Online citations, reference lists, and bibliographies.
← Back to Search

Transnasal Odontoid Resection: Is There An Anatomic Explanation For Differing Swallowing Outcomes?

Kathryn M Van Abel, Grant W. Mallory, J. Kasperbauer, M. D., E. Moore, D. Price, E. O'Brien, K. D. Olsen, W. Krauss, M. Clarke, M. Jentoft, J. V. Van Gompel
Published 2014 · Medicine

Cite This
Download PDF
Analyze on Scholarcy
OBJECT Swallowing dysfunction is common following transoral (TO) odontoidectomy. Preliminary experience with newer endoscopic transnasal (TN) approaches suggests that dysphagia may be reduced with this alternative. However, the reasons for this are unclear. The authors hypothesized that the TN approach results in less disruption of the pharyngeal plexus and anatomical structures associated with swallowing. The authors investigate the histological and gross surgical anatomical relationship between pharyngeal plexus innervation of the upper aerodigestive tract and the surgical approaches used (TN and TO). They also review the TN literature to evaluate swallowing outcomes following this approach. METHODS Seven cadaveric specimens were used for histological (n = 3) and gross anatomical (n = 4) examination of the pharyngeal plexus with the TO and TN surgical approaches. Particular attention was given to identifying the location of cranial nerves (CNs) IX and X and the sympathetic chain and their contributions to the pharyngeal plexus. S100 staining was performed to assess for the presence of neural tissue in proximity to the midline, and fiber density counts were performed within 1 cm of midline. The relationship between the pharyngeal plexus, clivus, and upper cervical spine (C1-3) was defined. RESULTS Histological analysis revealed the presence of pharyngeal plexus fibers in the midline and a significant reduction in paramedian fiber density from C-2 to the lower clivus (p < 0.001). None of these paramedian fibers, however, could be visualized with gross inspection or layer-by-layer dissection. Laterally based primary pharyngeal plexus nerves were identified by tracing their origins from CNs IX and X and the sympathetic chain at the skull base and following them to the pharyngeal musculature. In addition, the authors found 15 studies presenting 52 patients undergoing TN odontoidectomy. Of these patients, only 48 had been swallowing preoperatively. When looking only at this population, 83% (40 of 48) were swallowing by Day 3 and 92% (44 of 48) were swallowing by Day 7. CONCLUSIONS Despite the midline approach, both TO and TN approaches may injure a portion of the pharyngeal plexus. By limiting the TN incision to above the palatal plane, the surgeon avoids the high-density neural plexus found in the oropharyngeal wall and limits injury to oropharyngeal musculature involved in swallowing. This may explain the decreased incidence of postoperative dysphagia seen in TN approaches. However, further clinical investigation is warranted.
This paper references
Cystic deterioration of the C 1 – 2 articulation : clinical implications and treatment outcomes . Clinical article
JJ VanGompel (2011)
Oropharyngeal Dysphagia after Anterior Cervical Spine Surgery: A Review
K. K. Anderson (2013)
Endoscopic transnasal resection of the odontoid: case series and clinical course
J. Gempt (2010)
Surgical anatomy of human soft palate
J. H. Cho (2013)
Endoscopic Endonasal Odontoidectomy: Clinical Series
D. Mazzatenta (2014)
Endoscopic transoral excision of odontoid process in irreducible atlantoaxial dislocation: our experience of 34 patients.
Y. Yadav (2013)
Transnasal endoscopic approach to the pediatric craniovertebral junction and rostral cervical spine: case series and literature review.
Z. Hickman (2013)
Endoscopic transnasal transclival odontoidectomy: a new approach to decompression: technical case report.
J. Wu (2008)
Videofluoroscopic eval ­ uation of oropharyngeal swallowing
TA Goldsmith
Incidence of Dysphagia After Anterior Cervical Spine Surgery: A Prospective Study
Rajesh Bazaz (2002)
Endoscopic endonasal odontoidectomy with anterior C1 arch preservation in elderly patients affected by rheumatoid arthritis.
M. Iacoangeli (2013)
Fetal anatomy of the upper pharyngeal muscles with special reference to the nerve supply: is it an enteric plexus or simply an intramuscular nerve?
S. Abe (2013)
Dysphagia Following Cervical Spine Surgery With Anterior Instrumentation: Evidence From Fluoroscopic Swallow Studies
R. Leonard (2011)
Transnasal Endoscopic Odontoidectomy
R. Kania (2010)
An Endoscopic Transnasal Odontoidectomy to Treat Cervicomedullary Compression with Basilar Invagination
A. Kassam (2005)
Transnasal odontoid resection followed by posterior decompression and occipitocervical fusion in children with Chiari malformation Type I and ventral brainstem compression.
T. Hankinson (2010)
W. Hollinshead (1968)
Neuromuscular Specializations within Human Pharyngeal Constrictor Muscles
L. Mu (2007)
The Sensory Innervation of the Human Pharynx: Searching for Mechanoreceptors
F. Carlos (2013)
Videofluoroscopic Evaluation of Oropharyngeal Swallowing
T. Goldsmith (2011)
Endonasal Endoscopic Resection of an Os Odontoideum to Decompress the Cervicomedullary Junction: A Minimal Access Surgical Technique
L. Leng (2009)
Endoscopic transnasal odontoid resection to decompress the bulbo-medullary junction: a reliable anterior minimally invasive technique without posterior fusion
M. Gladi (2012)
Experience with intraoperative navigation and imaging during endoscopic transnasal spinal approaches to the foramen magnum and odontoid.
O. Choudhri (2014)
Cystic deterioration of the C1-2 articulation: clinical implications and treatment outcomes.
J. V. Van Gompel (2011)
Validity and Reliability of the Eating Assessment Tool (EAT-10)
P. Belafsky (2008)
Experience with the Expanded Endonasal Approach for Resection of the Odontoid Process in Rheumatoid Disease
J. Nayak (2007)
Sensory nerve supply of the human oro‐ and laryngopharynx: A preliminary study
L. Mu (2000)
Endonasal endoscopic resection of the odontoid process in a nonachondroplastic dwarf with juvenile rheumatoid arthritis: feasibility of the approach and utility of the intraoperative Iso-C three-dimensional navigation. Case report.
I. Laufer (2008)
Endoscopic transnasal odontoidectomy to treat basilar invagination with congenital osseous malformations
Y. Yu (2012)
The Expanded Endonasal Approach: A Fully Endoscopic Transnasal Approach and Resection of the Odontoid Process: Technical Case Report
A. Kassam (2005)
Early dysphagia complicating anterior cervical spine surgery: incidence and risk factors
Ji-Huan Zeng (2013)
The Endoscopic Endonasal Approach to the Odontoid and Its Impact on Early Extubation and Feeding
T. Schwartz (2014)

