Online citations, reference lists, and bibliographies.
← Back to Search

Towards Better Metrics And Policymaking For Seed System Development: Insights From Asia's Seed Industry

D. Spielman, A. Kennedy
Published 2016 · Economics, Medicine

Cite This
Download PDF
Analyze on Scholarcy
Share
Since the 1980s, many developing countries have introduced policies to promote seed industry growth and improve the delivery of modern science to farmers, often with a long-term goal of increasing agricultural productivity in smallholder farming systems. Public, private, and civil society actors involved in shaping policy designs have, in turn, developed competing narratives around how best to build an innovative and sustainable seed system, each with varying goals, values, and levels of influence. Efforts to strike a balance between these narratives have often played out in passionate discourses surrounding seed rules and regulations. As a result, however, policymakers in many countries have expressed impatience with the slow progress on enhancing the contribution of a modern seed industry to the overarching goal of increasing agricultural productivity growth. One reason for this slow progress may be that policymakers are insufficiently cognizant of the trade-offs associated with rules and regulations required to effectively govern a modern seed industry. This suggests the need for new data and analysis to improve the understanding of how seed systems function. This paper explores these issues in the context of Asia's rapidly growing seed industry, with illustrations from seed markets for maize and several other crops, to highlight current gaps in the metrics used to analyze performance, competition, and innovation. The paper provides a finite set of indicators to inform policymaking on seed system design and monitoring, and explores how these indicators can be used to inform current policy debates in the region.
This paper references
Independent panel review of the Doing Business report
(2013)
Benefits and Costs of Intellectual Property Protection in Developing Countries
R. Rapp (1990)
10.21955/GATESOPENRES.1115076.1
Public agricultural R&D in South Asia: Greater government commitment, yet underinvestment persists
G. Stads (2012)
PhillipsMcDougal
P Mcdougal (2015)
10.1002/jid.1234
Policy Entrepreneurship for Poverty Reduction: Bridging Research and Policy in International Development
J. Court (2007)
10.1016/J.FOODPOL.2010.01.005
Challenges of the maize seed industry in eastern and southern Africa: A compelling case for private–public intervention to promote growth
A. S. Langyintuo (2010)
10.1002/AGR.20221
Private‐sector investment in R&D: a review of policy options to promote its growth in developing‐country agriculture
A. Naseem (2010)
Hybrid rice technology development: Ensuring China's food security
J. Li (2009)
10.1146/ANNUREV.RESOURCE.050708.144147
The Economics of the Food System Revolution
T. Reardon (2012)
The rate of crop varietal replacement on farms: measures and empirical results for wheat
J. Brennan (1991)
10.1007/BF02860788
Maize Seed Industries in Developing Countries
M. Eubanks (2008)
Maize in India: Production System, Constraints, and Research Priorities. CIMMYT
P K Joshi (2005)
10.3362/9781780445588
New seed and old laws: regulatory reform and the diversification of national seed systems.
R. Tripp (1997)
Impact of International Maize Breeding Research in the Developing World
M Lopez-Pereira (1994)
10.3152/030234211X12924093660273
Conflicting advocacy coalitions in an evolving modern biotechnology regulatory subsystem: policy learning and influencing Kenya's regulatory policy process
A. Kingiri (2011)
CGIAR's DIIVA project: a consolidated database of crop varietal releases, adoption, and research capacity in Africa south of the Sahara
(2014)
Francis Kanoi Marketing Planning Services (P) Ltd.), 2015P. Agri-inputs marketing research. (Accessed October 2015:) http://franciskanoi.com/agri.htm
Francis Kanoi (2015)
10.1080/15427528.2012.670695
Farmers' Seed Sources and Seed Quality: 1. Physical and Physiological Quality
Z. Bishaw (2012)
Towards Innovation and Growth in Bangladesh's Seed Sector. Paper Presented at a Workshop on “Evidence-Based Policy Options for Food and Nutrition Security in Bangladesh,
F. Naher (2014)
Federation of Indian Chambers of Commerce and Industry/ National Commodity and Derivatives Limited), 2014m
Kpmg / Ficci Ncdex
Bangladesh, India and Nepal sign historic agreement in the evaluation of rice varieties
(2014)
10.1016/J.FOODPOL.2014.01.001
The seed and agricultural biotechnology industries in India: An analysis of industry structure, competition, and policy options
D. Spielman (2014)
10.1111/J.0020-8701.2004.00480.X
Issues in assessing the policy influence of research
F. Carden (2004)
10.4324/9781849774567
Seed trade in rural markets: implications for crop diversity and agricultural development.
