Online citations, reference lists, and bibliographies.
Please confirm you are human
(Sign Up for free to never see this)
← Back to Search

A Service, A ‘way Of Working’, Or A Profession? A Discourse Analysis Of Community Education/community Learning And Development In Scotland

G. Mackie, H. Sercombe, Anne Ryan
Published 2013 · Sociology

Save to my Library
Download PDF
Analyze on Scholarcy
Community-based informal education, like other practices, is fundamentally shaped by the discourses under which it is constituted. In Scotland, since 1975, the practice has been formally established by government policy as an amalgam of youth work, adult education and community development under a discourse of informal education. This combination carries its own internal tensions alongside the continually contested relationship between the field of practice and the State. This study analyses key documents in order to chart the shifts in discourse around the constitution of Community Education/Community Learning and Development since 1975. The analysis reveals the force of managerialist discourses which transformed understandings of the practice from post-war welfare state discourses as a service, to its reshaping as technique under New Labour. Current discursive work is directed to its reconstitution (still somewhat ambivalently) as a profession. This ‘re-professionalisation’ connects with similar movements in medicine, social work, parole and teaching which are attempting to reduce the costs of actuarial disciplinary techniques (in record-keeping, reporting and the generation of outcome data) by returning professional trust and judgement to practitioners.
This paper references
An Introduction to Critical Discourse Analysis in Education
R. Rogers (2011)
Community education, community learning and development
D. Wallace (2008)
Naming youth: the construction of the youth category
H. Sercombe (1996)
Madness and Civilisation
H. Merskey (1967)
The Foucault Reader
Michel Foucault (1984)
A collection of readings related to competency-based training: EAE604 curriculum and competencies. Geelong: Deakin University. Committee of Inquiry into Labour Market Programs
M Brown (1985)
The three types of legitimate domination
M Weber (1922)
The Foucault reader. Harmondsworth: Penguin
P Rabinow (1986)
Community learning and development: The way forward
Scottish Executive. (2002)
Vulgar eloquence: From labour to liberation: Essays on education
C Kirkwood (1990)
Audit Cultures: Anthropological Studies in Accountability, Ethics and the Academy
M. Strathern (2000)
Discourse Analysis: What Makes It Critical?
J. Gee (2004)
An introduction to the discourse on competency-based training (CBT)
M. Brown (1994)
Making sense of community. London: Institute for Public Policy
V. London HMSO. Nash (2003)
New Labour's communitarianisms
Stephen Driver (1997)
The ground of professional ethics
C. Miles (1995)
Performance Based Teacher Education. What is the State of the Art
S. Elam (1972)
Youth Work Ethics
J. Roberts (2009)
Informal education: Conversation, democracy and learning
T. Jeffs (2005)
Empowered to practice: The future of community learning and development training in Scotland
Scottish Executive (2003)
Report by a Committee of Inquiry (The Alexander Report)
Youth Work Ethics
H. Sercombe (2010)
Under new management: changing conceptions of teacher professionalism and policy in the further education sector
F. Shain (1999)
Making sense of community
V. Nash (2003)
Critical Discourse Analysis
R. Wodak (2003)
Community Education and Community Development
C. Fletcher (1989)
Vulgar eloquence: From labour to liberation
The Cambridge Introduction to Michel Foucault
M. Lexow (2011)
Strengthening standards: Improving the quality of community learning and development service delivery (The Milburn Report)
Scottish Executive (2006)
Critical Discourse Analysis
J. Sheyholislami, (2002)
The History of Sexuality: An Introduction
M. Foucault (2012)
Communities: Change through learning (The Osler Report)
Methods of critical discourse analysis
Adrián Thays (2010)
Tensions in medical work between patients' interests and administrative and organisational constraints
W Vogt (2006)
Policy, people, and the new professional: de-professionalisation and re-professionalisation in care and welfare
J. W. Duyvendak (2006)
Discourse and Communication
T. Kuhn (2014)
Making up People
D. Sparti (2001)
Building a leadership capacity for system
P. Education. Matthews (2010)
Working for Democracy: Review of Community Education Training. SCRE Research Report.
Heather Malcolm (2002)
Training for change: A report on community education training
Scientific Management, Bureau-Professionalism, New Managerialism: The Labour Process of State Social Work
J. Harris (1998)
Discourse as Social Interaction
T. Dijk (1997)
Working and learning together to build stronger communities
Scottish Executive (2004)
From popular enlightenment to lifelong learning : a history of adult education in Scotland 1707-2005
A. Cooke (2006)
Managing in the post‐managerialist era: Towards socially responsible corporate governance
J. Simmons (2004)
Critical Discourse Analysis in Education: A Review of the Literature
R. Rogers (2005)
On the genealogy of ethics: An overview of work in progress
M Foucault (1984)
Community education and community development. Dundee: Dundee College of Education
L Bidwell (1982)
Learning for change: Community education and community development. Glasgow: Community Development Foundation
A. Barr (1996)
Community Education, Lifelong Learning and Social Inclusion:
L. Tett (2002)
Who is an author?
K. Swedberg (2008)
Report of the committee of inquiry into labour market programs: Overview of the report and recommendations (The Kirby Report)
Committee of Inquiry into Labour Market Programs. (1985)
Madness and civilization : a history of insanity in the age of reason
Michel Foucault (1966)
community and politics
D. Polygon. Koehn (1994)
Teacher professionalism and cultural diversity: Skills, knowledge and values for a changing Australia
Fiona Hilferty (2008)
J. Beck (2008)
The Youth Service in England and Wales.
R. B. Marks (1960)
Building leadership capacity for system improvement in Victoria, Australia
P. Matthews (2008)

This paper is referenced by
Semantic Scholar Logo Some data provided by SemanticScholar