This paper is referenced by
Indications for Craniocervical Surgery and Anterior Resection Techniques (Endonasal, Transoral)
J. Gempt (2019)
Complications of transoral and transnasal odontoidectomy: a comprehensive review
R. Tubbs (2015)
Walk the Line. The Surgical Highways to the Craniovertebral Junction in Endoscopic Approaches: A Historical Perspective.
M. Visocchi (2018)
[Endoscopic endonasal removal of the invaginated odontoid process of the C2 vertebra].
A. Shkarubo (2015)
The rise and fall of the craniocervical junction relative to the hard palate: a lifetime story.
Grant W. Mallory (2016)
Nuances of Microsurgical and Endoscope Assisted Surgical Techniques to the Cranio-Vertebral Junction: Review of the Literature
V. Massimiliano (2017)
Chordoma and chondrosarcoma.
J. V. Van Gompel (2015)
Transoral Robotic Surgery (TORS)—Inside Out Anatomy and Exposure of the Operating Field
Linda X. Yin (2019)
Endoscopic endonasal odontoid resection with real-time intraoperative image-guided computed tomography: report of 4 cases.
H. Singh (2018)
Anterior release without odontoidectomy for irreducible atlantoaxial dislocation: transoral or endoscopic transnasal?
Chunke Dong (2020)
Endoscopic endonasal transclival transodontoid approach for ventral decompression of the craniovertebral junction: operative technique and nuances.
J. Liu (2015)
II . Role Of Oropahryngeal And Nasopharyngeal Biota In Causing Infection At The Defect
Dr. V. Rajarajan (2015)
Direct and Oblique Approaches to the Craniovertebral Junction: Nuances of Microsurgical and Endoscope-Assisted Techniques Along with a Review of the Literature.
M. Visocchi (2017)
Endoscopic endonasal approach for craniovertebral junction pathology: a review of the literature.
S. F. Morales-Valero (2015)
Endoscopic Transnasal Odontoidectomy: A Novel Technique in Orthopedic Surgery
Scott J. B. Nimmons (2019)
Endoscopic Endonasal Odontoidectomy : Nuances of Neurosurgical Technique Odontoidectomia endoscópica endonasal : nuances da técnica cirúrgica
F. R. Romero (2018)
Эндоскопическое трансназальное удаление патологических процессов зубовидного отростка С2 позвонка
Alexey Nikolaevich Shkarubo (2019)
Endoscopic Endonasal Odontoidectomy: Nuances of Neurosurgical Technique
F. R. Romero (2018)
Endoscopic Endonasal Odontoidectomy.
M. Zoli (2015)
The rhinopalatine line as a reliable predictor of the inferior extent of endonasal odontoidectomies.
Emanuele La Corte (2015)
Semantic Scholar Logo Some data provided by SemanticScholar