Online citations, reference lists, and bibliographies.
Please confirm you are human
(Sign Up for free to never see this)
← Back to Search

A Multi‐criteria Based Review Of Models That Predict Environmental Impacts Of Land Use‐change For Perennial Energy Crops On Water, Carbon And Nitrogen Cycling

A. Thomas, A. Bond, K. Hiscock
Published 2013 · Environmental Science

Save to my Library
Download PDF
Analyze on Scholarcy
Reduction in energy sector greenhouse gas GHG emissions is a key aim of European Commission plans to expand cultivation of bioenergy crops. Since agriculture makes up 10–12% of anthropogenic GHG emissions, impacts of land‐use change must be considered, which requires detailed understanding of specific changes to agroecosystems. The greenhouse gas (GHG) balance of perennials may differ significantly from the previous ecosystem. Net change in GHG emissions with land‐use change for bioenergy may exceed avoided fossil fuel emissions, meaning that actual GHG mitigation benefits are variable. Carbon (C) and nitrogen (N) cycling are complex interlinked systems, and a change in land management may affect both differently at different sites, depending on other variables. Change in evapotranspiration with land‐use change may also have significant environmental or water resource impacts at some locations. This article derives a multi‐criteria based decision analysis approach to objectively identify the most appropriate assessment method of the environmental impacts of land‐use change for perennial energy crops. Based on a literature review and conceptual model in support of this approach, the potential impacts of land‐use change for perennial energy crops on GHG emissions and evapotranspiration were identified, as well as likely controlling variables. These findings were used to structure the decision problem and to outline model requirements. A process‐based model representing the complete agroecosystem was identified as the best predictive tool, where adequate data are available. Nineteen models were assessed according to suitability criteria, to identify current model capability, based on the conceptual model, and explicit representation of processes at appropriate resolution. FASSET, ECOSSE, ANIMO, DNDC, DayCent, Expert‐N, Ecosys, WNMM and CERES‐NOE were identified as appropriate models, with factors such as crop, location and data availability dictating the final decision for a given project. A database to inform such decisions is included.
This paper references
Promotion of the use of energy from renewable sources
R. Newman (2014)
Evaluating annual nitrous oxide fluxes at the ecosystem scale
P. Groffman (2000)
Long-term impacts of high-input annual cropping and unfertilized perennial grass production on soil properties and belowground food webs in Kansas, USA
S. Culman (2010)
Estimating soil hydraulic properties of Fengqiu County soils in the North China Plain using pedo-transfer functions
Yong Li (2007)
Nitrogen Cycling in an Irrigated Wheat System in Sonora, Mexico: Measurements and Modeling
L. Christensen (2006)
Comparison of three modelling approaches for simulating denitrification and nitrous oxide emissions from loamtextured arable soils
Y Li (2005)
Climate change 2007: the Physical Science Basis. Contribution of Working Group I to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Summary for Policymakers.
S. C. Solomon (2007)
Model estimates of nitrous oxide emissions from agricultural lands in the United States
Changsheng Li (1996)
Miscanthus: A promising biomass crop, In: Advances in Botanical Research (ed
EA Heaton (2010)
Carbon mitigation by the energy crop, Miscanthus
John Clifton-Brown (2007)
Simulation of Effects of Soils, Climate and Management on N2O Emission from Grasslands
D. Chatskikh (2005)
Validation of DNDC
D Beheydt (2007)
Document SEC 85 V2; accompanying the package of implementation measures for the EU's objectives on climate change and renewable energy for 2020
Review and literature evaluation of nutrient quantification tools EUROHARP report 1, NIVA report
OF Schoumans (2003)
STICS : a generic model for the simulation of crops and their water and nitrogen balances. I. Theory, and parameterization applied to wheat and corn
N. Brisson (1998)
Carbon sequestration in croplands: The potential in Europe and the global context
P. Smith (2004)
Modelling variability in N2O emissions from fertilized agricultural fields
R. Grant (2003)
Modeling denitrification
EW Boyer (2006)
Nitrogen availability and soil N2O emissions following conversion of forests to coffee in southern Sumatra
L. Verchot (2006)
Greenhouse gas fluxes in varying soils types under conventional and no-tillage practices.
