← Back to Search
Aggregation Bias In Estimates Of Perceptual Agreement.
Published 1982 · Psychology
Download PDFAnalyze on Scholarcy
Abstract : It is shown that estimates of agreement based on group mean scores have been incorrectly interpreted as applying to perceptual agreement among individuals. Of initial importance is a study by Drexler (1977), who concluded that a considerable proportion of the variance in climate perceptions is accounted for by organizational membership. This conclusion has been employed recently by other authors to support the assumption that individuals in the same environment tend to agree with respect to climate perceptions. The present paper demonstrates that Drexler's analysis provided inflated estimates of agreement among individuals. The logic of the approach is then extended to other studies in which inflated estimates of agreement appeared likely. (Author)
This paper references
Relationships of perceptions of organizational climate to organizational structure, context, and hierarchical position.
R. Payne (1973)
Group climate: An exploratory analysis of construct validity
J. Howe (1977)
Statistical Principles in Experimental Design
B. Winer (1962)
On Various Intraclass Correlation Reliability Coefficients
J. Bartko (1976)
Development of the Job Diagnostic Survey
J. Hackman (1975)
Understanding the organizational structure — Job attitude relationship through perceptions of the work environment
J. E. Newman (1975)
Psychological climate: Dimensions and relationships of individual and aggregated work environment perceptions☆
A. Jones (1979)
Organizational structure: a review of structural dimensions and their conceptual relationships with individual attitudes and behavior
L. James (1976)
Organizational Climates: An Essay.
B. Schneider (1975)
Organizational climate: Its homogeneity within organizations.
John A. Drexler (1977)
Aggregate Data: Analysis and Interpretation
E. Borgatta (1980)
G. G. stern's organizational climate index: A reconceptualization and application to business organizations
R. Payne (1971)
A Theory of Behavior in Organizations
J. C. Naylor (1980)
An investigation of the validity of leader behavior descriptions obtained from subordinates.
D. R. Ilgen (1976)
Employee reactions to job characteristics.
J. Hackman (1971)
A statistical rationale for relating situational variables and individual differences
L. James (1980)
PSYCHOLOGICAL CLIMATE: IMPLICATIONS FROM COGNITIVE SOCIAL LEARNING THEORY AND INTERACTIONAL PSYCHOLOGY
L. James (1978)
Organizational climate: A review of theory and research.
L. James (1974)
Organizational climate: Individual preferences and organizational realities.
B. Schneider (1972)
Statistical Theories of Mental Test Scores.
Maurice M. Tatsuoka (1968)
Interactionism in personality from a historical perspective.
B. Ekehammar (1974)
Intraclass correlations: uses in assessing rater reliability.
P. Shrout (1979)
LEADERSHIP BEHAVIOR: DEMOGRAPHIC FACTORS AND AGREEMENT BETWEEN SUBORDINATE AND SELF-DESCRIPTIONS
M. Evans (1972)
The social psychology of organizing
K. Weick (1969)
Conditions under which employees respond positively to enriched work
G. R. Oldham (1976)
Psychology of work behavior
Frank J. Landy (1976)
A generalized expression for the reliability of measures
P. Horst (1949)
Toward a macropsychology.
G. Katona (1979)
ENVIRONMENTAL VARIATION IN STUDIES OF ORGANIZATIONAL BEHAVIOR.
G. Forehand (1964)
Employee and Customer Perceptions of Service in Banks.
B. Schneider (1980)
Aggregation and disaggregation in sociology
M. Hannan (1970)
Developing an Interdisciplinary Science of Organizations.
R. S. Bhagat (1979)
The Case for Subsystem Climates in Organizations
C. N. Powell (1978)
Estimation from Grouped Observations
M. Hannan (1974)
Toward A Psychology of Situations : An Interactional Perspective
D. Magnusson (1981)
The motivational strategies used by supervisors: Relationships to effectiveness indicators
G. R. Oldham (1976)
Organizational structure and climate
R. L. Payne (1976)
Effects of changes in job characteristics on work attitudes and behaviors: A naturally occurring quasi-experiment☆
J. Hackman (1978)
Some relationships between job satisfaction and organization climate.
B. Schneider (1975)
Organizational Climate: Science or Folklore?
R. Woodman (1978)
Management styles associated with organizational, task, personal, and interpersonal contingencies.