L. Lipper (2010)
Import and commercialization of transgenic crops: an Indian perspective.
G. J. Randhawa (2009)
10.4324/9780203125434-17
Success-making and success stories: agronomic research in the spotlight
J. Sumberg (2012)
Impacts of international maize breeding research in the developing world, 1966-1990
L. Pereira (1994)
INTERNATIONAL UNION FOR THE PROTECTION OF NEW VARIETIES OF PLANTS
Fifteenth Session (1985)
The Seed Industry in Indonesia. Paper Presented at the ReSAKSS-Asia Conference “Agricultural Transformation in Asia: Policy Options for Food and Nutrition
E. Jamal (2014)
Private Sector Agricultural Technology Transfer into Bangladesh, Kenya, Senegal , Tanzania, and Zambia. Agricultural Science and Technology Indicators (ASTI) Initiative Project Paper
D Gisselquist (2013)
10.1080/00220380601055601
Stealth seeds: Bioproperty, biosafety, biopolitics
Ronald J. Herring (2007)
10.9783/9780812294217-008
The Architecture of the Pakistani Seed System: A Case of Market-Regulation Dissonance
M. A. Rana (2015)
Guide to Seed Quality Management Practices
(2011)
Agricultural Transformation in Asia: Policy Options for Food and Nutrition Security
E Jamal (2013)
10.1007/s12571-014-0357-1
Taking stock of the genetically modified seed sector worldwide: market, stakeholders, and prices
S. Bonny (2014)
10.21955/GATESOPENRES.1115029.1
ASTI Global assessment of agricultural R&D spending: developing countries accelerate investment
N. Beintema (2012)
Alternatives for seed regulatory reform. An analysis of variety testing, variety regulation and seed quality control
R. Tripp (1997)
Maize in Asia : changing markets and incentives
A. Gulati (2008)
Accurate testing, exceptional service
Isu Stl (2014)
Tropical and subtropical maize in Asia : production systems, constraints, and research priorities
R. Gerpacio (2007)
US-Nepal Hybrid Maize Project Runs into Criticism. (SciDev.net, November 30
Scidev
10.1300/J153v04n01_02
The Importance of the Farmers' Seed Systems in a Functional National Seed Sector
C. Almekinders (2002)
The Role of Seeds in Transforming Agricultural in Nepal. Paper Presented at the ReSAKSS-Asia Conference
R Sah (2013)
Going to Seed: Hybrid and Genetically-modified Seeds may Create more Problems than they Solve
10.1073/pnas.0807414106
Linking international agricultural research knowledge with action for sustainable development
P. Kristjanson (2009)
10.1093/WBRO/9.1.97
THE ROLES OF THE PRIVATE AND PUBLIC SECTORS IN ENHANCING THE PERFORMANCE OF SEED SYSTEMS
S. Jaffee (1994)
10.1016/J.WORLDDEV.2005.05.012
Poor farmers' perceived benefits from different types of maize germplasm: The case of creolization in lowland tropical Mexico
M. Bellon (2006)
The Role of Seeds in Transforming Agricultural in Nepal. Paper Presented at the ReSAKSS-Asia Conference “Agricultural Transformation in Asia: Policy Options for Food and Nutrition Security,
R. Sah (2014)
Measuring the contribution of Bt cotton adoption to India's cotton yields leap
G. Gruère (2012)
Private-Sector Agricultural Research and Innovation in Bangladesh: Overview, Impact, and Policy Options. Agricultural Science and Technology Indicators (ASTI) Initiative Project Paper
H. Ar-Rashid (2012)
10.1111/CJAG.12055
Regulation of Genetically Engineered Crops in India: Implications of Policy Uncertainty for Social Welfare, Competition, and Innovation
Deepthi E. Kolady (2014)
An Innovation Market Approach to Analyzing Impacts of Mergers and Acquisitions in the Plant Biotechnology Industry
Margaret F. Brennan (2005)
LSMS-ISA: Living Standards Measurement Study - Integrated Surveys on Agriculture.