K. Regina (2010)
Does a large number of parameters enhance model performance? Comparative assessment of common catchment model structures on 429 catchments
C. Perrin (2001)
Estimating annual N2O emissions from agricultural soils in temperate climates
C. Roelandt (2005)
Assessing the Environmental Risks and Opportunities of Bioenergy Cropping
L. Firbank (2012)
A model of nitrous oxide evolution from soil driven by rainfall events: 1. Model structure and sensitivity
C. Li (1992)
Seasonal variations of nitrous oxide emission in relation to nitrogen fertilization and energy crop types in sandy soil.
Y. Kavdır (2008)
Prediction of nitrogen and phosphorus leaching to groundwater and surface waters; process descriptions of the animo4.0 model
P. Groenendijk (2005)
A semi-distributed ntegrated itrogen model for multiple source assessment in tchments (INCA): Part I — model structure and process equations
P. Whitehead (1998)
Carbon sequestration under Miscanthus: a study of 13C distribution in soil aggregates
M. Dondini (2009)
Using DAYCENT to quantify on-farm GHG emissions and N dynamics of land use conversion to N-managed switchgrass in the Southern U.S.
J. Chamberlain (2011)
A process-oriented model
C Li (2000)
IPCC guidelines for national greenhouse gas inventories, In: Prepared by the National Greenhouse Gas Inventories Programme
HS Eggleston (2006)
Field N2O, CO2 and CH4 fluxes in relation to tillage, compaction and soil quality in Scotland
B. Ball (1999)
InfoCrop: a dynamic simulation
P Aggarwal (2006)
European biomass resource potential and costs
M. D. Wit (2010)
Nitrate leaching losses under Miscanthus grass planted on a silty clay loam soil
D. Christian (2006)
Development and application of a mechanistic model to estimate emission of nitrous oxide from UK agriculture
L. Browna (2002)
An overview of the crop model STICS
N. Brisson (2003)
Simulating soil N2O emissions and heterotrophic CO2 respiration in arable systems using FASSET and MoBiLE-DNDC
N. Chirinda (2010)
Carbon Sequestration in Arable Soils is Likely to Increase Nitrous Oxide Emissions, Offsetting Reductions in Climate Radiative Forcing
Changsheng Li (2005)
Validation of DNDC for 22 long-term N2O field emission measurements
D. Beheydt (2007)
Mechanistic model for nitrous oxide emission via nitrification and denitrification
C. Müller (1997)
Evaluation of diffuse pollution model applications in EUROHARP catchments with limited data.
M. Silgram (2009)
Energy production from biomass (Part 1): Overview of biomass.
P. McKendry (2002)
Evaluation of the N2O emissions from N in plant residues as affected by environmental and management factors
Rafael S. A. Novoa (2006)
The use of artificial neural networks (ANNs) to simulate
M Ryan (2004)
Soil physics meets soil biology: Towards better mechanistic prediction of greenhouse gas emissions from soil
S. Blagodatsky (2012)
Comparing annual and perennial energy cropping systems with different management intensities
C. Boehmel (2008)
Modeling biogeochemical impacts of bioenergy buffers with perennial grasses for a row‐crop field in Illinois
G. Gopalakrishnan (2012)
Biofuels and other approaches for decreasing fossil fuel emissions from agriculture
D. Powlson (2005)
A hydrological model dedicated to topography-based simulation of nitrogen transfer and transformation: rationale and application to the geomorphology-denitrification relationship
V. Beaujouan (2002)
Simulation of soil nitrogen, nitrous oxide emissions and mitigation scenarios at 3 European cropland sites using the ECOSSE model
M. Bell (2011)
Modeling the Effects of Fertilizer Application Rate on Nitrous Oxide Emissions
R. Grant (2006)
Seasonal dynamics of nutrient accumulation and partitioning in the perennial C4-grasses Miscanthus × giganteus and Spartina cynosuroides
C. V. Beale (1997)
Comparative Biogeochemical Cycles of Bioenergy Crops Reveal Nitrogen-Fixation and Low Greenhouse Gas Emissions in a Miscanthus × giganteus Agro-Ecosystem
S. Davis (2009)
A spatially referenced water and nitrogen management model (WNMM) for (irrigated) intensive cropping systems in the North China Plain
Y. Li (2007)
Carbon budget and methane and nitrous oxide emissions over the growing season in a Miscanthus sinensis grassland in Tomakomai, Hokkaido, Japan
Yo Toma (2011)
Modelling soil
C Bessou (2010)
Land use change and biogeochemical controls of nitrogen oxide emissions from soils in eastern Amazonia
L. Verchot (1999)
E. Davidson (1998)
Assessing the ecological and economic sustainability of energy crops.
