Nutrition Epidemiology: How Do We Know What They Ate?
Published 1991 · Medicine
Download PDFAnalyze on Scholarcy
It is generally believed but difficult to prove that diet plays a role in the risk of various diseases. This paper reviews strengths and deficiencies of select diet-assessment methods used in epidemiologic studies with particular reference to their use in the study of osteoporosis. Direct observation or weighed food records are useful primarily as validation for less intrusive methods. Complete food history by interview or food diary (by self report) is expensive and time consuming. A 24-h diet recall obtained by a trained dietitian can provide accurate, quantitative information on recent intake but does not represent usual intake. Food frequency questionnaires provide better estimates of usual diet but are less quantitative and subject to problems of recall and seasonality. No method is universally the best. Lack of an expected diet-disease association may reflect exposure misclassification, inadequate statistical power, or limited range of the nutrients studied. Given the differences in diet-assessment methods, studies of dietary calcium and osteoporotic fracture have had surprisingly similar results.
This paper references
Alternatives in the collection and analysis of food frequency interview data.
Jonathan M Samet (1984)
Errors in reported dietary intakes. II. Long-term recall.
M. Wu (1988)
Validating the 24 - hour recall method as a dietary survey tool
A review of the methods used by studies of dietary measurement.
H Lee-Han (1989)
Validity of a food frequency questionnaire for the determination of individual food intake.
Barbara J. Mullen (1984)
The dietary history as a tool in research
B. S. Burke (1947)
A short dietary method for epidemiologic studies. 3. Development of questionnaire.
Jean H. Hankin (1968)
A comparison of dietary methods in nutritional studies.
Janice E. Stuff (1983)
Reliability of diet measures as chronic disease risk factors.
George G. Rhoads (1987)
Critical appraisal of the evidence that dietary fat intake is related to breast cancer risk in humans.
Pamela J. Goodwin (1987)
DIETARY CALCIUM AND RISK OF HIP FRACTURE: 14-YEAR PROSPECTIVE POPULATION STUDY
T. Holbrook (1988)
Measurement error and its impact on partial correlation and multiple linear regression analyses.
K. Liu (1988)
Estimates of food quantity and calories: errors in self-report among obese patients.
D. Lansky (1982)
Effects of intraindividual and interindividual variation in repeated dietary records.
C. Sempos (1985)
Dietary fat and the risk of breast cancer.
P. van’t Veer (1990)
Sources of variance in 24-hour dietary recall data: implications for nutrition study design and interpretation.
G. Beaton (1979)
Diet, serum cholesterol, and death from coronary heart disease. The Western Electric study.
R. Shekelle (1981)
A comparison of dietary methods in epidemiologic studies.
Robert W. Morgan (1978)
Some difficulties inherent in the interpretation of dietary data from free-living populations.
Tavia Gordon (1984)
A review of validations of dietary assessment methods.
G. Block (1982)
Nutritional epidemiology: issues and challenges.
W. Willett (1987)
Issues in reproducibility and validity of dietary studies.
G. Block (1989)
Dietary calcium, physical activity, and risk of hip fracture: a prospective study.
C. Wickham (1989)
Methodology for dietary studies in epidemiological surveys. II. Strengths and weaknesses of existing methods.
C. Young (1960)
Weak associations in nutritional epidemiology: the importance of replication of observations on individuals.
Wija A. van Staveren (1988)
Food frequency questionnaires as a research instrument
L. Sampson (1985)
A comparison of dietary study methods. II. Dietary history vs. seven-day record vs. 24-hr. recall.
C. Young (1952)
Physical activity and calcium intake in fracture of the proximal femur in Hong Kong.
E. Lau (1988)
Random repeat 24-hour dietary recalls.
M. Balogh (1971)
Nutrient misclassification: bias in the odds ratio and loss of power in the Mantel test for trend.