World Bank (2015)
10.1080/15427528.2011.611277
Integrated Seed Sector Development in Africa: A Conceptual Framework for Creating Coherence Between Practices, Programs, and Policies
N. P. Louwaars (2012)
P) Ltd.), 2015P. Agri-inputs marketing research
(2015)
10.1080/10440046.2010.484689
Integrating Genetic Resource Conservation and Sustainable Development into Strategies to Increase the Robustness of Seed Systems
W. S. de Boef (2010)
Understanding the Seed Industry: Contemporary Trends and Analytical Issues
B. Ramaswami (2006)
10.1093/AJAE/AAR016
Distortions to Agricultural Incentives: A Global Perspective
A. Schmitz (2011)
Hybrid Rice in Asia: An Unfolding ThreatAccessed November 2012: www.grain.org/article/ entries/34-hybrid-rice-in-asia-an-unfolding-threat)
D Kuyek (2000)
10.1016/S0048-7333(97)00022-X
DETERMINANTS OF PATENT RIGHTS : A CROSS-NATIONAL STUDY
J. C. Ginarte (1997)
Private-Sector Agricultural Research and Innovation in Zambia Overview, Impact, and Policy Options
M. Mwala (2012)
Accurate testing, exceptional service
Isu-Stl
Stealth seeds: biosafety, bioproperty, biopolitics
R. J. Herring (2007)
Impact of International Maize Breeding Research in the Developing World. International Maize and Wheat Improvement Center (CIMMYT), Mexico, D.F
M. Lopez-Pereira (1994)
Seed laws around the world. (Accessed October 2015:) https://www.grain. org/article/entries/5153-map-seed-laws-around-the-world
(2015)
10.1007/s10658-013-0269-5
Health of farmer-saved maize seed in north-east Nigeria
P. Biemond (2013)
10.1007/978-94-009-7355-8_2
AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS
G. E. Dalton (2003)
10.1016/S0306-9192(98)00014-1
India's maize seed industry in transition: changing roles for the public and private sectors
M. Morris (1998)
10.1093/ajae/aar044
The Economic Returns to U.S. Public Agricultural Research
J. Alston (2011)
10.22004/AG.ECON.33671
THE SEED INDUSTRY IN U.S. AGRICULTURE: AN EXPLORATION OF DATA AND INFORMATION ON CROP SEED MARKETS, REGULATION, INDUSTRY STRUCTURE, AND RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT
J. Fernandez-Cornejo (2004)
American Seed Trade Association), 2011. Guide to Seed Quality Management Practices
Seed Industry in Thailand: Market Structure, Regulations, Policies and Prospect
O Napasintuwong (1920)
Patterns of Adoption of Improved Maize Technologies in Ghana
C. Ragasa (2013)
Accessed September 2015: http://www.scidev.net/global/ biotechnology/news/us-nepal-hybrid-maize-project-runs-into-criticism.html)
(2011)
Biotechnology policy documents of FAO members
(2015)
10.2499/0896291162rr113
A meta-analysis of rates of return to agricultural R&D : ex pede Herculem?