M. Hanegraaf (1998)
DAYCENT and its land surface submodel: description and testing
W. Parton (1998)
Greenhouse gas mitigation in agriculture
P. Smith (2007)
Long-term impacts of high-input annual cropping and unfertilized perennial grass production on soil properties and belowground food webs in Kansas
SW Culman (2010)
Yield and spatial
MJ Aylott (2008)
Initial greenhouse gas emissions and nitrogen leaching losses associated with converting pastureland to short-rotation woody bioenergy crops in northern Michigan, USA
P. Nikièma (2012)
Predicting greenhouse gas emission from peat soils depending on water management with the SWAP – ANIMO model , In : 13 th International Peat Congress After Wise Use - The Future of Peatlands
van den Akker Alterra JJH (2008)
Model identification for hydrological forecasting under uncertainty
Thorsten Wagener (2005)
Where did all the nitrogen go? Fate of nitrogen inputs to large watersheds in the northeastern U.S.A.
N. van Breemen (2002)
General model for N2O and N2 gas emissions from soils due to dentrification
S. D. Grosso (2000)
Estimating changes in Scottish soil carbon stocks using ECOSSE. I. Model description and uncertainties
J. Smith (2010)
Is UK biofuel supply from Miscanthus water-limited?
G. M. Richter (2008)
15N isotopic crop residue cycling studies and modeling suggest that IPCC methodologies to assess residue contributions to N2O-N emissions should be reevaluated
J. Delgado (2009)
Dynamics of energy, water, carbon and nitrogen in agricultural ecosystems: simulation and experimental validation
R. Grant (1995)
Some ecological and socio-economic considerations for biomass energy crop production☆
L. Paine (1996)
Seasonal estimates of riparian evapotranspiration using remote and in situ measurements.
D. Goodrich (2000)
Testing DayCent and DNDC model simulations of N2O fluxes and assessing the impacts of climate change on the gas flux and biomass production from a humid pasture
M. Abdalla (2010)
Comparative biogeochemical cycles of bioenergy crops reveal nitrogen-fixation and low greenhouse gas emissions in a miscanthus 9 giganteus
SC Davis (2010)
The Physical Science Basis : Contribution of Working Group I to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change
S. E. Solomon (2007)
Description of nine nutrient loss models: capabilities and suitability based on their characteristics.
O. Schoumans (2009)
ForCent model development and testing using the Enriched Background Isotope Study experiment
W. Parton (2010)
Expert-N A tool for simulating nitrogen and carbon dynamics in the soil-plant-atmosphere system
R. Stenger (1999)
Simulation of Effects of Soils
D Chatskikh (2005)
Edgar G. Hertwich (2000)
Fuzzy Multiple Attribute Decision Making - Methods and Applications
S. Chen (1992)
Land Clearing and the Biofuel Carbon Debt
Joseph E Fargione (2008)
Modelling the effects of fertilizer application rate on nitrous oxide emissions
RF Grant (2006)
Multiple Attribute Decision Making: Methods and Applications - A State-of-the-Art Survey
C. Hwang (1981)
Energy crops: current status and future prospects
R. Sims (2006)
Biofuels: environmental consequences and interactions with changing land use; biofuels and water
C de Fraiture (2008)
The role of climate on inter-annual variation in stream nitrate fluxes and concentrations.
C. Gascuel-Odoux (2010)
Nitrous Oxide Emissions Respond Differently to No-Till in a Loam and a Heavy Clay Soil
P. Rochette (2008)
Miscanthus: A Promising Biomass Crop
E. Heaton (2010)
Biofuels, land use change, and greenhouse gas emissions: some unexplored variables.
Hyungtae Kim (2009)
Comparison of N2O emissions from soils at three temperate agricultural sites: simulations of year-round measurements by four models
S. Frolking (2004)
Modelling N2O emissions from agroecosystems: the WNMM experience.
Li Yong (2010)
The impacts of Miscanthus×giganteus production on the Midwest US hydrologic cycle
A. VanLoocke (2010)
Addressing land use change and uncertainty in the life-cycle assessment of wheat-based bioethanol.
