← Back to Search
Transcriptional Profiling Of Tissue Plasticity: Role Of Shifts In Gene Expression And Technical Limitations.
M. Flück, C. Däpp, Silvia Schmutz, E. Wit, H. Hoppeler
Published 2005 · Medicine, Biology
Save to my Library
Download PDFAnalyze on Scholarcy
Reprogramming of gene expression has been recognized as a main instructive modality for the adjustments of tissues to various kinds of stress. The recent application of gene expression profiling has provided a powerful tool to elucidate the molecular pathways underlying such tissue remodeling. However, the biological interpretations of expression profiling results critically depend on normalization of transcript signals to mRNA standards before statistical evaluation. A hypothesis is proposed whereby the "fluctuating nature" of gene expression represents an inherent limitation of the test system used to quantify RNA levels. Misinterpretation of gene expression data occurs when RNA quantities are normalized to a subset of mRNAs that are subject to strong regulation. The contention of contradictory biological outcomes using different RNA-normalization schemes is demonstrated in two models of skeletal muscle plasticity with data from custom-designed microarrays and biochemical and ultrastructural evidence for correspondingly altered RNA content and nucleolar activity. The prevalence of these biological constraints is underlined by a literature survey in different models of tissue plasticity with emphasis on the unique malleability of skeletal muscle. Finally, recommendations on the optimal experimental layout are given to control biological and technical variability in microarray and RT-PCR studies. It is proposed to approach normalization of transcript signals by measuring total RNA and DNA content per sample weight and by correcting for concurrently estimated endogenous standards such as major ribosomal RNAs and spiked RNA and DNA species. This allows for later conversion to diverse tissue-relevant references and should improve the physiological interpretations of phenotypic plasticity.
This paper references
The effect of sample degradation and RNA stabilization on classical swine fever virus RT-PCR and ELISA methods.
S. Blacksell (2004)
Housekeeping gene variability in normal and cancerous colorectal, pancreatic, esophageal, gastric and hepatic tissues.
C. Rubie (2005)
Nascent muscle fiber appearance in overloaded chicken slow-tonic muscle.
J. M. Kennedy (1988)
Statistical significance analysis of longitudinal gene expression data
X. Guo (2003)
Variance stabilization applied to microarray data calibration and to the quantification of differential expression
W. Huber (2002)
Morphometric analyses on the muscles of exercise trained and untrained dogs.
M. Čabríc (1983)
Characteristics of skeletal muscle tissue ribosomes
Khoroshkov IuA (1976)
Accurate normalization of real-time quantitative RT-PCR data by geometric averaging of multiple internal control genes
J. Vandesompele (2001)
The genetics of variation in gene expression
V. Cheung (2002)
Stereological methods in cell biology: where are we--where are we going?
E. Weibel (1981)
Research in the exercise sciences: where do we go from here?
K. Baldwin (2000)
Cellular adaptation of the trapezius muscle in strength-trained athletes
F. Kadi (1999)
Stretch-induced myogenin, MyoD, and MRF4 expression and acute hypertrophy in quail slow-tonic muscle are not dependent upon satellite cell proliferation
D. Lowe (1999)
Differential expression profiling of head and neck squamous carcinoma: significance in their phenotypic and biological classification
A. El-Naggar (2002)
Noise in eukaryotic gene expression
William J. Blake (2003)
Metaplastic and mitotic activity of the ischemic (endocrine) kidney in experimental renal hypertension.
M. Cantin (1979)
Assessing natural variations in gene expression in humans by comparing with monozygotic twins using microarrays.
Anu Sharma (2005)
The effect of hypokinesia and hypodynamia on protein turnover and the growth of four skeletal muscles of the rat
D. Goldspink (2004)
Statistical methods for assessing agreement between two methods of clinical measurement
J. M. Bland (1986)
Pre-steady-state kinetic characterization of RNA-primed initiation of transcription by HIV-1 reverse transcriptase and analysis of the transition to a processive DNA-primed polymerization mode.