J. Alston (2000)
The Seed Industry in Pakistan: Regulation, Politics and Entrepreneurship
M. A. Rana (2014)
10.2307/2074067
First the seed : the political economy of plant biotechnology, 1492-2000
Jack Kloppenburg (1989)
10.1111/j.0002-9092.2005.720_4.x
Agricultural Research Policy in an Era of Privatization
J. Gillespie (2005)
10.1596/978-0-8213-7665-2
Distortions to agricultural incentives : a global perspective, 1955-2007
K. Anderson (2009)
The Seed Industry in Indonesia. Paper Presented at the ReSAKSS-Asia Conference Agricultural Transformation in Asia: Policy Options for Food and Nutrition Security
E Jamal (2013)
Pakistan : corporate hybrid seeds fl ood efforts in agricultural reconstruction
G. P. Gruère (2010)
10.1079/9780851995496.0000
Crop Variety Improvement and its Effect on Productivity: The Impact of International Agricultural Research
R. Evenson (2003)
Hybrid Rice in Asia: An Unfolding Threat
D Kuyek
ISAAA (International Service for the Acquisition of Agri-Biotech Applications)
Index of Patent Rights
W. G. Park (2002)
10.1016/J.FCR.2014.06.021
How an improved sorghum variety evolves in a traditional seed system in Mali: Effects of farmers’ practices on the maintenance of phenotype and genetic composition
M. Deu (2014)
Maize in India: Production Systems, Constraints, and Research Priorities
P. Joshi (2005)
A consolidated database of crop varietal releases, adoption, and research capacity in South Asia
10.1080/01296612.2007.11726860
Thailand
Prangtip Daorueng (2007)
10.2499/9780896298279
Benchmarking Agricultural Research Indicators Across Asia–Pacific:
Kathleen R Flaherty (2013)
10.1016/J.FOODPOL.2015.07.008
Farmer seed networks make a limited contribution to agriculture? Four common misconceptions
O. Coomes (2015)
10.1016/j.ejor.2006.12.015
Coordinating the supply chain in the agricultural seed industry
S. Burer (2008)
Ministry of Agriculture and Farmers Welfare), 2007e
Goi Government (2015)
10.1186/1471-2148-14-1
Modern maize varieties going local in the semi-arid zone in Tanzania
Ola T Westengen (2013)
International patent protection.
M. R. Russel (1985)
PRIVATE INVESTMENT IN AGRICULTURAL RESEARCH AND INTERNATIONAL TECHNOLOGY TRANSFER IN ASIA
C. Pray (2001)
Nepali Times Going to Seed: Hybrid and Genetically-modified Seeds may Create more Problems than they Solve
(2011)
Distortions to agricultural incentives
K. Anderson (2009)
SeedNet India Portal - A National Initiative of Information Services on Quality Seeds to Indian Farmers for Agricultural Productivity Increase
S. Usman (2009)
A Meta-analysis of the Rates of Return to Agricultural R&D
J. M. Alston (2000)
10.1111/J.1574-0862.2003.TB00161.X
Estimating the benefits of plant breeding research: methodological issues and practical challenges
M. Morris (2003)
Technological opportunity, regulatory uncertainty, and the economics of Bt Cotton in Pakistan:
D. Spielman (2014)
10.2307/1908006
First the Seed: The Political Economy of Plant Biotechnology, 1492-2000
D. Kevles (1988)
10.1111/J.1759-5436.2011.00232.X
The politics of seed in Africa's green revolution: Alternative narratives and competing pathways
I. Scoones (2011)
Industrial Market Structure and Economic Performance
Charles F. Phillips (1971)
Thailand: Market Structure, Regulations, Policies and Prospect. Contributed Paper Presented at the 18th International Consortium on Applied Bioeconomy Research: Bioeconomy and Development
O Napasintuwong (1920)
10.1007/s40003-015-0151-0
Emerging Trends in the Public and Private Investment in Agricultural Research in India
A. Singh (2015)
Open-pollinated Maize Varieties: A Backward Step or Valuable Option for Farmers
K. Pixley (2002)
Indian Seed Industry: Market Overview and Outlook. Industry Note No
Rabobank (2006)
10.21955/GATESOPENRES.1115552.1
Intellectual Property Rights, Private Investment in Research, and Productivity Growth in Indian Agriculture A Review of Evidence and Options
Deepthi E. Kolady (2010)
10.1079/9780851998596.0000
Saving seeds: the economics of conserving crop genetic resources ex situ in the future harvest centres of the CGIAR.