J. Malça (2012)
Tentative guidelines to help choosing an appropriate MCDA method
A. Guitouni (1998)
A process-oriented model of N2O and NO emissions from forest soils: 1. Model development
C. Li (2000)
Energy- and greenhouse gas-based LCA of biofuel and bioenergy systems: Key issues, ranges and recommendations
F. Cherubini (2009)
The economical and environmental performance of miscanthus and switchgrass production and supply chains in a European setting
E. Smeets (2009)
Simulation of nitrogen leaching in sandy soils in The Netherlands with the ANIMO model and the integrated modelling system STONE
J. Wolf (2005)
Nloss : A mechanistic model of denitrified N2O and N2 evolution from soil
W. Riley (2000)
Testing DAYCENT model simulations of corn yields and nitrous oxide emissions in irrigated tillage systems in Colorado.
S. Del grosso (2008)
Representation of landscape hydrological connectivity using a topographically driven surface flow index
S. Lane (2009)
Modelling soil compaction impacts on nitrous oxide emissions in arable fields
C. Bessou (2010)
A novel, integrated approach to assessing social, economic and environmental implications of changing rural land-use: A case study of perennial biomass crops
A. Haughton (2009)
DAYCENT model analysis of past and contemporary soil N2O and net greenhouse gas flux for major crops in the USA.
S. D. Grosso (2005)
Hydrologic controls on soil carbon and nitrogen cycles. I. Modeling scheme
A. Porporato (2003)
Agricultural soil greenhouse gas emissions: a review of national inventory methods.
E. Lokupitiya (2006)
Landscape fate of nitrate fluxes and emissions in Central Europe: A critical review of concepts, data, and models for transport and retention
D. Haag (2001)
Modeling denitrification in terrestrial and aquatic ecosystems at regional scales.
E. Boyer (2006)
Process modeling of controls on nitrogen trace gas emissions from soils worldwide
C. Potter (1996)
Renewable Energy from Willow Biomass Crops: Life Cycle Energy, Environmental and Economic Performance
G. Keoleian (2005)
Which cropland greenhouse gas mitigation options give the greatest benefits in different world regions? Climate and soil‐specific predictions from integrated empirical models
J. Hillier (2012)
Yield and spatial supply of bioenergy poplar and willow short-rotation coppice in the UK.
Matthew J Aylott (2008)
Soil Organic Carbon Changes in the Cultivation of Energy Crops: Implications for GHG Balances and Soil Quality for Use in LCA
M. Brandão (2011)
GHG balances of bioenergy systems – Overview of key steps in the production chain and methodological concerns
F. Cherubini (2010)
Review of the IPCC methodology for estimating nitrous oxide emissions associated with agricultural leaching and runoff
C. Nevison (2000)
Agricultural soil greenhouse gas emissions
E Lokupitiya (2006)
Simulation of Nitrous Oxide Emissions from Wheat-cropped Soils using CERES
B. Gabrielle (2005)
Identifying potential environmental impacts of large-scale deployment of dedicated bioenergy crops in the UK
R. Rowe (2009)
Hydrologic controls on soil carbon and nitrogen cycles. II. A case study
Paolo D'Odorico (2003)
InfoCrop: A dynamic simulation model for the assessment of crop yields, losses due to pests, and environmental impact of agro-ecosystems in tropical environments. I. Model description
P. Aggarwal (2006)
Comparison of three modeling approaches for simulating denitrification and nitrous oxide emissions from loam‐textured arable soils
Y. Li (2005)
Nitrous oxide production in riparian zones and its importance to national emission inventories
P. Groffman (2000)
Fertiliser induced nitrous oxide emissions during energy crop cultivation on loamy sand soils
H. J. Hellebrand (2008)
'Agriculture', in Climate change 2007: mitigation
P. Smith (2007)
ANIMO 4.0; user's guide of the ANIMO 4.0 nutrient leaching model
L. Renaud (2005)
The Soil and Water Assessment Tool: Historical Development, Applications, and Future Research Directions
P. Gassman (2007)
Multiple Attribute Decision Making - Methods and Application: A State of the Art Survey
Hwang C-L (1981)
The hydrological impacts of energy crop production in the UK. Final report
J. Finch (2004)
Land Use Implications of Increased Biomass Production Identified by GIS-Based Suitability and Yield Mapping for Miscanthus in England
A. Lovett (2008)
