Online citations, reference lists, and bibliographies.
← Back to Search

Comparative Study Of The Efficacy Of Four Topical Anesthetics.

P. Friedman, J. P. Fogelman, K. Nouri, V. Levine, R. Ashinoff
Published 1999 · Medicine

Cite This
Download PDF
Analyze on Scholarcy
BACKGROUND With the emergence of new laser and dermatologic procedures, the need for more effective topical anesthesia continues to grow. There are now several topical anesthetics that are being used prior to laser and surgical procedures. OBJECTIVE To compare the degree and duration of anesthesia produced by four commonly used topical anesthetics, we performed a prospective study investigating the efficacy of EMLA (eutectic mixture of local anesthetics), ELA-Max, 4% tetracaine gel, and betacaine-LA ointment (formerly eutectic-LA). METHODS Equal amounts of the above topical anesthetics plus a control (eucerin cream) were applied to 10 test sites under occlusion on the volar forearms of 12 adult volunteers. After a 60-minute application time, the degree of anesthesia was assessed immediately by a Q-switched Nd:YAG laser at 1064 nm. Pain testing was also performed 30 minutes after the 60-minute application period. Volunteer responses to pain stimuli were recorded using an ordinal scale of 0 (no pain) to 4 (maximal pain). The mean scores for the time intervals were obtained. Analysis of the data was performed using analysis of variance (ANOVA), Newman-Keuls test, Friedman rank order test, and paired t-tests. RESULTS ELA-Max, EMLA, and tetracaine were statistically superior to control after the 60-minute application period. Thirty minutes later, ELA-Max, EMLA, tetracaine, and betacaine-LA were all statistically superior to the control. Comparing individual anesthetics, ELA-Max and EMLA were the superior anesthetics at both time intervals. Although the mean pain scores for each anesthetic were lower 30 minutes after their removal, the differences did not reach statistical significance. CONCLUSION This is the first prospective study comparing the efficacy of several new topical anesthetic agents. Using the methodology of this study, in which the anesthetics were applied under occlusion, ELA-Max and EMLA were the superior anesthetics after a 60-minute application time and 30 minutes later. In addition, there was a clinical increase in efficacy suggested with all of the anesthetics 30 minutes after their removal.
This paper references
Split skin grafting using topical local anaesthesia (EMLA): a comparison with infiltrated anaesthesia.
T. Goodacre (1988)
EMLA cream reduces the pain of venepuncture in children.
C. M. Cooper (1987)
Venepuncture pain can be reduced.
L. Kurien (1985)
Topical Analgesia for the Cutting of Split-Skin Grafts: A Multicenter Comparison of Two Doses of a Lidocaine/Prilocaine Cream
T. Lähteenmäki (1988)
Pain‐free injection in infants
C. S. Hopkins (1988)
Statistical Principles in Experimental Design
B. Winer (1962)
Liposomes as penetration promoters and localizers of topically applied drugs
M. Mezei (1994)
Fisher's Contact Dermatitis
R. Rietschel (1995)
Topical anaesthesia for fistula cannulation in haemodialysis patients.
A. Watson (1988)
Dermal effects of compositions based on the eutectic mixture of lignocaine and prilocaine (EMLA). Studies in volunteers.
H. Evers (1985)
A lignocaine-prilocaine cream reduces venipuncture pain.
C. Möller (1985)
Topical Anesthesia of the Skin by Liposome‐Encapsulated Tetracaine
A. Gesztes (1988)
Dermal drug delivery by liposome encapsulation: clinical and electron microscopic studies.
M. Foldvari (1990)
Pain-free venepuncture. Effect of timing of application of local anaesthetic cream.
B. Hallén (1983)
Comparison of Skin Anesthetic Effect of Liposomal Lidocaine, Nonliposomal Lidocaine, and EMLA Using 30‐minute Application Time
B. D. Bucalo (1998)
An anaesthetic lidocaine/prilocaine cream (EMLA) for epicutaneous application tested for cutting split skin grafts.
L. Ohlsén (1985)
Laser‐Induced Pain for Evaluation of Local Analgesia: A Comparison of Topical Application (EMLA) and Local Injection (Lidocaine)
L. Arendt-Nielsen (1988)
D. Mccafferty (1993)
Contact allergy and cross-reactions caused by prilocaine.
R. Suhonen (1997)
Comparison of iontophoresis of lidocaine with a eutectic mixture of lidocaine and prilocaine (EMLA) for topically administered local anesthesia.
S. Greenbaum (1994)
Biostatistical Analysis (2nd ed.).
T. Breen (1986)
Evaluation of topical anesthetics by laser‐induced sensation: Comparison of EMLA 5% cream and 40% lidocaine in an acid mantle ointment
E. Hernandez (1998)
Double-blind evaluation of a lignocaine-prilocaine cream (EMLA) in children. Effect on the pain associated with venous cannulation.
E. Maunuksela (1986)