Bonwoo Koo (2004)
10.2307/525223
Africa's Emerging Maize Revolution
D. Byerlee (1997)
International Service for the Acquisition of Agri-Biotech Applications), 2015i. GM approval database
(2015)
Distortions to Agricultural Incentives. World Bank
K Anderson (2009)
10.1007/978-1-4614-4602-6_3
Perspectives on Policy Analysis: A Framework for Understanding and Design
I. Mayer (2004)
Integrated Approaches to Higher Maize Productivity in the New Millennium
Dennis K. Friesen (2004)
10.1111/J.1574-0862.2003.TB00168.X
The roles of public sector versus private sector in R&D and technology generation: the case of maize in Asia
R. Gerpacio (2003)
10.1007/BF01024300
Market share inequality, the HHI, and other measures of the firm-composition of a market
S. Rhoades (1995)
PPV&FR (Protection of Plan Varieties and Farmers' Rights Authority, India)
(2007)
Federation of Indian Chambers of Commerce and Industry/ National Commodity and Derivatives Limited), 2014m. Maize in India: India Maize Summit '14
KpmgFicciNcdex kpmg
10.1186/s12863-015-0183-2
Variability of candidate genes, genetic structure and association with sugar accumulation and climacteric behavior in a broad germplasm collection of melon (Cucumis melo L.)
C. Leida (2015)
Tracking Improved Varieties in South Asia project), 2015). A consolidated database of crop varietal releases, adoption, and research capacity in South Asia
(2015)
Hybrid Rice in Asia : An Unfolding Threat
A. S. Langyintuo (2000)
Seednet India Portal: national initiative for information on quality seeds
Seednet (2015)
Frascati Manual. OECD, Proposed Standard Practice for Surveys on Research and Experimental Development
(2002)
Food Sovereignty: Turning the Global Food System Upside Down https://www.grain.org/article/ entries/491-food-sovereignty-turning-the-global-food-system-upside-down)
(2005)
10.2135/CROPSCI2006.0001BR
First the Seed
R. P. Cantrell (2006)
10.1093/OEP/55.2.235
Does Intellectual Property Protection Spur Technological Change?
Robert E. Evenson (2001)
The seed industry in Vietnam”. Paper presented at the ReSAKSS-Asia conference “agricultural transformation in Asia: policy options for food and nutrition security
N. Mau Dung (2014)
Going to Seed: Hybrid and Genetically-modified Seeds may Create more Problems than they Solve.”Nepali
Nepali Times (2011)
Maize in India: Production System
P K Joshi (2005)
10.1016/J.RESPOL.2008.01.006
International patent protection: 1960-2005
W. Park (2008)
The Seed Industry in Pakistan: Regulation, Politics and Entrepreneurship. Pakistan Strategy Support Program (PSSP) Working Paper No. 19IFPRI, Washington
M A Rana (2014)
PhillipsMcDougal. (Accessed September 2015:) http://www. phillipsmcdougall.com/home.asp
P. McDougal (2015)
10.1079/9780851990835.0000
Valuing Crop Biodiversity: On-Farm Genetic Resources and Economic Change
M. Smale (2005)
10.2139/ssrn.2027051
Research Investments and Market Structure in the Food Processing, Agricultural Input, and Biofuel Industries Worldwide
K. Fuglie (2011)
10.1017/S0014479709991074
UNDERSTANDING AND STRENGTHENING INFORMAL SEED MARKETS
L. Sperling (2010)
10.1111/j.1467-8489.2008.00435.x
Wheat Breeding, Productivity and Slow Variety Change: Evidence from the Punjab of India after the Green Revolution
M. Smale (2008)
10.1016/S1096-7508(01)00038-6
LIBERALIZATION'S IMPACT ON THE INDIAN SEED INDUSTRY: COMPETITION, RESEARCH, AND IMPACT ON FARMERS
C. Pray (1999)
Innovation and research by private agribusiness in India
C. Pray (2012)
10.1186/s12863-015-0273-1
