunda (2009)
Consistency of flight speed and response to restraint in a crush in dairy cattle
Jenny Gibbons (2011)
Characterising personality traits in cattle using biotelemetry systems
Jill R D MacKay (2013)
Inconsistency in dairy calves’ responses to tests of fearfulness
Rebecca K. Meagher (2016)
The association between glutamine repeats in the androgen receptor gene and personality traits in dromedary camel (Camelus dromedarius)
S. Ramadan (2018)
Evidence for Individual Differences in Behaviour and for Behavioural Syndromes in Adult Shelter Cats
Sandra Martínez-Byer (2020)
Einfluss der Mensch-Tier-Beziehung auf die Eutergesundheit von Milchkühen
Fachbereich Ökologische Agrarwissenschaften (2010)
Effects of dexamethasone and training on the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal response on mild stress challenge in dairy cows
N Khraim (2011)
Mother-offspring vocal communication and temperament in cattle
Mónica de la Torre (2013)
The effects of positive human contact by tactile stimulation on dairy cows with different personalities
Munira Shahin (2018)
IMPROVING THE WELFARE OF DAIRY COWS AND CALVES: THE IMPORTANCE OF THE ENVIRONMENT
Jessica Ann Pempek (2015)
Title The association between glutamine repeats in the androgen receptor gene and personality traits in dromedary camel ( Camelus dromedarius )
Sherif Ramadan (2019)
Developing and Validating Measures of Temperament in Livestock
Simon P. Turner (2011)
Personality and production: nervous cows produce less milk.
Louise Hedlund (2015)
Avaliação da reatividade de equinos durante o manejo e na presença de estímulo desconhecido
R. F. Calviello (2013)See more