J. Freudenheim (1989)
Physical activity and calcium intake in fracture of the proximal femur in Britain
C Cooper (1988)
This paper is referenced by
Concepts and Controversies in Evaluating Vitamin K Status in Population-Based Studies
M. Kyla Shea (2016)
Dietary intake and dinner timing among shift workers in Japan
Mieko Nakamura (2018)
NOSE: A Novel Odor Sensing Engine for Ambient Monitoring of the Frying Cooking Method in Kitchen Environments
Pooya Khaloo (2019)
Calcium and vitamin D intake influence bone mass, but not short-term fracture risk, in Caucasian postmenopausal women from the National Osteoporosis Risk Assessment (NORA) study
J. Nieves (2007)
Improvement of the nutritional management of glycogen storage disease type I
Kakali Bhattacharya (2010)
Abnormal Cholesterol is Associated with Prefrontal White Matter Abnormalities among Obese Adults: A Diffusion Tensor Imaging Study
Jonathan Cohen (2011)
A biocultural analysis of ethnic variation in colorectal cancer incidence and mortality in the United States between 1988 and 2006
Cari Lewis (2014)
Assessment of the nutrition status of patients with Huntington's disease.
A. Trejo (2004)
Anthropometric Status and Nutritional Intake in Children (6–9 Years) in Valencia (Spain): The ANIVA Study
María Morales-Suárez-Varela (2015)
Relationship Between Dietary Choices Made during a Low-Calorie, Low-fat Diet and Changes in Caloric Intake, Caloric Intake from Fat, and Weight Loss
Vaishali Deepak Keshani (2014)
Validity and test-retest reliability of a short dietary questionnaire to assess intake of saturated fat and free sugars: a preliminary study.
Heather M Francis (2013)
Health related lifestyle habits of Swedish schoolchildren : Studies on knowledge, conception and behaviour
Li Lindberg (2006)
Validation of an antioxidant nutrient questionnaire in whites and African Americans.
Jessie A. Satia (2009)
Diet and Nutrition in the Etiology and Prevention of Cancer
Steven K. Clinton (2017)
Mechanism of weight loss in the morbidly obese following ileogastrostomy and validation of reported energy intake in normal-weight and morbidly obese subjects
Wanfang Su (1995)
Assessment of a narrative approach to the diet history.
L. Tapsell (1999)
Lifetime dietary change and its relation to increase in weight in Spanish women
P. Montero (2000)
Community-specific modifications are essential for objective assessment of maternal dietary intake--Pune Maternal Nutrition Study.
S. Rao (2009)
Lower Resting Metabolic Rate and Basal Body Temperature of Fibromyalgia Patients Compared to Matched Healthy Controls
John C. Lowe (2006)
The Effect of Salvia Hispanica L. Seeds on Weight Loss in Overweight and Obese Individuals with Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus
Christy Brissette (2013)
Changing patterns of life-style and nutrition of men In Japan and Australia
Kayo Cruickshank (2014)
Title Reduced risk of Alzheimer ' s disease with antioxidant vitamin intake : The Baltimore Longitudinal Study of Aging Permalink
Claudia H. Kawasa (2005)
Does Nutritional Intake Differ Between Children with Autism Spectrum Disorders and Children with Typical Development?
Alison C Herndon (2009)
Heritability of dietary food intake patterns
L. V. D. van den Berg (2012)
Does nutritionist review of a self-administered food frequency questionnaire improve data quality?
Bette J. Caan (1999)
Portion Sizes from 24-Hour Dietary Recalls Differed by Sex among Those Who Selected the Same Portion Size Category on a Food Frequency Questionnaire.
Minji Kang (2018)
Epidemiologic insights on the role of fibroblast growth factor 23 in cardiovascular disease
Julia J Scialla (2015)
Assessment of dietary isoflavone intake among middle-aged Chinese men.
Sang-Ah Lee (2007)
Nutritional Status of Children with Autism Spectrum Disorders (ASDs): A Case-Control Study
Itziar Zazpe-Garcõ (2015)
Development and relative validity of semi-quantitative food frequency questionnaire for Korean adults
Sohye Kim (2018)
People with a body mass index ⩾30 under-report their dietary intake: A systematic review
Helena Wehling (2017)
Nutrition and Biotechnology in Heart Disease and Cancer
J. B. Longenecker (1995)See more