S. Thrall (1998)
RNA Content Differs in Slow and Fast Muscle Fibers: Implications for Interpretation of Changes in Muscle Gene Expression
P. E. Habets (1999)
Acridine orange flow cytometric analysis of renal cell carcinoma. Clinicopathologic implications of RNA content.
A. El-Naggar (1990)
Statistics for microarrays
E. Wit (2004)
Screening differentially expressed cDNA clones obtained by differential display using amplified RNA.
G. M. Poirier (1997)
Exercise-induced satellite cell activation in growing and mature skeletal muscle.
K. C. Darr (1987)
Changes in the size and synthetic activity of nuclear populations in chronically stimulated rabbit skeletal muscle.
R. Joplin (1987)
Isovolumic loading prevents atrophy of the heterotopically transplanted rat heart.
I. Klein (1991)
The role of apoptosis during intestinal adaptation after small bowel resection.
C. Welters (2000)
Effects of creatine supplementation on housekeeping genes in human skeletal muscle using real-time RT-PCR.
R. Murphy (2003)
Correcting log ratios for signal saturation in cDNA microarrays
L. Dodd (2004)
[Characteristics of skeletal muscle tissue ribosomes].
Iu A Khoroshkov (1976)
Nonparametric methods for identifying differentially expressed genes in microarray data
O. Troyanskaya (2002)
Lung growth in response to unilateral pneumonectomy in rapidly growing rats.
Watkins Ca (1985)
The number of nuclei in adult rat muscles with special reference to satellite cells
H. Schmalbruch (1977)
The limit fold change model: A practical approach for selecting differentially expressed genes from microarray data
D. M. Mutch (2002)
Identification from public data of molecular markers of adenocarcinoma characteristic of the site of origin.
J. L. Dennis (2002)
Normalization of gene expression measurements in tumor tissues: comparison of 13 endogenous control genes
J. B. Kok (2005)
Evaluation of gene expression measurements from commercial microarray platforms.
P. K. Tan (2003)
Significance analysis of microarrays applied to the ionizing radiation response
V. G. Tusher (2001)
Role of satellite cells in altering myosin expression during avian skeletal muscle hypertrophy
K. McCormick (1994)
Unexpected solute aggregation in water on dilution.
S. Samal (2001)
Effect of radiation on satellite cell activity and protein expression in overloaded mammalian skeletal muscle
J. Phelan (1997)
Validation of endogenous controls for gene expression analysis in microdissected human renal biopsies.
H. Schmid (2003)
Eating, exercise, and "thrifty" genotypes: connecting the dots toward an evolutionary understanding of modern chronic diseases.
M. Chakravarthy (2004)
Tenascin-C expression correlates with macrophage invasion in Duchenne muscular dystrophy and in myositis
D. Gullberg (1997)
Training affects myosin heavy chain phenotype in the trapezius muscle of women
F. Kadi (1999)
malizing DNA microarray data
M Bilban (2002)
DNA, RNA and protein contents in human uterine, breast and rectal cancer
M Bandopadhyay (2000)
Molecular and cellular adaptation of muscle in response to exercise: perspectives of various models.
F. Booth (1991)
Global analysis of gene expression patterns during disuse atrophy in rat skeletal muscle
E. Stevenson (2003)
Expression profiling identifies dysregulation of myosin heavy chains IIb and IIx during limb immobilization in the soleus muscles of old rats
J. S. Pattison (2003)
AUTORADIOGRAPHIC LOCALIZATION OF NEW RNA SYNTHESIS IN HYPERTROPHYING SKELETAL MUSCLE
C. Jablecki (1973)
A stochastic PCR approach for RNA quantification in multiple samples.
A. Puntschart (1999)
Morphological and biochemical evidence of muscle hyperplasia following weight-lifting exercise in rats.
T. Tamaki (1997)
rRNA-like sequences occur in diverse primary transcripts: implications for the control of gene expression.