This paper is referenced by
EMLA Versus Ice as a Topical Anesthetic
R. Kuwahara (2001)
Review of a New Topical Anesthetic, Liposomal Lidocaine, for Procedural Pain in Children
A. Yip (2005)
Local anesthetic cream prepared from lidocaine-tetracaine eutectic mixture.
Keiichi Ohzeki (2008)
Pediatric Anesthesia in Dermatologic Surgery: When Hand‐Holding is Not Enough
B. Chen (2001)
ELA-max: A New Topical Lidocaine Formulation
R. Goldman (2004)
Surgical pearl: tumescent anesthesia reduces pain of axillary laser hair removal.
J. Krejci-Manwaring (2004)
Transdermal absorption of a liposome-encapsulated formulation of lidocaine following topical administration in cats.
B. Fransson (2002)
Der Weg ist das Ziel: Dermatologisches Drug Targeting
H. C. Korting (2003)
Liposome-encapsulated ropivacaine for intraoral topical anesthesia.
M. Franz-Montan (2010)
Anesthesia for dermatologic surgery
G. Menaker (2001)
Percutaneous dermal drug delivery for local pain control
Sujatha Tadicherla (2006)
A randomized, double‐blind comparison study of EMLA® and ELA‐Max® for topical anesthesia in children undergoing intravenous insertion
J. Koh (2004)
Principles of office anesthesia: part II. Topical anesthesia.
S. Kundu (2002)
Anesthesia for Lasers
Annelyse Cristine Ballin (2014)
Local anesthetic effects of Lidocaine cream: randomized controlled trial using a standardized prick pain
K. Herberger (2012)
Lasers in dermatology: four decades of progress.
E. Tanzi (2003)
Topical Anesthetics Update: EMLA and Beyond
P. Friedman (2001)
A clinical comparison of topical piroxicam and EMLA cream for pain relief and inflammation in laser hair removal
S. Akinturk (2008)
Single‐Center, Double‐Blind, Randomized Study to Evaluate the Efficacy of 4% Lidocaine Cream versus Vehicle Cream During Botulinum Toxin Type A Treatments
A. Carruthers (2005)
Comparison of five commonly-available, lidocaine-containing topical anesthetics and their effect on serum levels of lidocaine and its metabolite monoethylglycinexylidide (MEGX).
Georgette Oni (2012)
Complications of Removal Lasers
Remington (2012)
Topical anesthetics for pediatric laser treatment
Marija Stevic (2019)
Lidocaine/tetracaine peel in topical anesthesia prior to laser-assisted hair removal: Phase-II and Phase-III study results
T. Alster (2014)
Structural Classification of Complex Molecules by Artificial Intelligence Techniques
Francisco Torrens (2012)
Topical anaesthetic effects on skin vasculature with potential implications for laser treatment
C. J. Tollan (2016)
Pharmacokinetic and Pharmacodynamic Evaluation of a Nanotechnological Topical Formulation of Lidocaine/Prilocaine (Nanorap) in Healthy Volunteers
Thiago Gagliano-Jucá (2015)
Information entropy and the classification of local anaesthetics
F. Torrens (2007)
Self‐Warming Lidocaine/Tetracaine Patch Effectively and Safely Induces Local Anesthesia during Minor Dermatologic Procedures
B. Berman (2005)
Clinical effect of ablative fractional laser-assisted topical anesthesia on human skin: A randomized pilot study
T. Tian (2016)
Eruption hematomas: report of 3 clinical cases in infants
L. H. Almeida (2015)
The use of fractionated ablative lasers as a transdermal microporation technique
G. Oni (2013)
Evaluation of the S‐Caine Peel for Induction of Local Anesthesia for Laser‐Assisted Tattoo Removal: Randomized, Double‐Blind, Placebo‐Controlled, Multicenter Study
J. S. Chen (2005)
See more
Semantic Scholar Logo Some data provided by SemanticScholar