B. M. Bass (1975)
Organizational climate and job satisfaction: a conceptual synthesis
R. Payne (1976)
A note on organizational climate
R. Guion (1973)
Motivation and Organizational Climate
G. H. Litwin (1968)
Psychological climate: Some theoretical and empirical considerations†
James F. Gavin (1975)
Some observations on two methods in psychology.
H. E. Brogden (1972)
INDIVIDUAL DIFFERENCES AND ORGANIZATIONAL CLIMATE II: MEASUREMENT OF ORGANIZATIONAL CLIMATE BY THE MULTI-TRAIT, MULTI-RATER MATRIX
B. Schneider (1970)
Estimation of the reliability of ratings
R. L. Ebel (1951)
The effects of organizational climate on managerial job performance and job satisfaction
R. Pritchard (1973)
This paper is referenced by
and Team Members ' Reactions to Conflict The Influence of Team Emotional Intelligence Climate on Conflict
O. B. Ayoko (2008)
Cross-Level Inference and Organizational Research: Perspectives on Interpretation and Application
K. W. Mossholder (1983)
An approach for confirmatory measurement and structural equation modeling of organizational properties
J. Anderson (1987)
Explaining Psychological Climate: Is Perceptual Agreement Necessary?
F. Moussavi (1990)
Perceptual Agreement as an Aggregation Criterion: An Empirical Study of a Debate in Climate Research
F. Moussavi (1990)
Levels Issues in Theory Development, Data Collection, and Analysis
Katherine J. Klein (1994)
Multilevel theory of team decision making: Decision performance in teams incorporating distributed expertise.
J. Hollenbeck (1995)
Exploring the Conceptual Expansion within the Field of Organizational Behaviour: Organizational Climate and Organizational Culture
Willem J. Verbeke (1998)
A General Approach for Representing Constructs in Organizational Research
R. Bagozzi (1998)
A multiple-goal, multilevel model of feedback effects on the regulation of individual and team performance.
R. P. Deshon (2004)
Effects of Managerial Drivers and Climate Maturity on Knowledge-Management Performance: Empirical Validation
Jang-Hwan Lee (2001)
Toward a deeper understanding of system usage in organizations
Safety climate: Conceptual and measurement issues.
D. Zohar (2011)
El Clima Organizacional en el Diseño del Balanced Scorecard: Evaluación Psicométrica de un Instrumento de Medida
Roseane Patrícia de Araújo Silva Freire (2011)
The mechanisms and work group context in the victimization of high performers
Yui Jin Eugene Kim (2012)
An Empirical Study of Group Stewardship and Learning: Implications for Work Group Effectiveness
Richard L. Groesbeck (2001)
TMT Potency and Strategic Decision�?Making in High Technology Firms
K. Clark (2012)
Status Inertia and Member Replacement in Role-Differentiated Teams
J. S. Bunderson (2014)
Organizational climate and climate strength in UK hospitals
J. Dawson (2008)
Answers to 20 Questions About Interrater Reliability and Interrater Agreement
J. Lebreton (2008)
Safety Performance in the Construction Sector: The Influence of Transformational Leadership and the Mediating Role of Safety Climate
R. Schutte (2010)
Service climate in knowledge-intensive, internal service settings
Ronnie Jia (2016)
Assessing community effects on adolescent substance use and delinquency
M. L. Horn (2007)
Cross-Functional Project Groups in Research and New Product Development: Diversity, Communications, Job Stress, and Outcomes
R. T. Keller (2001)
Perceived support for mentoring: A multiple perspectives approach
L. Eby (2006)
Measurement Error in Research on Human Resource Decisions and Firm Performance: How Much Error is There and How Does its Influence Effect Size Estimates?
Barry A. Gerhart (2015)
Integration and Extension of Leader-Member Exchange and Organizational Justice and Individual- and Group-Levels of Analysis
R. Suk (2008)
Organizational culture and physician satisfaction with dimensions of group practice.
J. Zazzali (2007)
An examination of the antecedents and moderator influences of climate strength.
V. González-romá (2002)
The role of organization culture in service operation : effects on customer satisfaction and employees' affective outcomes
Torvald Øgaard (1999)
The effect of high performance work systems utilization on firm performance: does human resource attribution of employees matter?
Shibiru Ayalew Melesse (2015)
The influence of high commitment HR system on turnover intention at the individual level: a critical view