V. Mauro (1997)
Reloading of atrophied rat soleus muscle induces tenascin-C expression around damaged muscle fibers.
M. Flück (2003)
A comparison of oligonucleotide and cDNA-based microarray systems.
N. Mah (2004)
Control points in eucaryotic ribosome biogenesis.
D. Larson (1991)
Effects of mRNA amplification on gene expression ratios in cDNA experiments estimated by analysis of variance
Vigdis Nygaard (2002)
High-accuracy amplification of nanogram total RNA amounts for gene profiling.
M. Kenzelmann (2004)
Ribosomal Highly Basic 23-kDa Protein as a Reliable Standard for Gene Expression Analysis
R. Jesenofsky (2002)
Parameters for evaluation of viability assays: accuracy, precision, specificity, sensitivity, and standardization.
H. Bank (1989)
Fundamentals of cDNA microarray data analysis.
Y. F. Leung (2003)
Prolonged unloading of rat soleus muscle causes distinct adaptations of the gene profile
M. Wittwer (2002)
Reproducibility of alternative probe synthesis approaches for gene expression profiling with arrays.
S. Vernon (2000)
Putrescine, DNA, RNA and protein contents in human uterine, breast and rectal cancer.
M. Bandopadhyay (2000)
Model-based estimation of transcript concentrations from spotted microarray data
A. Frigessi (2004)
The training state determines the acute muscular transcriptome response to endurance exercise
S Schmutz (2005)
Controlling the false discovery rate in behavior genetics research
Y. Benjamini (2001)
Centralization: a new method for the normalization of gene expression data
A. Zien (2001)
Microarrays: how many do you need?
A. Zien (2002)
Satellite cell activation in the stretch-enlarged anterior latissimus dorsi muscle of the adult quail.
P. Winchester (1991)
The elevated mRNA content as a potential indicator of precancerous states of the gallbladder mucosa in patients with pancreaticobiliary maljunction.
Y. Miura (1998)
Hypertrophy and hyperplasia of adult chicken anterior latissimus dorsi muscles following stretch with and without denervation.
O. Sola (1973)
P. Trayhurn (1996)
Gene expression databases and data mining.
P. Anderle (2003)
High throughput gene expression profiling: a molecular approach to integrative physiology
M. Liang (2004)
Quantitation of mitochondrial DNA, RNA, and protein in starved and starved‐refed rat liver
D. Stocco (1977)
Variability of fiber type distributions within human muscles.
G. Elder (1982)
The Concept of the Gene: Short History and Present Status
P. Portin (1993)
Distinguishing unloading. Versus reloading‐induced changes in rat soleus muscle
B. Krippendorf (1993)
Muscle fiber formation and fiber hypertrophy during the onset of stretch-overload.
S. Alway (1990)
Characteristics of ribosomes of skeletal muscle tissue
Yu. A. Khoroshkov (2004)
The expression of androgen receptors in human neck and limb muscles: effects of training and self-administration of androgenic-anabolic steroids
F. Kadi (2000)
GAPDH as a housekeeping gene: analysis of GAPDH mRNA expression in a panel of 72 human tissues.
R. D. Barber (2005)
Single muscle fiber gene expression in human skeletal muscle: validation of internal control with exercise.
B. Jemiolo (2004)
Heterotopic cardiac transplantation decreases the capacity for rat myocardial protein synthesis.
I. Klein (1991)
Elucidating the molecular mechanism of cardiac remodeling using a comparative genomic approach.
M. Mirotsou (2003)
The elusive field of systems biology.
A. Cowley (2004)
Regulatory gene expression in skeletal muscle of highly endurance-trained humans.
M. Wittwer (2004)
Interaction of thyroid state and denervation on skeletal myosin heavy chain expression
F. Haddad (1997)
Muscle growth in response to mechanical stimuli.
D. Goldspink (1995)
Multiple comparisons: philosophies and illustrations.
D. Curran‐Everett (2000)
Endurance training modulates the muscular transcriptome response to acute exercise
Silvia Schmutz (2005)
Injury-induced inhibition of small intestinal protein and nucleic acid synthesis.