Tracking crop varieties using genotyping-by-sequencing markers: a case study using cassava (Manihot esculenta Crantz)
I. Rabbi (2015)
10.17660/ACTAHORTIC.2006.714.22
NEW DEVELOPMENTS IN THE INTERNATIONAL UNION FOR THE PROTECTION OF NEW VARIETIES OF PLANTS (UPOV)
P. Button (2006)
10.1111/J.1477-9552.2012.00335.X
The Impact of Seed Policy Reforms and Intellectual Property Rights on Crop Productivity in India
Deepthi E. Kolady (2012)
10.1016/S0306-9192(97)00033-X
Seed regulation: choices on the road to reform
R. Tripp (1997)
2002n. Frascati Manual . OECD, Proposed Standard Practice for Surveys on Research and Experimental Development



This paper is referenced by
10.1007/978-3-030-53017-4
Sustainable Agriculture Reviews 45: Legume Agriculture and Biotechnology Vol 1
Praveen Guleria (2020)
Strategies for Catalyzing Business Innovation in Small-Scale Agribusinesses in Southern Africa
Golden Mahove (2019)
10.20381/RUOR-22879
Seed Governance in Tanzania: Seed Capitalism, Pluralism, and Sovereignty Discourses Compared, and the Value of Nuance
K. Moore (2019)
10.4157/GEOGREVJAPANB.91.40
Influence of Trading Structure on Maize Seed Selection by Farmers in Vietnam: Case Study on Yen Chau District, Son La Province
Ngoc Nguyen Hong (2018)
10.1007/S13593-020-00636-1
Citizen science breathes new life into participatory agricultural research. A review
J. V. D. Gevel (2020)
The contribution of seed systems to crop and tree diversity in sustainable food systems Seeds
J. Etten (2017)
10.5539/SAR.V6N4P12
Implications of seed policies for on-farm agro-biodiversity in Ethiopia and Uganda
G. Otieno (2017)
10.1111/1477-9552.12395
Information Barriers to Adoption of Agricultural Technologies: Willingness to Pay for Certified Seed of an Open Pollinated Maize Variety in Northern Uganda
A. Mastenbroek (2020)
10.21955/GATESOPENRES.1115279.1
Policy Options to Accelerate Variety Change Among Smallholder Farmers in South Asia and Africa South of the Sahara
D. Spielman (2017)
10.1007/978-3-030-53017-4_9
Transformation of Agricultural Breeding Techniques Using Biotechnology as a Tool
E. Khare (2020)
10.1002/9781119616801.ch5
The Foundations, Continuing Evolution, and Outcomes from the Application of Intellectual Property Protection in Plant Breeding and Agriculture
S. Smith (2019)
10.17170/KOBRA-202003241098
Thailand’s maize seed market structure, conduct, performance
O. Napasintuwong (2020)
10.1016/j.procs.2019.09.289
Design Science Information System Framework for Managing the Articulations of Digital Agroecosystems
S. Nimmagadda (2019)
10.1007/978-981-32-9648-0_8
Seed Sector Development in Nepal: Opportunities and Options for Improvement
D. Gauchan (2019)
10.3389/fsufs.2018.00073
Raising the Stakes: Cassava Seed Networks at Multiple Scales in Cambodia and Vietnam
Erik Delaquis (2018)
10.5772/intechopen.94212
Varietal Release, Notification and Denotification System in India
S. Chand (2020)
Integrer l’agrobiodiversite dans les systemes alimentaires durables: Fondements scientifiques d’un indice de l’agrobiodiversite - Synthese
A. Bailey (2016)
10.1016/J.GFS.2019.05.001
New evidence on concentration in seed markets
K. Deconinck (2019)
10.1088/1755-1315/484/1/012122
Barrier to entry and feasibility of community based corn seed agribusiness: study case in Sigi Regency Central Sulawesi
Heni Sp Rahayu (2020)
10.1007/s10460-020-10170-1
Transforming a traditional commons-based seed system through collaborative networks of farmer seed-cooperatives and public breeding programs: the case of sorghum in Mali
F. Rattunde (2020)
Semantic Scholar Logo Some data provided by SemanticScholar