A comparison of the performance of nine soil organic matter models using datasets from seven long-term experiments
P. Smith (1997)
Long‐term development of phosphorus and nitrogen loads through the subsurface and surface water systems of drainage basins
A. Darracq (2008)
Use of U.S. Croplands for Biofuels Increases Greenhouse Gases Through Emissions from Land-Use Change
T. Searchinger (2008)
Using the ecosys mathematical model to simulate temporal variability of nitrous oxide emissions from a fertilized agricultural soil
K. Metivier (2009)
The FullCAM Carbon Accounting Model: Development, Calibration, and Implementation. Carbon Accounting and Emissions Trading Related to Bioenergy, Wood Products, and Carbon Sequestration
GP Richards (2001)
The use of artificial neural networks (ANNs) to simulate N2O emissions from a temperate grassland ecosystem
M. Ryan (2004)
Comparing annual and perennial
C Boehmel (2008)
User's Guide for the DNDC Model. Version 9.3. Institute for the Study of Earth, Oceans and Space
Dndc User Guide (2009)
N2O emissions from agricultural lands: a synthesis of simulation approaches
Deli Chen (2008)

This paper is referenced by
SPLiCE Phase 1 Significant evidence gaps on the environmental, social and economic impacts of energy system components. Output 1 from SPLICE Phase 1
P. Agnolucci (2015)
Advances in Agronomy
Liwang Maa (2019)
Bioenergy crop productivity and potential climate change mitigation from marginal lands in the United States: An ecosystem modeling perspective
Zhangcai Qin (2015)
Multi-scale relationship between land use/land cover types and water quality in different pollution source areas in Fuxian Lake Basin
S. Li (2019)
Carbon Sequestration by Perennial Energy Crops: Is the Jury Still Out?
F. Agostini (2014)
Biofuel Crops and Soil Quality and Erosion
D. Chatskikh (2013)
Using existing landscape data to assess the ecological potential of Miscanthus cultivation in a marginal landscape
Sarah Harvolk (2014)
Meeting Emissions Reduction Targets: A Probabilistic Lifecycle Assessment of the Production of Alternative Jet Fuels
A. P. Payan (2014)
Bioethanol from poplar clone Imola: an environmentally viable alternative to fossil fuel?
Miao Guo (2015)
Abundance, Activity and Community Structure of Nitrifier and Denitrifier Communities in Agro- Ecosystems
K. Thompson (2016)
Allocating shadow prices in a multiobjective chance constrained model for biodiesel blending
C. Caldeira (2014)
Ecosystem model parameterization and adaptation for sustainable cellulosic biofuel landscape design
John L. Field (2016)
Impacts of surface-applied residues on N-cycling soil microbial communities in miscanthus and switchgrass cropping systems
K. A. Thompson (2018)
Biofuel, land and water: maize, switchgrass or Miscanthus?
Q. Zhuang (2013)
Land-use change and greenhouse gas emissions from corn and cellulosic ethanol
J. Dunn (2013)
Development and preliminary evaluation of an integrated field scale model for perennial bioenergy grass ecosystems in lowland areas
S. Tian (2016)
Influence of land use on river water quality in the Ganjiang basin
王. W. Peng (2015)
Evaluating potential policies for the UK perennial energy crop market to achieve carbon abatement and deliver a source of low carbon electricity
P. Alexander (2015)
Coupling epidemiological and tree growth models to control fungal diseases spread in fruit orchards
D. Bevacqua (2019)
Quantifying Crop Yield, Bioenergy Production And Greenhouse Gas Emissions From Cropland And Marginal Land Using A Model-Data Fusion Approach
Zhangcai Qin (2013)
Modélisation et évaluation environnementale des filières de cogénération par combustion et gazéification du bois
Jessica François (2014)
Can Carbon in Bioenergy Crops Mitigate Global Climate Change
A. Jaradat (2013)
Application of grazing land models in ecosystem management: Current status and next frontiers
L. Ma (2019)
Comprendre les changements d'utilisation des terres en France pour mieux estimer leurs impacts sur les émissions de gaz à effet de serre : De l'observation à la modélisation
Colas Robert (2016)
Importance of biophysical effects on climate warming mitigation potential of biofuel crops over the conterminous United States
P. Zhu (2017)
Estimating greenhouse gases emissions from horticultural peat soils using a DNDC modelling approach.
H. Taft (2019)
Semantic Scholar Logo Some data provided by SemanticScholar