E. Carter (1990)
Control of Stochasticity in Eukaryotic Gene Expression
J. Raser (2004)
Options available—from start to finish—for obtaining data from DNA microarrays II
A. Holloway (2002)
Anomalous colossal magnetoresistance effect in the Zn-doped Fe1−xZnxCr2S4 polycrystals with the spinel structure
S. X. Wang (2001)
Le "tissue microarrays" : nouvel outil de transfert et de contrôle de qualité en cancérologie
J. Jacquemier (2003)
Stochastic mechanisms in gene expression.
H. McAdams (1997)
Mechanisms for intracellular distribution of mRNA: in situ hybridization studies in muscle.
B. Russell (1992)
Effect of starvation and refeeding on the blood and liver of domesticated rabbits.
A. Shakoori (1982)
Real-time RT-PCR analysis of housekeeping genes in human skeletal muscle following acute exercise.
D. J. Mahoney (2004)
[Tissue microarrays a powerful tool in transfer and quality control in oncology].
J. Jacquemier (2003)
Normalization of Real-Time Quantitative Reverse Transcription-PCR Data: A Model-Based Variance Estimation Approach to Identify Genes Suited for Normalization, Applied to Bladder and Colon Cancer Data Sets
C. L. Andersen (2004)
Monitoring global messenger RNA changes in externally controlled microarray experiments
J. van de Peppel (2003)
Exercise‐Induced Expression of Vascular Endothelial Growth Factor mRNA in Rat Skeletal Muscle is Dependent on Fibre Type
Olivier J G Birot (2003)
Microarray analysis of normal and dystrophic skeletal muscle
J. N. Haslett (2002)
Model-based methods for identifying periodically expressed genes based on time course microarray gene expression data
Yihui Luan (2004)
The use and analysis of microarray data
A. Butte (2002)
Fractional composition and metabolism of proteins, and levels of polynucleotides, in canine heart in experimental myocardial infarction.
Fetisova Tv (1975)
G. Casella (1990)
Molecular responses of human muscle to eccentric exercise.
Yi-Wen Chen (2003)
Post-analysis follow-up and validation of microarray experiments
R. Chuaqui (2002)
Sources of variability and effect of experimental approach on expression profiling data interpretation
M. Bakay (2001)
Transcription occurs in pulses in muscle fibers.
S. Newlands (1998)
Housekeeping genes as internal standards: use and limits.
O. Thellin (1999)
Apoptosis: a mechanism contributing to remodeling of skeletal muscle in response to hindlimb unweighting.
D. Allen (1997)
Differential global gene expression in red and white skeletal muscle.
W. H. Campbell (2001)
Invited Review: contractile activity-induced mitochondrial biogenesis in skeletal muscle.
D. Hood (2001)
Lung growth in response to unilateral pneumonectomy in rapidly growing rats.
C. Watkins (1985)
Quantification using real-time PCR technology: applications and limitations.
D. Klein (2002)
A reliability test of standard-based quantitative PCR: exogenous vs endogenous standards.
L. D. Ke (2000)
Effects of one bout of endurance exercise on the expression of myogenin in human quadriceps muscle
F. Kadi (2004)
Messenger RNA regulation during compensatory renal growth.
A. Ouellette (1983)
Concomitant increases in myonuclear and satellite cell content in female trapezius muscle following strength training
F. Kadi (2000)
Statistical Adjustment of Signal Censoring in Gene Expression Experiments
E. Wit (2003)
Effects of aging on human skeletal muscle myosin heavy-chain mRNA content and protein isoform expression.
J. O. Marx (2002)
Statistical modeling for selecting housekeeper genes
A. Szabó (2004)
DNA microarray experiments: biological and technological aspects.
D. Nguyen (2002)
Cellular mechanisms of tubule hypertrophy and hyperplasia in renal injury.
G. Wolf (1995)
Molecular basis of skeletal muscle plasticity--from gene to form and function.
M. Flück (2003)
The impact of recent stereological advances on quantitative studies of the nervous system
H. Brændgaard (1986)
A compendium of gene expression in normal human tissues.
L. L. Hsiao (2001)
Spotted long oligonucleotide arrays for human gene expression analysis.
Andrea J Barczak (2003)
Normalizing DNA microarray data.
M. Bilban (2002)
Transcriptional reprogramming and ultrastructure during atrophy and recovery of mouse soleus muscle.
C. Däpp (2004)
A muscle precursor cell-dependent pathway contributes to muscle growth after atrophy.
P. O. Mitchell (2001)
Molecular and Cell Biology of Skin Wound Healing in a Pig Model
J. Wang (2000)
Getting the Noise Out of Gene Arrays
E. Marshall (2004)
Systematic analysis of T7 RNA polymerase based in vitro linear RNA amplification for use in microarray experiments
J. Schneider (2003)
Expression of fos and jun genes in human skeletal muscle after exercise.
A. Puntschart (1998)
Patterns of gene expression in atrophying skeletal muscles: response to food deprivation
R. T. Jagoe (2002)
Stretch-induced growth in chicken wing muscles: biochemical and morphological characterization.
J. Barnett (1980)
Quantification of MyoD, myogenin, MRF4 and Id-1 by reverse-transcriptase polymerase chain reaction in rat muscles--effects of hypothyroidism and chronic low-frequency stimulation.
B. Kraus (1997)
Gene expression profile analysis by DNA microarrays: promise and pitfalls.
H. King (2001)
New molecular research technologies in the study of muscle disease
E. Hoffman (2003)
Microarray, SAGE and their applications to cardiovascular diseases
Shui Qing Ye (2002)
Identification and removal of contaminating fluorescence from commercial and in-house printed DNA microarrays.
M. Martinez (2003)
Regenerated mdx mouse skeletal muscle shows differential mRNA expression.
B. Tseng (2002)
Project normal: Defining normal variance in mouse gene expression
C. Pritchard (2001)
Exercise-enhanced satellite cell proliferation and new myonuclear accretion in rat skeletal muscle.
H. Smith (2001)
On the association of reverse transcriptase with polynucleotide templates during catalysis.
D. Dube (1976)
Turnover of muscle protein in the fowl. Changes in rates of protein synthesis and breakdown during hypertrophy of the anterior and posterior latissimus dorsi muscles.
G. Laurent (1978)
Elevated interstitial fluid volume in rat soleus muscles by hindlimb unweighting.
S. Kandarian (1991)
Microarray data normalization and transformation
John Quackenbush (2002)
Stimulation of myofibrillar synthesis by exercise is mediated by more efficient translation of mRNA.
S. Welle (1999)
Amplification protocols introduce systematic but reproducible errors into gene expression studies.
C. Wilson (2004)
Further defining housekeeping, or "maintenance," genes Focus on "A compendium of gene expression in normal human tissues".
A. Butte (2001)
Compensatory growth of the lung following partial pneumonectomy.
D. Rannels (1988)
Gene expression following acute morphine administration.
A. Loguinov (2001)
Characterization of variability in large-scale gene expression data: implications for study design.
J. P. Novak (2002)
Selection and validation of endogenous reference genes using a high throughput approach
P. Jin (2004)
Normalization of cDNA microarray data.
G. Smyth (2003)
Pre - steady - state kinetic characterization of RNAprimed initiation of transcription by HIV - 1 reverse transcriptase and analysis of the transition to a processive DNAprimed polymerization mode
SH Thrall (1998)
Minimum information about a microarray experiment (MIAME)—toward standards for microarray data
A. Brazma (2001)
Differential response of macrophage subpopulations to soleus muscle reloading after rat hindlimb suspension.
B. S. St Pierre (1994)
Differential regulation of actin and myosin isoenzyme synthesis in functionally overloaded skeletal muscle.
P. Gregory (1990)
This paper is referenced by
Effects of Sample Size on Differential Gene Expression, Rank Order and Prediction Accuracy of a Gene Signature
C. Stretch (2013)
Heat shock protein translocation and expression response is attenuated in response to repeated eccentric exercise
K. Vissing (2009)
Unraveling the molecular underpinning of nature and nurture of aerobic fitness.
M. Flück (2008)
Quantification by real-time PCR of developmental and adult myosin mRNA in rat muscles.
H. Sanchez (2006)
Fine needle aspiration coupled with real-time PCR: a painless methodology to study adaptive functional changes in skeletal muscle.
M. Guescini (2007)
Low load endurance activity and green tea extract represent potential therapies for Duchenne muscular dystrophy
J. Call (2007)
ADAPTAÇÕES MUSCULARES AO TREINAMENTO DE FORÇA COM SOBRECARGAS EXCÊNTRICAS
B. Ide (2010)
Gene expression profiling of the uterus with embryos cloned by somatic cell nuclear transfer on day 30 of pregnancy.
H. Ka (2008)
Multilevel modeling in human microarray time course gene expression data
Mostafa Ghaderi-Zefrehei (2010)
A hypoxia complement differentiates the muscle response to endurance exercise
Silvia Schmutz (2010)
Select Skeletal Muscle mRNAs Related to Exercise Adaptation Are Minimally Affected by Different Pre-exercise Meals that Differ in Macronutrient Profile
Pim Knuiman (2018)
Treinamento de força versus treinamento de endurance: Existe compatibilidade?
B. Ide (2010)
Muscling in on microarrays.
C. Virtanen (2008)
Muscle unloading potentiates the effects of acetyl‐L‐carnitine on the slow oxidative muscle phenotype
P. Cassano (2010)
Effects of concentric and repeated eccentric exercise on muscle damage and calpain–calpastatin gene expression in human skeletal muscle
K. Vissing (2008)
Repeatability of exercise‐induced changes in mRNA expression and technical considerations for qPCR analysis in human skeletal muscle
H. Islam (2019)
Indicator of Ischemia Syndrome and Reperfusion in Resisted Training
Phillipi Leme Dias (2018)
STUDIES IN SPORT, PHYSICAL EDUCATION AND HEALTH 115
J. Ahtiainen (2006)
Constitutive upregulations of titin-based signalling proteins in KY deficient muscles
Jane Beatham (2006)
Functional, structural and molecular plasticity of mammalian skeletal muscle in response to exercise stimuli
M. Flück (2006)
A mixed-effects model of the dynamic response of muscle gene transcript expression to endurance exercise
T. Busso (2012)
Novel design and controls for focused DNA microarrays: applications in quality assurance/control and normalization for the Health Canada ToxArray™
C. Yauk (2005)
Monitoring Athletes' Physiological Responses to Endurance Training with Genomic-wide Expression Data
I. Chen (2007)
Identification of reference genes suitable for qRT-PCR in grapevine and application for the study of the expression of genes involved in pterostilbene synthesis
Magdalena Gamm (2011)
Smoothelin-like 1 Protein Regulates Myosin Phosphatase-targeting Subunit 1 Expression during Sexual Development and Pregnancy*
Beáta Lontay (2010)
RNA biomarkers in colorectal cancer.
S. Bustin (2013)
DNA Genome-based Diagnostics for Athletes ’ Physiological Conditions Using Cluster Analysis
L. Tseng (2003)
Global gene expression in skeletal muscle from well-trained strength and endurance athletes.
N. Stepto (2009)
Tuning of mitochondrial pathways by muscle work: from triggers to sensors and expression signatures.
M. Flück (2009)
Muscle transcriptome adaptations with mild eccentric ergometer exercise
S. Klossner (2007)
Effect of intermittent hypoxic training on HIF gene expression in human skeletal muscle and leukocytes
R. Mounier (2008)
Molecular Modifications Induced by Physical Exercise: A Significant Role in Disease Prevention
M. Guescini (2007)See more